Buccaneers–Panthers rivalry

Tampa Bay Buccaneers–Carolina Panthers
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Carolina Panthers
First meeting October 1, 1995
Tampa Bay 20, Carolina 13
Latest meeting October 10, 2016
Carolina 14, Tampa Bay 17
Next meeting January 1, 2017
Meetings total 31 meetings
All-time series Carolina leads 20–12
Largest victory Tampa Bay 16, Carolina 48
Current win streak Tampa Bay,1 win
Championship Success

Super Bowl Championships (1)

Conference Championships (2)

Division Championships (12)

The Buccaneers–Panthers rivalry is between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Carolina Panthers.[1][2][3][4]

The two teams met for the first time in 1995 when the Panthers were an expansion team.[5] In 2002, due to league-wide reorganization, the teams were moved into the newly formed NFC South division, and have played each other twice a year since then--once each at the Bucs' Raymond James Stadium in Tampa and the Panthers' Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte. The matchup immediately became popular, and by many accounts intensified into a heated rivalry starting in 2003.[2][6]

The two teams have yet to meet during the playoffs, and cannot play each other during the preseason under current NFL rules.

The annual games have been described by observers as "physical"[4] and numerous players have suffered season-ending injuries. Among the most serious was Chris Simms, who suffered a ruptured spleen in 2006 and Kavika Pittman who suffered a career-ending knee injury.[4] Return specialist Clifton Smith suffered concussions in both games in 2009,[4] the first from a high hit by Dante Wesley, who was subsequently ejected and suspended for one game.[7] In addition to hard-hitting play, considerable off-the-field squabbles and verbal skirmishes have provided bulletin board material, including a brouhaha between Brentson Buckner and Warren Sapp[1][2] as well as the arrest of two Panthers cheerleaders in a Tampa-area bar.[1][2][8]



Carolina joined the league as an expansion team in 1995. For the first seven years of their existence, they were part of the NFC West division, while Tampa Bay was part of the NFC Central during that time. The two teams happened to play as intra-conference opponents in that first season in 1995. The Buccaneers won 20-13 after a QB sneak by back-up quarterback Casey Weldon in the fourth quarter. This game took place at Clemson, the Panthers temporary home during their first season.

The teams met again the following season (1996), with Carolina prevailing 24-0. It was the only shutout in the series' history, on the way to Carolina's first appearance in the NFC Championship Game. It was also the first meeting at the newly constructed Ericsson Stadium.

The two teams would never meet at Tampa Stadium before it was demolished.

In 1998, the two teams met one additional time prior to being placed in the same division. Tampa Bay won 16-13 at Raymond James Stadium, the third-ever game at the Buccaneers new facility. Trailing 13-3, Trent Dilfer led the Buccaneers on two touchdown drives late in the fourth quarter to take the lead. Panthers kicker John Kasay had an opportunity to tie the score with ten seconds left in regulation, but his 47-yard field goal attempt sailed wide left.


In 2002, due to league-wide reorganization, Carolina and Tampa Bay were placed into the newly formed NFC South division. They became division foes, and would begin an annual two-game, home/away series each season. In 2002, Tampa Bay swept the regular season series en route to their Super Bowl victory. The first meeting, at Charlotte, was a defensive struggle, with neither team scoring a touchdown. Tampa Bay quarterback Brad Johnson was out with an injury, and Rob Johnson started in his place. Martín Gramática made four field goals, including the game-winning kick with 5 seconds left in regulation. Tampa Bay won 12-9.

The second meeting, at Tampa, was a highly anticipated defensive struggle - Tampa Bay entered the game ranked #1 in total defense, while Carolina ranked #3. It also saw the return of quarterbacks Brad Johnson and Rodney Peete, both on whom had sat out the last meeting between the two. However, Tampa Bay won a largely one-sided contest. The Buccaneers racked up 314 yards of offense, forced four turnovers, and sacked Peete four times. The Buccaneers won by a score of 23-10, improving to 8-2 on the season, a franchise record after ten games.[9]

Between the two games, a feud developed between Panthers punter Todd Sauerbrun and Buccaneers kicker Martín Gramática.[10] Sauerbrun took exception with Gramática's emotional celebrations during their first meeting, and later alleged that his youngest brother (Santiago) heckled him after the second game.[11] Sauerbrun called all three Gramática brothers (Martín, Bill, and Santiago) "idiots"[10] while Martín had to be restrained from attacking him.[11] Years later, the rift still remained, as Sauerbrun called the brothers "fucking greaseballs"[11] and vetoed a chance for Bill to join the Panthers. Martín has countered by stating "one hundred percent of the people that know [Sauerbrun] don't like him,"[6] and stated that if they were both chosen for the Pro Bowl, he would not participate if Sauerbrun was to be his holder.[10]


During training camp in the summer of 2003, Panthers defensive tackle Brentson Buckner created a stir when he argued that his teammate Kris Jenkins was better than Tampa Bay's Warren Sapp.[12] The trash-talk ensued as Sapp responded by stating "I don't think Brentson Buckner has any pineapple in his diet"[12] (a reference to the Pro Bowl). Tampa Bay was coming off their Super Bowl season, while Carolina missed the playoffs in 2002 at 7-9.

The defending Super Bowl champion Buccaneers hosted Carolina in their home opener in week two. The game turned into an embarrassment for Tampa Bay, and marked the point at which the rivalry firmly established and began to intensify. A defensive-oriented game saw young Carolina quarterback Jake Delhomme held to only 9-for-23, 96 yards and two interceptions. Meanwhile, Brad Johnson threw for 339 yards. Special teams breakdowns cost the Buccaneers dearly. After two earlier botched field goal attempts, the Buccaneers trailed 9-3 late in the fourth quarter. On the last play of regulation, Brad Johnson connected to Keenan McCardell for a dramatic game-tying touchdown pass in the back of the endzone time expired. The extra point would have given Tampa Bay the win. Martin Gramatica's extra point attempt, however, was blocked. The game went to overtime tied 9-9. Both teams traded possessions, and with just over 6 minutes left in the overtime period, Tampa Bay punted to Carolina. Steve Smith returned the punt 52 yards to the Tampa Bay 40-yard line. Five plays later, Carolina won 12-9 after a 47-yard field goal.

In week 10 of the 2003 season, the surging Panthers hosted the now-sputtering Buccaneers. Carolina broke out to a 20-7 lead through three quarters, but the Buccaneers rallied in the fourth quarter for 17 points. Tampa Bay took a 24-20 lead with 2:45 to go. The Buccaneer defense, however, failed to keep Carolina at bay, and Jake Delhomme swiftly led the Panthers to a game-winning touchdown with 1:11 left. Carolina, nicknamed the "Cardiac Cats" that season, swept the season series for the first time, en route to their first Super Bowl appearance.


Tampa Bay hosting Carolina on November 6, 2005

Both Carolina and Tampa Bay were playoff contenders in 2005, and battled neck-and-neck all season for the NFC South division title. The first meeting on November 6 at Raymond James Stadium saw both teams enter at 5-2, and in a tie for first place in the division. The Panthers intercepted Chris Simms twice, one returned for a touchdown, and Carolina rolled 34-14. It was Carolina's fifth straight victory against Tampa Bay, the longest winning streak between the two teams in the series' history.

Off the field, a scandal involving two Panthers cheerleaders made headlines around the league. Angela Ellen Keathley and Renee Thomas, both members of the Carolina Topcats, were arrested[1][2][8] the night before the game for allegedly having sex with each other in a bar in the Channel District of Downtown Tampa, Florida. Both were intoxicated,[13] and had a subsequent run-in with police.[8] Both were dismissed from the squad November 7 for violating the team's code of conduct.

On December 11, Tampa Bay and Carolina faced each other again, with the division title effectively on the line. Tampa Bay broke a five-game losing streak to Carolina, winning by a score of 20-10. With 11:47 remaining in the fourth quarter, Ronde Barber intercepted Jake Delhomme, which set up a game-icing touchdown by Carnell Williams.


President George W. Bush visiting the Bucs at practice before their 2006 game against the Panthers

Neither team made the playoffs in 2006, however, the first meeting between the two teams on September 24 is remembered for the injury to Chris Simms. Both teams entered at 0-2, and the game turned into a hard-hitting, physical contest in hot, humid conditions.

Late in the third quarter, Tampa Bay quarterback Chris Simms was leading the Buccaneers on a drive when he was hit on a two-yard bootleg play. He had to momentarily leave the game, and Bruce Gradkowski took over. Initially diagnosed as bruised ribs, Simms returned minutes later to lead a go-ahead field goal drive. Simms received several other vicious hits that likely aggravated his condition. Carolina got the ball back with less than two minutes left. With only six seconds left in regulation, Panthers kicker John Kasay kicked a game-winning field goal, and Carolina won 26-24.

After the game, Simms complained of ongoing pain, and was admitted to the hospital. It was discovered that he had suffered a ruptured spleen, was experiencing internal bleeding, and required immediate emergency surgery.[14] Had the injury not been diagnosed in a timely manner, it could have been fatal. Simms was placed on injured reserve, and ultimately never played another down with the Buccaneers.


The Panthers and Buccaneers split the season series in 2007. During the first meeting, Tampa Bay running back Carnell "Cadillac" Williams suffered a season-ending injury, a torn patellar tendon.


In the 2008 season, Tampa Bay rolled at home during the first meeting by a score of 27-3. Both teams, however, emerged later in the season as playoff contenders, and both improved to 9-3 by December.

The second meeting was at Carolina on December 8, on Monday Night Football. With both teams in a tie for first place in the division, as well as positioning themselves for a possible first-round bye during the postseason, the game had a "playoff atmosphere."

The game turned Carolina's way early, and despite a Bucs rally, the Panthers won convincingly. Carolina steamrolled the Buccaneers defense with 299-yard rushing, and essentially clinched the NFC South division with the victory. The loss started Tampa Bay on a downhill spiral, and the Buccaneers dropped the next three games as well. Tampa Bay fell to 9-7 and missed the playoffs. Shortly thereafter, head coach Jon Gruden was fired. Carolina improved to 12-4 and won the division, but were knocked out of the playoffs in the divisional round by Arizona. It was the beginning of the end of the Jake Delhomme era in Charlotte.


On October 18, Panthers defender Dante Wesley launched himself (leaving his feet) into punt returner Clifton Smith, who had signaled for a fair catch[15] and had not yet received the ball. Wesley was assessed a 15-yard penalty and ejected.[15][16] referee John Parry explained the offense as "unnecessary roughness that was also a personal foul." Smith was knocked out and lay motionless on the field for a brief time. He sustained a concussion and an injured throat and sat out the remainder of the game.[15]

A melee between the players immediately ensued out on the field, but was quickly broken up by officials. Two days later, the NFL suspended Wesley for one game without pay. Smith suffered a second concussion in the second meeting between the two teams (December 6), and was placed on injured reserve.[17][18]


In 2011, Carolina, behind rookie Cam Newton, swept the series in dominating fashion. In the first meeting, Tampa Bay wore their orange throwback uniforms, but were without Josh Freeman due to injury. The Panthers rolled 38-19, with Newton setting a single-season NFL record for rushing touchdowns by a quarterback.[19] Three weeks later, Newton set the NFL rookie passing yards record,[20] also against Tampa Bay, routing the Buccaneers 48-16.


In 2012, Tampa Bay rebounded to sweep the season series. The two teams met on opening day for the first time, with the Buccaneers prevailing 16-10. Tampa Bay held the Panthers and Cam Newton to only 10 yards rushing.

In Week 11, the two teams met again in another close game, one of Tampa Bay's most impressive comebacks in recent history. The Panthers led 21-10 with just over four minutes left in regulation. A field goal by Tampa Bay trimmed the lead to 21-13. The Buccaneers got the ball back with 1:02 left in the fourth quarter. Josh Freeman drove the Buccaneers 80 yards for a touchdown with 20 seconds to go. The two-point conversion tied the game at 21, sending it to overtime. Tampa Bay won the coin toss, and proceeded to score an 80-yard touchdown drive on the first possession, winning 27-21.


The Panthers swept the Buccaneers in 2013, 2014, and 2015. In 2015, Carolina won both meetings en route to their appearance in Super Bowl 50. In week 17, Carolina's 38-10 victory gave them a franchise-best 15-1 regular season record. A few days after the game, Buccaneers head coach Lovie Smith was dismissed.


Tampa Bay snapped Carolina's six game winning streak in the series, as the two clubs met on Monday Night Football. With Cam Newton sidelined due to concussion protocol, Derek Anderson started for Carolina. Anderson threw two interceptions and lost one fumble. With the game tied 14-14, Tampa Bay drove to the Panthers 20 yard line in the final minute. After missing two attempts earlier in the game, Roberto Aguayo kicked a 38-yard game-winning field goal as time expired.

Game results

Regular season results

Carolina leads the series 20-12

Season Day Date Visiting team Home team Site
1995SundayOctober 1 Buccaneers 20Panthers 13Memorial Stadium
1996SundayDecember 1 Buccaneers 0Panthers 24Ericsson Stadium
1998SundayOctober 18 Panthers 13 Buccaneers 16 Raymond James Stadium
2002SundayOctober 27 Buccaneers 12Panthers 9Ericsson Stadium
SundayNovember 17Panthers 10 Buccaneers 23 Raymond James Stadium
2003SundaySeptember 14Panthers 12 (OT) Buccaneers 9 Raymond James Stadium
SundayNovember 9Buccaneers 24Panthers 27Ericsson Stadium
2004SundayNovember 28Buccaneers 14Panthers 21Bank of America Stadium
SundayDecember 26Panthers 37 Buccaneers 20 Raymond James Stadium
2005SundayNovember 6Panthers 34 Buccaneers 14 Raymond James Stadium
SundayDecember 11Buccaneers 20Panthers 10Bank of America Stadium
2006SundaySeptember 24Panthers 26 Buccaneers 24 Raymond James Stadium
MondayNovember 13Buccaneers 10Panthers 24Bank of America Stadium
2007SundaySeptember 30Buccaneers 20Panthers 7Bank of America Stadium
SundayDecember 30Panthers 31 Buccaneers 23 Raymond James Stadium
2008SundayOctober 12Panthers 3 Buccaneers 27 Raymond James Stadium
MondayDecember 8Buccaneers 23Panthers 38Bank of America Stadium
2009SundayOctober 18Panthers 28 Buccaneers 21 Raymond James Stadium
SundayDecember 6Buccaneers 6Panthers 16Bank of America Stadium
2010SundaySeptember 19Buccaneers 20Panthers 7Bank of America Stadium
SundayNovember 14Panthers 16 Buccaneers 31 Raymond James Stadium
2011SundayDecember 4Panthers 38 Buccaneers 19 Raymond James Stadium
SundayDecember 24Buccaneers 16Panthers 48Bank of America Stadium
2012SundaySeptember 9Panthers 10 Buccaneers 16Raymond James Stadium
SundayNovember 18Buccaneers 27 (OT)Panthers 21Bank of America Stadium
2013ThursdayOctober 24Panthers 31 Buccaneers 13Raymond James Stadium
SundayDecember 1Buccaneers 6 Panthers 27 Bank of America Stadium
2014SundaySeptember 7Panthers 20 Buccaneers 14Raymond James Stadium
SundayDecember 14Buccaneers 17 Panthers 19 Bank of America Stadium
2015SundayOctober 4Panthers 37 Buccaneers 23Raymond James Stadium
SundayJanuary 3Buccaneers 10Panthers 38Bank of America Stadium
2016MondayOctober 10Buccaneers 17 Panthers 14 Bank of America Stadium
SundayJanuary 1Panthers Buccaneers Raymond James Stadium


The series is generally a back-and-forth contest, with respective winning streaks by one team common. Carolina holds an edge in total victories (20-12) and also holding the longest winning streak (6 games). The visiting team has a 16-15 record, and the two teams have gone to overtime twice, with the visiting team winning both instances.

The rivalry is often headlined as a defensive struggle. Both franchises have finished in the top ten in total defense multiple times, and four times (1996, 2002, 2003, 2005) both teams finished in the top ten in the same year. However, despite several defensive-oriented games, the series has seen its share of high-scoring, high offense, outputs.

Both Carolina and Tampa Bay have managed to sweep their opponent on multiple occasions. Carolina has swept Tampa Bay seven times (2003, 2004, 2006, 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2015). Tampa Bay has swept Carolina three times (2002, 2010, 2012).

The two clubs have met on Monday night three times, all three of were held at Bank of America Stadium. The first such instance (2006) saw former Buccaneer wide receiver Keyshawn Johnson facing his former teammates. In that game, Johnson became the first player in NFL history to score a touchdown on Monday Night Football with four different clubs (Jets, Buccaneers, Cowboys and Panthers). The two teams faced each other on Thursday night for the first time in 2013, with Carolina routing a winless Buccaneers team.

The two franchises made their first respective Super Bowl appearances in consecutive seasons. Tampa Bay went to Super Bowl XXXVII (2002) and Carolina went to Super Bowl XXXVIII (2003). Carolina returned to the Super Bowl (50) in 2015. Tampa Bay won their lone Super Bowl appearance, while Carolina lost both of their appearances. The teams swept their rival in all of their respective Super Bowl seasons.

The two franchises have never met in the preseason. Following current NFL precedent, two teams from the same division do not play one another during the exhibition season, rendering a future exhibition meeting unlikely. Despite their geographical proximity, from 1995 to 2001 (when the two teams were not in the same division), they still never were scheduled to play during the preseason.

See also



  1. 1 2 3 4 Scott, David (2008-10-10). "Panthers, Bucs have flourishing rivalry". The Charlotte Observer. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Yasinskas, Pat (2008-09-11). "NFC South's most intense rivalry: Panthers vs. Bucs". NFC South Blog. ESPN.com. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  3. Goodall, Fred (2008-10-09). "Panthers-Buccaneers becoming heated rivalry". USA Today. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Richardson, Anwar (2010-09-17). "Bucs, Panthers renew heated NFC South rivalry Sunday". Tampa Bay Online. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  5. "On the RJS Docket: Previewing the Bucs 2012 Home Slate". Buccaneers.com. 2012-07-06. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  6. 1 2 Cranston, Mike (2006-11-13). "Bucs, Panthers Have Wild History". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2012-00-13. Check date values in: |access-date= (help)
  7. "Wesley tossed; Smith has concussion". ESPN.com. 2009-10-18. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  8. 1 2 3 "Two Panthers cheerleaders dismissed". ESPN.com. 2005-11-08. Retrieved 2012-11-27.
  9. "Bucs 23 Panthers 10". BucPower. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
  10. 1 2 3 "Punter vs. kicker: A feud with legs". Philly.com. 2002-11-22. Retrieved 2012-12-13.
  11. 1 2 3 "Knee Jerk Reactions". Sports Illustrated. 2004-11-29. Retrieved 2012-12-12.
  12. 1 2 "Sapp and Buckner shutting up in advance of showdown". The Augusta Chronicle. 2003-09-11. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
  13. "Top Five Cheerleading Scandals Of All Time". Bleacher Report. 2010-06-15. Retrieved 2012-07-16.
  14. Stroud, Rick (2006-09-26). "Gruden: We didn't know". BucPower.com. The St. Petersburg Times. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
  15. 1 2 3 "Wesley tossed; Smith has concussion". ESPN.com. 2009-10-18. Retrieved 2012-11-30.
  16. "Dante Wesley's hit on Clifton Smith Video". 2009-10-18.
  17. Holder, Stephen (2010-12-08). "Second concussion may end season of Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Clifton Smith". St. Pete Times. Retrieved 2012-11-30.
  18. Smith, Joe (2010-06-10). "Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Clifton Smith won't let concussions hold him back". St. Pete Times. Retrieved 2012-11-30.
  19. "Cam Newton rushes for three TDs, sets QB record as Panthers crush Bucs". ESPN.com. 2011-12-04. Retrieved 2012-11-00. Check date values in: |access-date= (help)
  20. "Cam Newton tops Peyton Manning's rookie record for yards passing". L.A. Time. 2011-12-24. Retrieved 2012-11-30.

Works cited

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 11/6/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.