SHE LET GO OF MY HAND
A father's memoir of his divorce journey

A heart-wrenching story that resonates with everyone
who has ever experienced a loving partnership.

"It has been painful to realize that John is a CAT
who tried to be a DOG all these years,
but in the end, he is a cat and will always be.
I do not want him to be anything more than who he is.
He has tried to be a dog because a dog is what I want,
but alas, he can only be who he is.”
~ Veeby QUOTE ~

Queen Veeby proclaims her husband, John…is a CAT.

Her Highness really prefers a DOG. Adorned with shaming pendants, John's collar merely reflects projections from her royal crown. They dance the stately Silent Treatment Tango until her screams of discontent drown out the music. Thus, she abruptly ends their dance and commences the Game of Divorce.

hero

SPACER

READ the book

Calm

We travel our life journey in a small boat…just the right size for her and I Too many times, we’ve experienced rough seas 17 foot waves often try to veer us off course… The wake of other ships seems intent on tossing us out of our little boat. The journey thus far has been to just try and hold on It’s easy to see interesting things on either side of the boat One or the other of us will lean over the edge to get a closer look This has only made the boat lopsided… Nearly capsizing us…way too often Sometimes, we see the huge waves coming at us We try to run from one side to the other…to balance ourselves Even after the waves have subsided, we continue running back and forth… It’s what we’ve gotten use to doing to steady our boat This does nothing but continue to create waves WE create the waves by running back and forth In a vain attempt to stabilize the boat If, however, we remain calm… Seeing the waves and other interesting things as mere distractions… If we remain calm and simply move together towards the middle of our boat We can stop creating unnecessary waves…and Little by little the boat will rock less and less If we lie together…quietly in the center The waves will eventually subside The little distractions will eventually float away on their own If we cling to each other...the other we’ve always enjoyed… And loved… The rough seas beneath will return… To calm…to love…to us

Prologue

The “Calm” in a relationship does not return when one passenger disembarks. Instead, a different “calm” eventually emerges—typically called the “aftermath.” My wife and partner of 33+ years—I’ll call her Veeby—gave up on our coupleship, got out of our boat and then proclaimed she had… “…washed up on a beach of love.” However, I believe she never made it to the shore. When Veeby got out of our boat and “let go of my hand,” she began to sink very fast into the watery depths of despair, fear, and eventually anger…which seems to remain her final resting place. She managed to tread water long enough to hurl floating debris [as bombs] back towards the boat, however. This created even more waves, purposefully trying to tip me out of the boat, all the while creating a wider gulf between us. I find myself agreeing with the character Gimli…
 from the Lord of the Rings Trilogy—who said: “Faithless is [she] that says farewell when the sea [road] darkens.” As you will read in the following pages, Veeby and I acknowledged our journey together would be long and difficult, but also joyful. Veeby chose to “get out” during troubled seas and has seemingly forgotten all the fun and wonderful times we had on board. Of course, we had many “less than wonderful times” as well, but I believe that would be a typical description of most marriage relationships. Since I consider myself a Reductionist, here’s how we got to this place: • I hurt her, • she hurt me, • we decided to divorce… …and then all hell broke loose. Of course, there’s a lot more to the story, but that’s the short version. Indeed, there are two sides to every coin, or story…and this is mine. I don’t normally write out my thoughts and feelings—it proved far too risky within the relationship to expose what I was really thinking and feeling. I always believed that if my diary or journal were ever found, the information would be used against me. Now, I write mostly for me…as a cathartic experience…but also to highlight the injustice that screams throughout the story. I write for our children—when they are ready to read the story—for further understanding about this turbulent time in their lives. I write for our friends and family who may have witnessed some of these events…but only saw one side of the coin at the time. I write for the roughly 60% of people that have experienced divorce trauma themselves…who may recognize some of the pain and injustice…who have learned from their experiences, survived and are hopefully now thriving. I also write to educate and gift empathy and gracious understanding to the remaining 40% of folks who have not gone through the trauma of divorce. I am trusting that Iyanla Vanzant’s wise words will come true: “When you stand and share your story in an empowering way, your story will heal you and your story will heal somebody else.” So, without further interruptions…other than Veeby’s voice in my head…I will tell you MY truth and experience in the divorce journey. Since I journaled during that time period, I trust these memories to be accurate. Additionally, I will reference many of the court documents and transcripts…plus many handwritten letters, cards, emails and texts. John

A Little Background

In the beginning, we were young and happy. Veeby and I met in high school, I “chased her until she caught me” as we liked to say, and then we grew up in life together. We married young and at our wedding, we purposefully did not use the “traditional vows”…instead, we each said the following: Before our friends, family and God, I stand here today committing my life to you. I choose you as my companion and friend through life. To share with and love with; to accept and respect. I commit my time and understanding; my loyalty and love. I promise to continue dreaming and working with you; to make our lives worth having lived. I choose to share my life with you. We publicly acknowledged we were on a journey together…by reading this during the ceremony: The way is long…Let us go together The way is difficult…Let us help each other The way is joyful…Let us share it The way is ours alone…Let us go in love The way opens before us…Let us begin. 15 years later, we used the same vows and reading at our Renewal of Vows Ceremony. We were very much in love and looking forward to our journey together. Veeby was happy. Within her early cards to me, she wrote: 1st Anniversary—My Dearest John, One year ago, we started on an adventure, and tomorrow—one year later—we’ll do the same! Let’s make it worth remembering! I love you—more than ever! 3rd Anniversary—My Dearest John, The last three years of my life have been “transforming.” That’s because when I met you, you loved me enough to allow me to change. You’ve allowed and helped me change, John. You taught me what it is to feel love and most importantly to give love. I’ve learned to love through you. For that I am forever in your debt. Let’s make the next three years as “transforming” as the last three! I love you! My Birthday—My Dearest John, My wish for your birthday is that you acknowledge the wonderful person that you are. You should let that wonderful person be known by others than just me! Thank you for sharing your life with me. 4th Anniversary—My Dearest John, Thank you for coming and staying in my life. You give my life the stability I’ve always needed—you are my rock! Thanks for loving me and letting me love you. Happy 4th Anniversary! With all my love, 5th Anniversary—I love you very much, John. I want our lives together to be filled with joy…for the way has been joyful—so let us share! Happy 5th! Much love… Valentine’s Day—John, I love you more and more as the years go by! Here’s to many many more years of love! Happy Valentine’s Day! My Birthday—Dear John, You grow more and more special to me as the years increase in our lives together. Happy 28th Birthday! I love you very much. 7th Anniversary—Dear John, Happy Anniversary—7 years! We have a lot of changes ahead of us—but I know our relationship is strong and can only grow from them. I love you very much. You get the idea. However…a darkness slowly entered our relationship, as evidenced within her writings: [cue the dramatic music: “Duh, Duh, Duh”] My Dearest John, I want to be able to undue [sic] all the hurt and cruel words I’ve caused and used—but apologies don’t seem to suffice. I want to be able to promise that I’ll never act or say such things again, but I know that I can’t promise that because I’d fail and I don’t want unbroken promises to be between us. I know that the biggest weapon I have to use against you is the threat of leaving you. I never want that to come about, but sometimes I fear that I’ll go through with it just to prove my point. I don’t want to be like my father—backed into a corner by his pride and going through with actions that only hurt all who are involved. You are a very wonderful human being, John—you are because I would have never married you if you weren’t. I know that I’m immature in many respects but about this I’m not—you care enough to love me and stick with me and that takes a lot of caring and goodness. I’m not an easy person to live with—I wish I could change—maybe I can but it would require your help. You’ve helped me already—so much! You’ve taught me to open up and be willing to love! Believe me when I say that I never want to hurt you—I hate myself when I’m hurting you—it’s just a vicious cycle that I don’t know how to stop. It’s very hard for me to forgive myself for causing you pain. I want to be good for you, John, but I really don’t know how. I say you’re selfish—and part of me believes that—but part of me knows that I’m accusing me, not you. I’m very selfish. I love you, John. And… John—I’m tired of saying I’m sorry—but I guess I am. Don’t cut me off—I need you to stay in there with me and let me be angry—it won’t get overwhelming and out of control—as long as I know you care and understand—I just want it to be the two of us, not just me. And… You have become an ugly man, John, both in body and soul. Lately, I wonder why I stick around. I will chose another person to be emotionally close to. I have always given you that part of me—but I won’t trust it to you anymore. Sometimes it amazes me that knowing that I’m vulnerable you continue to hurt me. You should be ashamed of your ugliness John, I am. And… John—I’ve been very angry at you for awhile now and it’s taken me some time to figure out why. The way I see it is this! You always get what you want—if I get what I want I hear from you over and over again how I either “manipulated” it out of you or “tricked” or “whined” or “nagged” or something to that effect. I’m never allowed to just want something and feel entitled to get it. When I do express my concern or disagreement with what you want to do, I’m painted as unsupportive. I’m sick and tired of this—I have a wealth of anger towards you about this. Lately, for the first time ever in our married lives, I’ve entertained thoughts of not being married to you. I know, that’s taboo with you, but it’s how serious I am about my feelings towards you. Lately everything you do irritates me and that’s because I have a lot of anger towards you and the anger comes from not able to feel like I can want certain things in my life without having to constantly justify them. I am tired of having to explain and justify my wants to you. Why is it assumed that your wants are more valid than mine? Don’t say they’re not because you act like they are. My wants are passed off as trivial—you are not the end all, be all. I’m tired of playing second fiddle to your wants and I’m angry. And… John—I behaved badly last night. I’m sorry! No excuses offered, just an apology! I love you. And… My anger flows—often at John—he’ll tap into it and out it comes—when it needs to have been directed at my father for his distance, at my mother for her complicity and need to protect my dad from my anger—her own anger. John and I entered into an unconscious dance—complicit in each others anger issues. But my passion for John got buried under fear—fear that I need him too much, depend on him too much—that he wouldn’t reciprocate. That I don’t love him as much as he loves me so that I won’t feel too vulnerable—find out he doesn’t love me. I resented [his work]—it caused me to pull away—to close my heart to him—to be cruel to him—cut him off, to be repelled and not want to be loving—tender—caressing—all the things he wanted—I didn’t want to feel them—because it left me scared that if I gave him that—he would just take and retreat to his world—his work—with my gift without me getting anything back—I would be left emptied, so I hoarded my love—which drove him further away. What a vicious cycle. Again, you get the idea. • • • • • In contrast to her verbosity, I never really felt safe enough to write out my feelings on paper. The few times I tried to keep a journal, it was “found” and was “discussed” between us. I clearly remember destroying my fledgling journal after that. So, I was surprised when many years later I discovered two pages from my handwritten journal entry I’d written in 1982…two years into our marriage…that I’d stuffed between the pages of a book and had miraculously survived: For the first time, I really feel like being away from Veeby. She makes me so mad; she’s rude to me; she’s always fighting; not a nice home life. Today, we’ve not talked all day long and have been avoiding each other as much as possible. I want to tell her to stay when she goes [to visit her family]. I really feel like divorcing. She says such mean things to me, I retreat more and more. If I divorce her, I could still live off my job and continue living. She’d be forced to go home, or find her own place [and have to work]. I wouldn’t mind leaving her here, and I’ll move elsewhere. She can keep everything. I might miss her being around, but I won’t miss her constant bickering…about how I drive [never correct]; My body odor and bad breath in the morning; how I can talk all I want, but I don’t love her like I used to; she never lets me finish a sentence! I don’t like talking with her. She’s always right; She never apologizes either. “The only thing keeping us together is that we are here together.” Fine, let’s split up! I’ll make it. Of course I’ll never be as mature as you, but hey, you can just go ahead and feel sorry for me and the pitiful existence I’ll end up living without you…Right! Sure! I think it’s time I’m by myself. I’ve always thought that I’d be by myself, but then loused it up by marrying Veeby. She’s just like her father, too! Divorce is scary; but it’s funny how Veeby keeps pushing me for it. Taunting me about it. I think the time has come. Will time pass and I’ll miss her and want her back? Yes and No. That was quite eye opening for me…to have found and reread those words written so very early in our marriage…yet, then finding myself still dealing with the very same issues and threats in the relationship 25 years later. Nothing had changed. Obviously, I saw the conflicts, then chose to bury them…and kept them buried for many years until their existence could no longer be contained. An argument could be made that except for the joy of bringing our children into the world through our union, it might have been better had I acted on my earlier instincts and gotten divorced. Due to my upbringing, however, I was not able to seriously consider such a possibility. My family of origin was very religious and conservative. That fundamental training had always cast a terribly negative connotation on divorce. Since we’d gotten married so young, I was still surrounded by all of that original “hard wiring” which dictated deferring within my relationship to keep the peace at all costs—to stay married no matter what. Indeed, we were biblically “yoked” together. Veeby and I discussed the concept quite often. She understood that dynamic within me and proceeded to beat me on the head with the constant threat of divorce if I did not conform to her wishes. Even though I ended up hurting her—and she also ended up hurting me—we still had many wonderful and loving moments and experiences together, not the least of which would be creating our three beautiful children. That being said, let me state for the record: Being married to a Financial Analyst…definitely had it’s drawbacks. During our years together, Veeby needed to discuss and “analyze” every emotional feeling she had with me, in which I dutifully participated. However, when I did not participate, I was accused of “not putting emotional energy into the marriage.” Her need to “over-process” every thought or feeling was something that never felt comfortable to me. Most of the time it just felt completely unnecessary. Eventually, her over-analyzing thread was reframed that “I was not in touch with my feelings and emotions”—which was not true for me. I simply did not share her need to verbally express my feelings as often. I felt that words were quite often very limiting. My feelings were best expressed through my music and my actions. Veeby often stated that she was the only one putting the time and emotional energy into “working on our marriage” but nothing could be further from the truth. While I never really felt safe to speak my truths, Veeby was continually frustrated that I thoughtfully put my words together a little slower than her. She talked faster and louder than me. I felt a lack of graciousness—and a lot of belittling—during those times she spoke “to me.” It was eventually framed that I was not as intelligent as her [obviously], with which I never agreed. Since I was a Southern-born boy, my words just came out more slowly—I actually took a breath between my sentences. Eventually, she would just complete my sentences for me, but at her faster speed. I would often remark that I knew what I was in the middle of saying, and that she would just need to let me finish my own sentences, thank you. It didn’t usually work out that way. Our “discussions” often amounted to her asking several questions at a time, then my trying to answer the first question, while she continued on to the next several questions. A most awkward circular dance was developed. • • • • • One of our main dance steps, however, was nothing more than a re-creation of dance steps Veeby observed within her family of origin. I regularly endured the wrath of Veeby, and it felt like she was always angry with me over “something.” When she was angry, she would typically lead us into the Silent Treatment Tango by withdrawing all communication with me for a day or two, sometimes more. Unfortunately, Veeby learned that dance from her father during her childhood—whenever he was displeased with her. Since I was her new [unwilling] Tango dance partner, she taught me those most uncomfortable dance moves. She withdrew and I pursued her—back and forth we danced for years! What had been her secret punitive behavior towards me during our marriage would soon become amplified within court records! Veeby also desired that I engage in political dialogue with her—to debate and argue current events: John, I wanted you to know that I truly enjoyed our time together 
[on vacation]. I think for the first time in our history we actually talked more about substantive things, even though it was a bit rocky. I’m glad you hung in there and didn’t shy away as in the past. It is important to me that we have that together. That I know what you think about things. I want to admire that about you. You know the other night when [actor] was on TV and he was speaking so eloquently about what he thought was important in political life, I realized that this is what I admire—someone who is well thought out and isn’t afraid to express it. Not be fanatical or extremist, but careful and thoughtful about well thought out issues. I want to have that with you. I think you do have thoughts and opinions but for reasons that I’m sure are partly my fault, you’ve kept that hidden from me. You don’t engage in meaningful discussions and sharing of your thoughts. I wanted you to know I enjoyed it when you did. It’s nice to share that way with you. Now, I really don’t care to be involved in politics or political debate…it simply doesn’t appeal to me. I hardly ever “shared” thoughts or feelings in that area since it usually became an argument. Within the debating of a topic, she would feel the need to convince me she was right and I was wrong…try to change my position. That was absolutely NOT FUN for me to participate in that type of activity. I eventually was able to “use my words” to tell her I didn’t feel “safe” in sharing my views or truths with her. [FYI—My understanding of world and local issues is simply more inclusive…and concedes that there are valid points and concerns on both sides. I understand that based on perspective, one side is correct in their beliefs…just as much as the other side believes they are correct. I do not have a need to draw a line in the sand concerning absolute rights and wrongs. This basic knowledge allows me to have a broader world view—not excluding those who believe or think differently than me. Therefore, debating topics in that way…was of little interest to me.] • • • • • Even though Veeby married a musician, she felt threatened and jealous from the very beginning. Yep, good old jealousy entered into our relationship and slowly pervaded Veeby’s every thought. During college, she was jealous when I simply practiced in the practice rooms, since it was time away from her. In the lobby of her college dormitory—before we were married—I was an unwilling participant in one of her major “discussions” in which she absolutely needed to know that she was “Number One” in my life…even more than music. I remember telling her that I didn’t feel the need to chose between her and music, but wanted both. Having created music since I was five (5)…and a piano major at that time…the argument didn’t make sense to me. Of course, that was later negatively reframed, “I wanted my cake and to eat it, too.” Jealousy showed up if I spent time with someone other than Veeby. While I freely admit I’m much more comfortable hanging out with my female friends and co-workers, [i.e., booking agents, publicists, artists and musicians], this frustrating thread was interwoven throughout our entire relationship. She wrote: I’m jealous—jealous that he’s going to spend time with her [booking agent] and not with me. It’s accentuated because I’m lonely. I’m tired of living by myself, that’s what it feels like. I’m living by myself even though we live together and I’m not so much blaming but feeling frustrated that it’s this way. Why does he have to stay late to practice with him [musician]? That’s going to get him home by 12:30 at night! I spend another evening alone. For the most part I’m used to it now. It’s been about 3 1/2 years of lonely evenings. For the most part I just do my own thing and wait for him. Wait—one long wait. I’m lonely, tired of spending only snitches of time together and always feeling like I’m taking him away from something else if I request some time with him. Time—enough time has always been an issue. I don’t really feel like I’m complaining anymore. I used to feel very bothered by it, now I’m just used to it. But, I don’t want to be used to it anymore. Maybe it’s insignificant and maybe it doesn’t mean anything but, the fact of the matter is that she’s getting some time when I’m not, when I feel I don’t get any or nearly enough. I can offer no solutions. I want him to have her as a booking agent. I want him to create with the artists and the musicians and the photographers, etc., but it’s almost like I just become part of the fabric of his existence and don’t stand out—don’t require special attention, special time. I’m not complaining, I’m really not. I’m just frustrated that that’s all I get. That my life is permeated much too infrequently by his presence…by his time. If I don’t demand, it’s easy to just assume I’m satisfied and don’t need. I do need—I need attention and time. I need to not be lonely. I need to not have to demand and feel guilty and conflicted for it. Maybe if we saw each other all the time we would be bored? We would get on each other’s nerves, maybe? All I know, though, is the feeling of coming home and not having him to share the day with—not having him to experience. And the feeling of insignificance at not getting his time as if it were a gift bestowed on only the important ones and things in his life. I know I’m important in his life, but knowing that does not take away the feelings…the frustration of watching him share his time with others when I get so little of it. I feel myself getting bitter and resentment kills. I want to purge that from within. I write to get it out, to understand where it comes from. I’m jealous—jealous of the time he’ll spend with [them] today and the 24 hours I’ll spend without him. That was written when I was traveling out of town for musical “gigs.” I would leave in the afternoons [while she was still at work] and be gone until the late hours. I often hung out with other musicians afterwards, since Veeby usually went to bed early for her work the next day. I was also teaching nights/weekends at a university, so when she would come home from work, I’d be AT work. During that time, we just had a schedule that had us missing each other. It saddened me when I learned Veeby was lonely during that time in our marriage. Over the years, the jealousy theme expanded into accusations of being “too friendly” with a lady behind the counter at the coffee store…or “flirting” with the sales women at a retail store while Veeby tried on clothes in the changing rooms. What this good old Southern boy considered friendly banter, Veeby viewed as my “casting the nets” to see what I could catch. Eventually, all the above was reframed as “I was not the marrying kind of man”—which was absolutely untrue from my perspective. I learned to not play as many out of town gigs and just worked from my home studio most of the time. That was better for me, since I’m basically a home-body anyway. That also allowed me to experience being “Mr. Mom” for our children. During our time together, I was extremely attentive, tender, loving and loyal to Veeby. However, she never really understood my loyalty, no matter how many times I tried to explain it with my words and through my actions. In her black and white version of the world, it didn’t make sense and was beyond her comprehension. Even though she dealt with the many shades of gray her private clients would bring in during her Financial Analysis appointments, she could not tolerate any gray area or a different perspective within our relationship. In the end, things had to be “her way or the highway.” The times that I would try to explain my side—my perspective or my truth—she’d claim I was “manipulating” or “rationalizing” or I was in “denial” or [my favorite] was becoming “defensive.” Usually, her accusation of my being “defensive” occurred while I was in the middle of answering a question she’d asked. As a “peace at all costs” kind of guy, I learned very quickly in the marriage to simply defer, for the sake of enjoying marital harmony. During her Master’s degree, Veeby took an elective class in Psych-ology and administered the MBTI [Myers-Briggs Type Indictor Personality Inventory] upon me when I [involuntarily] volunteered as her test subject. I popped up as an INFJ…the 1% club of the 16 possible personality types. Basically, I do not like conflict…it hurts my heart. However, looking back now I see myself having lived a 33+ year, drama filled, emotionally charged and conflict infected married life. WOW, what a ride! I’m glad the ride is finally over [well, almost over]. Veeby wrote: …[John] wants order—calm—harmony—no conflict. Passion without conflict? How does that fit? We seem to be at cross purposes. I want conflict, according to John, but I don’t…I truly don’t. I’m just not afraid to be angry with him. Maybe I go to anger much too quickly and he not at all. We can both use to be more balanced individually in this area. I have seen his want-ing harmony as boring, as the opposite of passion, assuming then that he has no passion. His passion is disguised, it masquerades as harmony…comes out of him in a way I can’t understand. Everyone has a life journey which requires getting into their own little boat, possibly deciding to share a boat with someone, and then pushing off into the sea of life—all the while hoping and praying that life’s waters will not become too rough. Try as we might to figure out the journey beforehand, “best laid plans” and all, it proves impossible. The twists and turns, the waves thrown at us by the sea, no one can know or prepare. It’s the same for deciding to get married or starting a family. There truly is never a good or right time…you just have to take the plunge. During our ending, I felt totally and utterly rejected and abandoned, which I know was Veeby’s intent. I certainly was not prepared for the recast version of the War of the Roses movie, ours seemingly on steroids. The following pages will illuminate the absolutely horrible ending of “Us”…carefully and masterfully manipulated, produced and directed by the conductor, Veeby. Sadly, I believe her terribly misinformed decisions, rationalized spiteful actions and multiple misleading semantical games in order to “play the system” during the whole ordeal merely highlight how she’s chosen to represent herself in this lifetime.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2007 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

1 Decision 2007

The cartoon character, Popeye, said it best: I’d had “all I could stands and I can’t stands no more.” The last several months of therapy had led to the upcoming moment. It was time for me to “draw a line in the sand”—to clearly state what was and was not acceptable behavior, in order for me to remain in the relationship. As we awaited our turn on the therapist’s couch, I reread the words from Oriah’s The Invitation, featured in a beautifully framed picture hanging in the lobby…and I wept. I had come to understand “owning my own power” and was about to verbalize it. While I’d never thought about existing apart from Veeby, it became clearer during that latest round of marital therapy that she was not listening or hearing me. While my youthful religious hardwiring dictated that divorce was “bad” and not an option, I found myself finally prepared to pull the divorce trigger. Oriah’s powerful words included: I want to know if you can sit with pain mine or your own without moving to hide it or fade it or fix it. Veeby and I had sat with pain many times, alone and together in marital therapy sessions. I expressed my pain and accepted hers. We were yoked together in partnership, sure to disappoint one another at times. I want to know if you will stand in the centre of the fire with me and not shrink back. In all our joys and hurts, I had often stood smack dab in the middle of the fire with Veeby. I endured her venomous verbal anger, her wagging finger in my face, her screaming at me usually nose to nose. I felt her eyes scorch my soul, and it hurt my heart. Yet, it never entered my mind to end our misery through divorce. Yes, I can say I’d successfully stood in the fire with my partner many, many times. I want to know if you can be alone with yourself and if you truly like the company you keep in the empty moments. Odd, but I appreciated the validation of those words. As a musician, I was used to being alone in order to hone my craft. As a creator, I needed the quiet “empty moments” to envision and then implement. However, my need for alone time had always been a source of irritation to my partner. I want to know if you can disappoint another to be true to yourself. If you can bear the accusation of betrayal and not betray your own soul. This theme spoke the loudest to me…and made me cry the very first time I read it several months earlier. Veeby had threatened to divorce me over and over [and over] through our 33+ years together. I endured accusations of betrayal I knew had not occurred, but could not convince my partner otherwise. I was finally strong enough to not “confess” to something I hadn’t done…just to keep the peace. I was finally strong enough to not betray my own soul. In all our years together, I had never threatened to divorce Veeby. I had put up with all her emotional baggage and she’d put up with mine. Now, finally, I was about to enter a therapy session where I did not need to be changed or fixed. I had finally found the strength to be willing to walk away from our marriage and our partnership if she didn’t change. The door opened…it was time. We entered, sat again, and I began the session by reading the following aloud to Veeby: NEW CONTRACT Veeby—Here’s what needs to happen in order for me to stay in our marriage: • I have allowed you to almost kill me...emotionally abuse me and beat me down. I will NO LONGER ACCEPT THIS BEHAVIOR FROM YOU. You must take steps to change. • During the last seven years, I could have easily been involved with others and have not. While there is no way to prove that I have not, I have not. I have honored my renewed vow to you from seven years ago. If you do not believe this, then we need to end our relationship. I can’t prove a negative. • We have talked about the PAST way too much—have analyzed and processed it, gone to tons of therapy for it and I’ve allowed you to beat me up for it. YOU have NOT worked through this for yourself. YOU have NOT forgiven me. YOU will NEVER FORGET and will always try to MAKE ME PAY for past hurts. I have paid my dues. I am DONE hearing about your list of hurts each and every time you are angry. This has not been FAIR and has only served to KILL US. • GOING FORWARD, we will NO LONGER talk about the past. The past is past—if YOU want to continue to swirl around in all our past hurts, then we have nothing else to talk about and we should end our marriage. • Friends: I will have both male and female friends—NON-NEGOTIABLE. You will not try to control who I can have as friends. I have no problem letting you know who my friends are, but do NOT need to tell you everything that we discuss. They will be MY friends. I will continue to honor my renewed vow to you. You will work on this issue with a therapist to gain further insight into your insecurities and jealousy issues. • Shame reduction for ME will include not allowing YOU to continue the belittling I’ve endured throughout our marriage. My thoughts and truths are just as valid as yours. Because they are not your thoughts and truths does NOT mean that “I am in denial.” I will no longer tolerate your condescending verbal abuse. You will work on this with a therapist to gain further insight and I will work on “owning my own power” and speaking my truth more honestly to you. • Our relationship has to be one of EQUALS, or it’s not worth having anymore. • There is no KING or QUEEN anymore. No more BROWBEATING. Neither one of us KNOWS IT ALL. We can DISCUSS things, but your DICTATING to me is no longer acceptable. • I stand by what I have stated before: it is not the desire of my heart to end our marriage. However, I simply cannot survive as a person any longer doing the current dance steps. • Either these changes are accepted, or I SAVE MYSELF by divorcing YOU and surviving. Her response? Veeby turned away from me, repositioned herself to face the therapist and speaking to him said she wanted to “move forward with the divorce.” I sat speechless. I was hurt beyond words. My partner wanted to end being my partner. She wanted to Un-Yoke us, after 33+ years together. I don’t remember much about the rest of the session. I barely remember leaving…I was numb. I drove to a dear friend, who held me as I cried. • • • • • That particular day, Veeby and I had planned to travel together for an out of town workshop. I was presenting at the State Convention of Music Teachers the very next day. She elected to not go on that trip. However, she texted me later in the afternoon that she wanted to meet before I left town. We coordinated to meet under a specific bridge on a major highway, after I was finished teaching. We cried together under that bridge. We got in the back seat, held each other, apologized to each other and both cried like babies. I told her she wasn’t supposed to divorce me…that this was simply another rough patch. We spoke about taking a year apart for space and healing, to find out what would be best and how to pursue it in the coming days. We discussed how we were simply unable to get past our accumulated hurts and differences. She superimposed various boundaries like a twisting maze of “walls”…to exert her control within our relationship. I always saw possibilities, not limitations. It was time for me to climb over the walls and get out of the maze. So, I drove off alone…down the road to the Convention. • • • • • Thus ended our “marital therapy.” We had been in and out of therapy for as long as we were together. Couples therapy, individual therapy…constantly. Actually, it’s hard to remember the times when were we not in therapy. From early on, we had to process how to fight fairly, and then if and when we would have children, and then her jealousy concerns, etc. It usually boiled down to I needed to be fixed—at least that’s what I remember Veeby telling the therapist as the scissors were sharpened and a smock was placed around me before we began each new round of therapy sessions. I learned very early that there really was no compromising within our sessions. Veeby thought or felt one way, and I usually felt or thought the opposite. The only way we’d been able to stay together for so long was through my uncanny ability to defer. Since I prized peace…usually at all costs…it led me to defer my preferences most of the time within my primary relationship with Veeby. In other relationships and within my work life, I would never have accepted such bullying behaviors. However, I loved and built my partner up and eventually placed her on a pedestal. I actually created a most demanding and entitled little beast…and yet I would do anything for her…often at my own emotional expense. This led to a terrible power imbalance within our relationship. Once, she emailed one of her friends that she had placed me in a “time out”…like she was the parent and I was the little kid: I spoke with John last night…he understands…he is in a “time out” but there are no guarantees…he just needs to realize he has to start putting effort into our marriage…maybe he will, maybe he won’t…time will tell. I am committed to exclude the expletives, but really…Dub Ya Tee Eff? Her constant framing that I wasn’t putting “effort” into the marriage…drove me crazy! I was eventually able to vehemently verbalize my disagreement. Such was our dance. When we disagreed, she would usually yell louder than me and I would back down…to keep the peace. If I stood up for myself—basically, not backing down—we’d end up in therapy. Most of those sessions were intended to change me, since it was obvious [to her] that I was entirely “wrong.” I jumped through so many hoops during our time together. I went to all those therapists and did everything Veeby asked me to do. I jumped over every obstacle she’d throw down, just trying to keep the marriage together. Still, she would say I hadn’t changed…or didn’t “get it”…or I’d crossed yet some other made up “line in the sand” or boundary…or wasn’t putting effort into our marriage…grrrr! There was so much built up hurt through the years…on both sides. Veeby wrote: John, I know you are hurt with my outburst today. I know it probably seems to come out of nowhere… these feelings are displaced…I should feel happy to be with you, I should feel loving, and I don’t. Know that I don’t want to be mean to you…. And… John, I long to be close to you. I know your hurt keeps me out—but I’m aching to be let in—to feel connected to you. I know I have hurt you— I acknowledge the times I have said hurtful words in my hurt. For all the hurt I’ve caused you, I apologize…. One therapist taught us the concepts of “Individuating” and “Withdrawing our Will” as to whether we stayed in our relationship or not. That’s exactly what Veeby acted on at our last session…she withdrew her will to continue our journey….since I would no longer back down to her demands. • • • • • The last storm of angst blew through our relationship several months prior. A jealous clod of a husband—let’s call him an Unenlightened Neanderthal—came to our house to speak to Veeby while I was at work. He made accusations of my being “too close” to his wife…an adjunct member of the music department at my university job…who was also part of a five member group of friends that regularly stayed after work to talk and vent about our respective lives. While she and I were close friends, we were not “having an affair.” The Unenlightened Neanderthal—[Thal, for short]—had illegally wiretapped and recorded a phone conversation between us [felony offense] that he then pompously played for Veeby to hear. There was nothing damning within that conversation, but just the fact that I was speaking with his wife, hurt Veeby. Later, both Thal and Veeby concluded that even if we weren’t having an affair, then we must be having an “emotional affair.” Yeah, that’s the ticket! OMG—we were friends—both hurting and sharing in the safety of a group of friends after work. I later learned that Thal and his [then] wife had decided to terminate their marriage the evening prior to his showing up at my house. It became obvious to Thal—since I was the only male member within that group of friends his wife was hanging out with—it made sense in his small brain that it must be my fault. I must have done STOLE HIS WOMAN. And if he was gonna lose his woman, then he was gonna make sure I lost my woman, too! Ugh, Ugh. Thal landed at my house and proceeded to exploit Veeby’s fears by using his suspicion [not proof] to not only hurt me by destroying my marriage relationship, but by throwing Veeby into needless turmoil. If Thal had “used his words” [hard for an Unenlightened Neanderthal] and conversed and actually LISTENED to his wife, a whole bunch of heartache could have been avoided on both sides. Alas, Unenlightened Neanderthals generally don’t listen too well. They usually think they already know everything. They tend to yell and boast loudly as they bully their way through life. Before I arrived back home after Thal’s little visit, Veeby was already in a tail spin. She’d taken the two oldest children aside and told them mommy and daddy were getting divorced. She would later confide that she needed to tell our daughters to force herself to follow-through with the divorce. Talk about sacrificing your own children without regard to their well-being! What a horrible thing to have done. Not only were Thal’s accusations false, but to compound the issue and mess up the children that way? Not a very well thought out plan. One daughter left and returned to college that afternoon before she and I could speak and process all of the information. While the other daughter was already going through a turbulent year of teenage angst, the divorce details Veeby shared melted the rest of her childhood away. Not only was Veeby’s insecurities exploited by Thal, plus the potential loss she was about to put into motion with a divorce, but there had already been many losses for her that particular year. Veeby had had yet another falling out with her own father earlier in the year—a long story with lots of hurts. She later wrote about feeling rejected as a daughter by her father, rejected as a mother by one of her kids, and rejected as a wife by me. [Disclaimer: I never rejected Veeby, but she couldn’t understand things any differently.] Our family cat had just passed away. There were premenopausal issues going on during that time, and I got my head bitten off by merely bringing up that subject. The oldest girl had left the nest to begin her own life in college. In order to prevent further hurt from our middle girl, Veeby wanted to sever all ties and send her away to military school. [I saved her from the military school option…whew!] Like I said, there was a whole lot going on in our family during that time period. • • • • • Early in our marriage—when we moved to Denver for our respective post-graduate studies—Veeby and I had several discussions regarding “opening up” our relationship to the possibility of experiencing “others” from time to time. This resulted in an Agreement between us…that if we ever acted on this, neither party wanted to know. Accordingly, I have no idea how that manifested itself within Veeby’s life and decisions during our time together. I know that my acting on that permission allowed me to open and grow in my understanding of life. During discussions within a therapeutic setting many years later, we re-addressed that Agreement and chose to return to our original monogamous arrangement. Therefore, it’s extremely MISLEADING and INACCURATE [all the while remaining somewhat funny] that Veeby would make the argument that I had “stepped out” on her…screaming to all who would listen. Nothing had happened within her and my relationship that both parties hadn’t already agreed to. Her spewing vile accusations was just a cruel shaming game she used to sway sympathy from our friends and family, most of whom had no idea of our previous Agreement. • • • • • Thal’s false accusation set the stage for our last round of therapy. So, when a good intentioned friend suggested seeing a Sex Therapist, Veeby jumped all over that. It was obvious, of course—if I didn’t desire her and just her, I must be a sexual deviant…a pervert…an out-of-control sex addict. Yeah, that’s the ticket! Off we went to Sex Therapy, i.e., we began another round of marital therapy. This time we were going to get me snipped and fixed to her liking—a little off the top, leave some on the sides—you know, get me fixed up nice and pretty so I’d follow her around like a dog. Veeby probably daydreamed about the envious comments she’d receive from her friends—how beautiful and wonderfully trained I was. Whether I was or was not a sexual deviant was entirely dependent on which side of the bed Veeby woke up each morning. If she needed to shame me to others, I was portrayed as a sexual addict. She had been given a new label to throw at me, in yet another attempt to hurt and control me. However, she also knew the true me…and that the sexual deviant claim was just a sham. During that time, she wrote my parents: Let me reiterate now what I said earlier to you, I do not believe John is a sexual deviant in any way, shape or form. Let me also be clear that John has given me many gifts and joys throughout our 33+ years together, not the least of which are your three amazing grandchildren. John is kind, loving and an amazing father to our children. As I told you earlier, I am with him still because I love him deeply…I will not abandon him, I will continue to love him even if that means our marriage doesn’t survive. I have told John all of this and he understands. I know I need to change, listen more and create space for John to feel comfortable challenging me more. My individual therapist was female and absolutely wonderful. She helped me find my own power and gave me permission to view the dynamics of what all was going on in my relationship with Veeby within a different context. I wasn’t “wrong” or “crazy”—I just saw things differently. Thank you, thank you! In order to get to the bottom of the whole sex addiction thing, I took the Sexual Dependency Inventory [SDI] test. I needed to score at least a “6” on their scale in order to qualify as a real live genuine sex addict. Unfortunately, I only scored a “2”—not enough—DARN! I was confirmed [condemned?] to NOT be a sex addict. Tested and confirmed, I was just a normal guy. But wait…there’s more. Even though Veeby had met that female therapist and “approved” of our working together, it became abundantly clear to Veeby after 10 sessions and my receiving a “normal” rating on the SDI, that my therapist did NOT know what she was doing. I had not “changed” sufficiently. So Veeby dragged me into a different therapist’s office [within the same practice], but now we would do “couples therapy.” Now, for sure, I would be fixed! Yippee!! So, the new male therapist read my SDI results. Luckily for me, if I would only see him for a year or so of additional therapy, and then retake the SDI, I would definitely score more towards being a real sex addict. He unbelievably and truthfully said that to me…WOW…sign me up! [NOT] While those practitioners observed the Patrick Carnes sexual addiction model, I had clearly stated from the beginning that their model did not feel right to me. However, as yet another hoop I had to jump through to “work on our marriage,” I was then signed up for Group [Sex] Therapy. Yep, I attended Group Therapy for Sexual Addicts! A lovely time was had by all. I never felt like I belonged and eventually walked away from the group. I was kind of hoping for an electric shock therapy session when I “graduated” from Sex Therapy…to erase all my memories of the entire ordeal. Even though I jumped through her Sex Therapy hoop [good dog!]—to save and work on our marriage—Veeby eventually [slanderously] reframed that entire experience within court records as “John has been in sex addiction therapy, and fits the criteria for a person with sexual deviancy issues.” Veeby excelled in playing semantical games. She loved to twist the truth to her needs. It has always been about Perspective. S M O K E & M I R R O R S Threads of jealousy resurfaced several days before our very last therapy session. Veeby was aware I had just set up a new social media page, linked it to my website, and sent out a generic email to about 80+ people: I’m trying to launch a new Artist Page for myself…. Would you be able to “Like” my Artist Page, please? Thanks. It was Fall and the kids were preparing their costumes for Halloween, which fell on a Sunday evening that year. For reasons I don’t fully understand, Veeby became jealous and suspiciously went looking for “evidence.” So while I was at work, she tried to log into my Facebook account. She didn’t know my password, so she submitted a password reset request. She then logged in, printed out the above little blurb and copied the 80+ contacts information. [Talk about invasion of privacy!] I later learned that she was furious—not that I’d sent out the promotional email, but that I’d sent it to the ladies in my group of friends. Walking towards my car after morning rehearsals that Sunday, I found Veeby waiting for me, already seated in my hot car with the windows rolled up. She launched into a verbal rampage, waving a print out of the above little blurb. She told me to not come home. I told her I didn’t have any other clothes, but she countered that I had the clothes I was wearing. I told her it was my house, too…and that I didn’t like her setting the precedent that she could “kick me out” whenever she felt like it. She yelled and ranted some more until I backed down…deferred once again…our normal dance steps. I spent the night with some friends, but more importantly, was “forbidden” to enjoy Halloween with our kids. CONTROL! Apparently, there’s a double standard when it comes to promoting internet pages which I never knew—I didn’t get the memo. Evidently, it’s completely acceptable if Veeby promotes her newly designed website to her email distribution list the month before… Sharing my new website with you and bragging on my eleven-year-old son who designed it for me! …but not all right if I promote my new social media page. S M O K E & M I R R O R S Over the next several days, Veeby continued to process her thoughts and feelings. She researched and emailed me about our Individuating: I think this [article] sums it up well—I have to individuate from you to know what I want—if at the end of the process I want what you offer [and you want me] then we can come together as a “we”—but in either case I need this transformation for myself. I know you blame me but I hope someday you’ll see it was the only way for me not to hate the person I’d become—now I can be freer to love you for who you are, without it hurting me. [she drew a little heart symbol] Since she and I married after college and then continued to “grow up” together as a couple, there is some validity to the suggestion that neither she nor I ever fully Individuated from our families of origin. Neither of us lived on our own prior to marriage [college dorm roommates don’t count]. Based on our shared religious upbringings, it was just the thing to do back then…we got married relatively early in life. Hindsight allows me to see how Veeby’s Individuation process seemingly created an ugly monster. • • • • • She also researched and wrote about Kabbalah: I thought this article was interesting… I see myself as Binah consciousness and you as chochma :) The article then went on to include the following text about her “Binah” consciousness: “…Binah is a female force and indeed the Talmud tells us that women have a higher level of it. Binah is the power of control [ya think?] and creative imitation.” [Veeby drew and copied art, but did not create originals.] Also, “Sometimes, people over-analyze, second guess and scrutinize. They are too heavily controlled by Binah, and this usually leads to negative results, as in, ‘well, he texted me yesterday and told me he had a good time,’ but then I thought, ‘What does he mean by that? Isn’t “good” kind of a generic word? And if he really cared wouldn’t he have just called anyway?’ Though useful, Binah does not always bring us to tranquility, harmony and big picture thinking.” Oh…My…Goodness…the paragraph above is EXACTLY how Veeby rambled on and on throughout all her letters and emails. • • • • • After her decision to end us, Veeby wrote my parents: …I want to tell you both that I love your son very much. He needs your loving kindness and support right now. I have asked John for a dissolution of our union. I love you both and rest assured I know you love me. John and I love our children and will be forever linked through them. My prayer is that once this trial passes we will be able to have peace and love restored John is a magnificent father to [our children] and has always been. He is a kind, loving, attentive man to me. It is just time to move on for me. I want nothing but goodness and mercy to follow John all the days of his life. I love you all. And… …just wanted to inform both of you that I am fine and so are the children. I also want to be accountable to both of you that I have made many mistakes and erred towards John in our time together. I have apologized for my cruel words and actions towards him and I want to let you both know that I take responsibility for my wrongs in our old marriage. John and I have decided to pause and let each other heal. I want you both to be certain that you have raised a kind, loving, and gentle man. John is all those good things as well as things that aren’t good, like all of us, we have our warts and all. I have lived my life from a place of fear for many years, and that made me do and say hurtful things in order to keep John from hurting me. I know now that I want to live my life from a place of love, to know that I am responsible for not letting myself get hurt. I don’t fear John, I know whatever happens to us we will always love each other, our DNAs are forever linked. I pray you hear my words and forgive me if I have hurt either one of you with my past actions or words. I love you both and pray for good things for you both. She wrote our friends: Because I still love John and I know he has feelings for me, we are doing this leaving as gently as possible, so that neither one of us or the children has to be hurt any further…John and I want different things. She wrote me: John, You are my love and will always be. I know that now. You are right, there is only love or fear, and I have operated out of fear all of my life. Out of fear has come my anger and that has been toxic for me, you and our family. My fear leads to my anxiety which causes me to act in damaging ways. For all of this I apologize and take accountability. I am not proud of how I have been acting with you. I am grateful that it has brought me finally to a resting place of awareness and the choice I get to make now to live from a place of love. From this place of love, which is new and exciting for me to explore, I want to recreate my life. I have washed up on this beach of love and am exploring it all. I know that I cannot be a mate to you on a new boat without first getting my sea legs of love underneath me. I read recently that a healthy relationship is: I am me, You are you, We are us I can grow, You can grow, We can grow I need to learn to be me. I need to not operate from fear and use threats of leaving you to keep you with me and calm my fears. I was damaged before you met me…your love all these years has healed a lot of it…I have to find a way to fix that and it will only happen if I operate from a place of love, for me, for others. I have attempted to keep from hurting by protecting myself from you, by controlling who you are I believed I could keep myself safe…you couldn’t hurt me if I knew all of you…you have your own damages and hurts and didn’t feel safe letting me know you. We went around and around in circles…hurting each other. Despite all that we have loved each other and our children abundantly. We have been able to rise above our past hurts and call out our better angels many times in these 33+ years. I want to continue calling on my better angel…believing that is possible, choosing to create my life differently, choosing to not get trapped by fear. I know that fear is powerful in me and will continue to trap me, but I have to believe love is stronger. I guess what I am saying is I have washed up on this beach of love and am exploring it. I long for company…I would welcome yours. But I accept that you have your own exploring to do. Our lives have touched and our DNA’s are entwined forever even if we don’t continue as mates. I know now that it is the desire of my heart to be loving with you and I believe that is possible independent of our being mates or not. I love you forever. And… John, Thanks for understanding my paranoia and fears—we will do this together—I know that. [drew a little heart] And… John, I respect you more than you can know for staying true to who you are—I understand that, because that’s what I’m doing too—remaining true to who I am even though it is killing me to do so. You are and always will be my true love—my first love—I’ve been desperately trying to fight for our marriage so as not to lose my love and that’s brought us nothing but grief and pain…I’m so sorry this separation is happening—I want to be as gentle as possible to you and me as I pull us apart. If I could be different I would—but I’m not—in this lifetime we got many good years out of our union—we beat all their odds—but in the end we have to let it go. • • • • • Veeby did have some “down time” between all her writings…which she used to throw dramatic hissy fits. Just a few examples will suffice: • The previous spring, we were having one of her “discussions”—which meant I was being yelled at rather loudly. It happened to be a cooler, breezy day, so we had all the windows opened in the house. At the end of her loud sermon, Veeby drove off to work—she had “said her piece” and then left me in emotional shreds on the floor as she just drove away—a common occurrence. Veeby justified her actions thusly: She didn’t want to hold onto her anger, but wanted to “get it out” so it would “get dealt with.” During our time together, I was eventually able to “use my words” and tell her that her “getting her anger out” usually cut me like a knife, leaving me in bloody shreds on the floor. While she might feel great verbally expressing her latest struggle, I told her she shouldn’t hurt me so deeply, since she supposedly loved me and we were married. However, Veeby’s loud rant that particular day was carried down the block in our development. After she drove off, one of the neighbors rang the doorbell…said she’d heard a lot of screaming and was checking to make sure everything was all right…WOW! All was not well in Camelot, indeed. • Then there was the time we were having a lovely little “discussion” in the master bathroom. I don’t remember the subject matter, but do remember ducking quickly to avoid being hit by the flying glass soap dispenser. I dutifully cleaned up the glass and soap mess she’d made…and then went out and purchased replacement soap dispensers…plastic ones. • The day she elected to end us, she later cautioned me…that I’d better not go out and kill myself. I wasn’t sure if she was projecting her own thoughts or not so subtly planting a suggestive seed for me to ponder. I later learned that she sought medical help the next day and received prescription drugs for anxiety and depression…which confirmed my belief she’d had those thoughts and was simply projecting. • When I got back from the Convention, she broke down in our bedroom and lamented, “How was she going to raise our three kids all by herself?” I was standing right there…and replied that she wouldn’t be raising them alone. I’d always been involved and would continue to be involved in our children’s lives.
[The phrase Drama Queen entered my mind.] • • • • • Yes—all in all, it had been a very turbulent year. Veeby’s decision to end us in the Fall…seemed logical to her and was originally supposed to be an amicable separation, during which time we’d figure out how to proceed. It didn’t end up that way. I believe Veeby did not honor our marriage vows when she decided to “withdraw her will” and end our partnership. By getting out of our small boat, she was unfaithful in our journey.

2 Told the Kids to Float

Even though she wanted out of our little boat, she asked me to move out…to let her stay in our house with the children. If I only knew then what I would come to know, I would have never agreed to that. At the time, the whole separation thing was new to me and I deferred to her request. Even though I was the one that paid our mortgage and bills, and her income was our vacation and savings money. Though we continued living together in the house for another month—even sleeping in the same bed—we agreed that we were “emotionally divorced,” and would take no legal action for awhile. Her asking that I move out was framed that she needed time and space to heal. She was still my partner…whom I still loved and cared for…so of course I agreed to her request. We spoke in depth about how we had both been involved with our kids during the coupleship, and would continue to do so. We specifically agreed that we had done Life well together, so we would do Divorce well together. Unfortunately, that didn’t work out so well. Since I worked primarily from home…with rehearsals and lessons at the University only a couple of days each week, I had always been an equal Co-Parent with our children. I was the constant—i.e., taking kids to the dentist and doctor appointments, picking them up or dropping them off to their sports events, rollerblading and biking them to and from school as needed. Not that Veeby didn’t also, but it primarily fell to me. As a couple, I was the one to get up early with the kids and get them off to school. I would make the morning juice while Veeby often slept in until waking up just to see them off. In fairness, she sometimes would help make their lunches before school. Our entire married life, Veeby and I toggled the care of our children. It took several days before everyone’s schedules aligned and we could all assemble to discuss mom’s decision, and the upcoming changes within our family. In attendance were our oldest daughter, Eliana; middle daughter, Noelle; youngest son, Mark; plus one mom, one dad, one dog and the one remaining cat—all gathered for our family “pow-wow.” She and I explained the upcoming Separation. I clearly stated the Separation was mom’s idea. SHE shot me one of her death looks the moment the words came out of my mouth…but it was the truth. That was the time to be real, to be truthful and calmly explain how it was going to affect all of our lives. Since I had previously shared my little boat analogy with the family, I continued that thread and told our kids to simply FLOAT. I explained that they were about to be tossed into rough seas, but a symbolic “life preserver” had been placed around each of them that would keep them safe. I reaffirmed the rough seas would calm back down at some point and they would ultimately be all right. I looked each of our children in the eye and told them to: • love on mom, • love on dad, and • don’t choose sides Mom and Dad had already worked out a plan!

3 Plan A

So as to provide consistency in the lives of our children, Veeby and I devised an amicable Plan A. We discussed staying legally married until our youngest son finished high school, selling the house and splitting any profits at that time—maybe filing divorce papers then. That made the most sense to us, since the housing market had just crashed and we were upside-down with our mortgage. I would simply move out, per Veeby’s request, but Noelle and Mark would continue to live in our house with mom. Eliana was already in college, so she was basically “gone.” I would still see our remaining two children regularly since I’d continue to teach my private piano lessons at the studio in the house. We decided to share the financial responsibilities of the household based on a 55/45 split of joint bills. Really, the unequal split was Veeby’s idea, based on our income and a Child Support Guidelines Worksheet she filled out…whatever, I went with the flow. It was only the beginning of my getting royally screwed. We figured if I moved into a cheap little rental place, I could make ends meet. At that time, I was willing to take the big financial hit, in order to have Veeby and the children stay in the house. I was being loving toward my partner and our children. It didn’t matter to me that Veeby was pulling the plug on us, I was still trying to do the right thing for my family. Such naïveté on my part. We began to separate our bills and expenses into individual accounts over the next month. I helped Veeby spin off onto her own cell phone account. We terminated any credit cards that were in both names. We discussed who would take which car. She didn’t want any payments, so she took the older car which was already paid off and I took the newer car. I set up “her” car with an automatic Toll device and attached payment to her credit card. I helped her set up her website on her own new account. We even discussed whether to sell my grand piano. That was my baby. I had done a big project, earned enough money to pay off some of our bills and then bought my piano. In one last moment of tenderness and clarity, Veeby wrote: John—Don’t sell your piano…you worked so hard for it. Just leave it [at our house] and continue to teach here. Her correspondence through the end of the year referred to the piano as “mine,” but it would eventually become a “marital asset.” Who knew? Plan A was neatly laid out within a spreadsheet, showing her and my income and our joint and separate expenses. She and I wrote notes back and forth by hand on a hard copy as we ironed out all the details to make the 55/45 split happen smoothly. • • • • • Then, it hit me, quite unexpectedly. Not even a month had passed since her decision to end us, when she began referring to me as her “Ex.” We had not yet decided how long to remain separated or how long to wait before filing any legal paperwork. We hadn’t even decided if or when to file for divorce. We had spoken about what to call each other—possibly “former partner” since neither of us really liked “ex-wife” or “ex-husband” label. I suppose it’s part of separating the WE that had always been into the individual parts. It just caught me by surprise. Seemingly overnight, I became her “Ex.”

4 John Is a Cat…I Wanted a Dog

I learned that Veeby had already talked to most of our friends and family…spinning her version of the story…acquiring sympathy. Only a handful were wise enough to not take sides. It appeared that whomever presented “their side” of our story first, usually got to keep those friends! Most of “our” friends fell into her deceitfully spun web. Lesson learned. In an email to some of our wiser friends, Veeby used the following metaphor: It has been painful to realize that John is a cat who tried to be a dog all these years, but in the end is a cat and will always be. I do not want him to be anything more than who he is, he has tried to be a dog because a dog is what I want, but alas, he can only be who he is. While I’m aware she didn’t mean it in a positive way, I’ll reframe the above and wear it as a badge of honor. I like that cats are independent. I’m sure Veeby was frustrated during our time together that she wasn’t able to “control” me like she would have preferred…couldn’t get me to do whatever/whenever…and would have preferred to have a dog that would follow her around, doing exactly what she wanted…including being close enough to kick when she felt like it. Although her email stated she didn’t want me to “be anything more than who he is”…she sure didn’t act or behave that way in the following months. Instead, she tried to kill the cat…stomp him…burn him… bury him alive…take away his offspring! What Veeby never fully understood nor gave me credit for was: I was an excellent dog! I let her scream at me, kick me, shame me, abuse me and I continued to come back for more. I would be right beside her as she yelled, then comfort her, love on her…until she would mistreat me once more…over and over again. Evidently, my being her faithful companion for so many years…in the end, meant nothing. The collar got tighter and the leash got shorter during our time together—it eventually became hard to breathe. If I found shelter and took refuge from the abuse…I was punished more for being a “bad dog” when I returned home. We actually had a family dog…it kept Veeby very happy by following her around…slept with her once I was gone…and worshiped at her feet.

5 Our Buffer

As we prepared to disassemble our life together, I went to the safe deposit box to retrieve my important documents. I discovered that Veeby had already been there and taken all of our buffer money—the cash we kept in case of an emergency. It was only $8000…but, it was $8000! When I confronted her about it, she replied that she would hold onto it for us…i.e., CONTROL. I told her I’d need some of that money to get into a new place. She produced $2000 for that purpose. However, since we’d decided I would not take any furniture, leaving everything at the house for the family, I was also going to need money for some basic furniture. Veeby suggested I purchase my furniture needs with a credit card…one in just my name, of course. She needed to hold onto my remaining half of the buffer money. She’d see “where she was” in a month, as to whether she could part with that extra money or not. That really rubbed me the wrong way. It didn’t seem right or fair. Yet, it was hard for me to stand up and ask for what I needed—the rest of “my half” of our buffer money. She wanted me to leave our house, not take anything, not let me have money to start my life over, not give me half our buffer money, and she was okay with that! To rub salt in the wound, I knew she’d already booked herself a “get-away” vacation a couple of weeks later! Bolstered by my friends, I began a conversation with Veeby in which I asked for the additional $2000, my half of the original $8000. O…M…G! The screaming, cursing, anger…good thing we had plastic soap dispensers! The “discussion” spilled out onto our driveway. Veeby was not happy and she very angrily let me know. That conversation ended when she stormed into our house and slammed the door closed, leaving me outside but luckily, not locked out. Back inside and later that evening, she threw an envelope at me…with the remaining funds of my half of our buffer. Boy, was I surprised. I had stood up to her…and she backed down. She then stormed out of the house in anger, but texted me later: John, I’m sorry. I don’t want to fight with you. You’re half of our buffer is $4000. The next day, I found a one bedroom rental, submitted application forms and began to shop for furniture.

6 Calculating the Manipulation

Veeby reached out to our most recent therapist a couple of weeks later. She needed advice and guidance since it was “…extremely difficult for her to extricate herself from me…” I was in disbelief as I continued to read her words: I am trying to be gentle with John now because I need him to see me as his friend because I need his help financially during this transition in order to stay in the house and have the least amount of change for the children and me. We had already developed our Plan A. Why did she need to be so calculating in her manipulation? I guess Veeby received the information she needed and figured out how to manipulate me. She then sent me this enticing email: Subject: friend Hi John, you asked me if I would still be your friend a while back. I can assure you that I have always been your best friend and even though you may not believe it right now, continue to be that. I ask you to be my friend now. What I mean by this is that I want you to be your true self with me, just like you are with the other people you consider your friends. I don’t feel that you have been able to be your true self with me and that is the relationship I would like us to have as we move forward in this separation. You have nothing to fear anymore by being your true self with me. I remember thinking, “She doesn’t want to know me.” She was separating us after 33+ years. What a manipulative email.

7 Erased

Meanwhile, I began to feel erased. I was being erased from her life…slowly disappearing until completely invisible. Someone was in Veeby’s ear, giving her advice and counsel…bad guidance in my opinion. She’d started seeing one of our former therapists during that time period. She was hanging out more with her recently divorced sister, and some other “friend” who enjoyed “Sticking It To The Man” according to her social media pages. I was [am] a touchy, feely person generally. It was my way to lovingly stay connected. Typically, as I would walk past Veeby, I would usually touch her back or stroke her hair…just to connect. I would just as often lean over and kiss her, or give her a peck on the forehead—it was just part of me. I was affectionate without thinking anything about it. Until she announced, “NO MORE TOUCHING.” Even though I’d heard her words about separation and perhaps eventual divorce, it just didn’t register until she said I couldn’t touch her in any way. It was the beginning of a new strangeness for me. Since we were still sleeping in the same bed, I had to make sure not to greet her in the mornings by caressing her face. Her new decision was a daily rejection of me. Not a great way to start each day. I was being erased. The hurts kept on a coming. Since I had never “ended” a relationship before, I didn’t know if that was “normal” ending stuff. DOWN CAME THE PICTURES…every single picture I happened to be in. All the family pictures came down…while I was still living there… before I’d moved out. At least she asked me if I wanted them before she threw them away with the trash. At least she didn’t burn them in front of me. I grabbed them all and they are all safely stored. I was being erased. She UPDATED HER WILL, changing not only the Executor [no longer me], but the children’s custody. She changed her Will to reflect that if she died, that I not “get” the children. Veeby designated they would go to her sister, then to a friend, then to my sister. Wait, what? Veeby’s need for CONTROL was clearly demonstrated with every deletion of my name from her Will. I didn’t think her new Will would stand up in court if challenged. I was their father for goodness sake. I should get to raise our children if something should happen to Veeby. It was just plain cruelty on her part to discount me as their father in this way. Jeez, I had multiple cards and letters from Veeby proclaiming what a “magnificent father I’d been to our children—and had always been.” I was being erased. She CHANGED HER LIFE INSURANCE POLICY. Just like the actions with her Will, she took me completely off as Beneficiary. If she were to die, wouldn’t I need the extra money to help raise our children? I was being erased. Her NEW FORMER NAME: Within the first several days after her decision to end us, not only did she start referring to me as her “Ex”, but she started referring to herself using her maiden name. Even though no legal separation or divorce paperwork had been filed, she just became a newly named being. She stopped using her email address and internet domain name—anything that referenced her “married” name…was tossed away! She created her new name email address and her new name URL for the internet. All of these actions seem beyond Veeby simply “reclaiming” herself. Her growing uncivil interactions during that time period seemed intended to inflict further emotional pain by overtly erasing that I ever existed in her life. I was being erased. Unwisely publishing her thoughts and fears through online social media, Veeby continued to spin her web, by trying to label me as a “Master Manipulator” and “Duplicitous.” That was indeed funny, since Veeby was strategic in both chess and life. The “Pin the Tail on the John” labels she used were merely projections of her own personality characteristics. I did not think strategically in that way, nor planned on how to manipulate people. Actually, I considered myself more of a Reactive—meaning I reacted to all the hoops she had me jump through. As a Reactive, I accepted events as part of my journey and realized I couldn’t control everything. Veeby hadn’t yet come to understand that. So, I went with the flow for the most part. Not to say I didn’t make plans or carry out complicated bigger projects. I was being erased. I do not believe the above actions were suggested by legal counsel. Documentation Veeby left lying around our house during that time affirms this belief. She did not contact a lawyer until the end of the year. Her actions were premature and specifically aimed to inflict emotional hurt upon me, the intended target. Unfortunately, she was just getting warmed up to her new life purpose…my misery. I was being erased.

8 Thanksgiving 2007

Erasing exercises continued daily through Thanksgiving weekend. Since Eliana was home from college for the holiday, I suggested to Veeby that we take our annual family Holiday card pictures. My thought was that even though we were separating—and possibly divorcing in the future—we were still married and more importantly still a family. Veeby stated she did not want to send out a card that year…no way, no how. Alrighty, then! No family pictures were taken. People came over to our house on Thanksgiving Day. The air was noticeably thick with “they’re getting divorced” whispers from our family and friends. I tried to avoid the awkwardness of my presence by working in my office. When it was time for the feast, everyone filed through the kitchen to serve their own plates before being seated at the large family table. As was typical, I brought up the end of the line. I wasn’t late to dinner, I was simply at the end of the line as a courtesy to our guests. While I was still getting food on my plate, Veeby began the feast by raising her glass and toasting. The children and our guests looked over at me. I was still over in the kitchen and not at the table. I was taken aback and felt hurt. Why would Veeby treat me so horribly in front of our family and friends? I felt like her actions made her look petty. I finished gathering my food and walked to the table only to find that no seat had been left for me. We were one chair short. The table had been prepared without one place setting. Subtle. I ended up sitting on the couch and ate off the coffee table. I had seemingly been expelled from the family. I finished up quickly and left the house—I was terribly upset. I walked around the block and cried. I would never do something like that to her—I just wouldn’t—it was terribly rude and uncivil. Our children noticed…the cousins saw. Later that evening, Veeby emailed a “Happy Thanksgiving” greeting to my parents which included a picture of her and our children taken that day. She labeled the picture, “my greatest blessings.” As in most intimate relationships, there are dynamics between the parties that might look benign to an outside eye. Those in the relationship fully understand what is being said, reading in between the lines. Veeby was LARGE and IN CHARGE. She was claiming the house and she was claiming the kids. I was OUT…there’s the door! Unfortunately, there was much more to come.

9 Took a Condo

I took my not-so-subtle cue and exited our house, stage left…into a small one bedroom condominium. While I moved some of my stuff, I turned my office/music studio at the house into storage space for the rest. I used the remaining funds from our buffer money to purchase home furnishings, had it all delivered and enjoyed putting everything together. I began a new chapter. Even though Veeby wanted to end us, I was the one that moved out. I rationalized that I was willing to do that for a time. I paid 55% of her and the kids household expenses so as to not impact them too negatively until they finished high school. Our Plan A meant I left my teaching tools and supplies at the house, would live in a little hole in the wall and continue to see our children when I taught lessons over there. In the category of “If I knew then what I know now”—since Veeby was the one who wanted to end our relationship, she should have been the one to move out. I was the one paying the mortgage! What did we know? Neither of us had lived through the divorce process before. I was simply trying to be a nice guy. At that time, Veeby had an unrealistic expectation of how well everything would work out for her. She wanted out of our relationship, so she would (1) kick me out, (2) keep the kids, (3) stay in the house, and (4) have me pay for everything. A perfect little world…in her mind. What was framed as my moving out as a time of “separation” for us to “heal,” turned into the first of many manipulative moves in the new divorce dance. She led, and I reactively followed.

10 France Trip

In celebration of her new life, new house and new name, she left and took a week’s vacation to France. She said she needed time to clear her head, heal, relax, recharge her batteries and rejuvenate—since everything was “just too overwhelming at home.” So, over to the South of France she went to lay on the beach, eat some good French food and dance to some good music. Veeby stated she needed to let her “inner child run free,” so she booked a hang gliding excursion and landed on the beach. My having just moved out, I returned to the house to take care of our children during her absence. When she needed validation documentation so she could log into her social media accounts from out of the country, I received a very nice “could you help me, please?” email. All my organizational skills—and the ability to scan—proved useful once more. It seemed I was good for something! I replied to her email request and attached the documents, then ended by writing, “Refresh yourself...cry for our loss, I still love you, Veeby.” For some reason, that confused her and made her sad. She later said she took a nap and woke up feeling stronger. Just because Veeby made her decision to no longer be in relationship with me—withdrew her will, and all—didn’t mean I had made the same choice. She and I had discussed many times through our years together the concept of my Unconditional Love for her. She never understood, nor would she commit the same in return. She lived her life based on the “Why would I stay in a relationship if I were no longer happy?” premise. The concept of Unconditional Love—never made sense to Veeby. • • • • • To confuse matters even more, she sent me this text when she returned… John, I remember the good too. That’s why my heart is shattered. I pray for no more pain, no more sorrow for me…for you. I send you love. …and included a picture of herself in a bikini from our 25th Anniversary trip to Cozumel. Guess she loved me, she loved me not—she loved me, she loved me not. I no longer knew what was going on anymore.

11 Holiday Card…REALLY?

Subject: Merry Christmas from Veeby and her gang Wishing everyone a blessed Christmas and Happy New Year! Love, Veeby She sent out a Holiday Card to 87 of “our” friends and family, but excluded me from the picture. She didn’t send me a copy or even let me know! Every year for the last 30 years, we’d sent out a Holiday photo card. It documented the growth of our family—began with us as a couple with only cats, B.C. [Before Children] and then showed the addition of each child. We eventually became a family of five: Dad, Mom, two daughters and one son. I had just brought up the Holiday photo card subject to Veeby at Thanksgiving, which was the normal time we took the pictures. She strongly declared she did not want to send out Holiday cards that year, thus ending our long tradition. I even suggested at Thanksgiving that we could simply have the kids stand between us, but she completely vetoed the idea. After her return from France, she elected to take pictures of just her with our children and then sent out her own Holiday card. Just another attempt to totally erase me from her life. Admittedly, I was too close to be objective and could only view my omission from the card as further cruelty—especially since I was the archiver within the family. The whole photo card was originally my idea. I was also the “attention to details” person within the family. Translation—I made sure hair was combed, shirts were tucked in, everyone was smiling, I checked the energy within the shot, etc. That was not Veeby’s strength… she seemingly just didn’t have an eye for those details. Within the picture that Veeby chose to represent “her and her gang”—the front zipper on Noelle’s pantsuit was actually open in the picture…it was the second thing I noticed, after noticing I wasn’t in the shot. Eliana told me later that she asked mom prior to taking the pictures if she would be using them for Holiday cards and that Dad should be in the picture. Using the semantical games she enjoyed so much, Veeby stated, “No, these are just to share with my friends.” Veeby then asked Mark to create the Holiday card on the computer, told him what words to type and then sent it out to her [limited] email distribution list as her Holiday card. I had the Master email distribution list on my computer…she didn’t ask me for it since she wasn’t including me in the picture. I only found out that she’d sent the card because she emailed it to my parents, who then forwarded me a copy. Wow! Was she trying to be covert, or just blatantly didn’t care if I found out? Perhaps she was hoping it would sting when I discovered her joyous Holiday card? Yep, I was more than a little upset. Being erased from the family I created with Veeby…my family…didn’t feel very good at all. That particular year would have been the year to have not sent out a photo Holiday card, per her earlier preference. That would have been statement enough that things were changing for us. Instead, she declared to our family and friends the end of us, by my omission from our Holiday card. Again, how amazingly cruel. What happened to the person who had “washed up on a beach of love” only several weeks earlier? The Beach of Love Girl became upset with my parents for having sent me a copy of her Holiday card. Within their communications, my parents reminded her that “Limited communication will continue to produce limited understanding of actions and intent.” Unfortunately, Veeby continued her preference of CONTROL through “limited communication”…which indeed produced terribly “limited understanding” for our family, friends and myself as we went forward in the journey.

12 Baby Car

We bought our blue baby car when it was brand new. We gave it every ding and scratch—it was our dirt. Long since paid off, it was a stick shift and had power when we needed it. We both loved baby car. We discussed the division of our two cars in preparation for the separation—one newer and one older—and Veeby elected to keep the older baby car. Several weeks later, she needed me to transfer the title to her so she could sell it to our mechanic. Wait, WHAT? This was a change from what we discussed. She reframed her decision to keep baby car as “John left me with the old car and I needed something more reliable.” Initially concerned with not taking on the additional expense of monthly car payments, Veeby then re-spun her tale into “He left me the old run down car.” S M O K E & M I R R O R S I wasn’t happy about her selling baby car. She never expressed her “needing something more reliable.” I would have taken baby car and enjoyed having no payments for awhile. She didn’t communicate about it…she just did. I signed the car’s Title over to her and gave it to her. Of course, I didn’t do that the way she thought it should have been done. So, I had to jump through more hoops. Then, I wrote her an email: Veeby, Regarding baby car, I wish you would have spoken with me about your decision to sell the car. The last time we spoke about the distribution of cars, we decided together to let you have baby car so you wouldn’t incur monthly payments. We did not speak of baby car being in any way undependable. I would have been more than willing to have kept baby car...with no monthly payments...if you felt like you wanted our newer car with payments as a more dependable car. Communication with me would have been appreciated, Veeby. Today’s Car Title stuff: Just so we are clear, I did not fill out the Title incorrectly. I gave the car to you and filled in the bottom portion of the form correctly, as directed by Sharon [whom we met with today]. Of course I don’t mind trying to help you save money and not get a new title to only then sell to our mechanic—I understand the concept. I just don’t sell cars regularly and needed to run this information past Sharon to more fully understand what you were requesting and it’s impact on me. [BTW: it cost me to get a copy of the Title to give to you, which I’ve absorbed, and don’t mind doing so]. Slow down, Veeby…breathe. Veeby sold baby car and then purchased a new car, with payments. Later, she would gloat: I am trading up…having fun…got the better deal…I feel like I’ve turned in all my old models and upgraded to new and improved ones!! Putting 2+2 together = baby car and I were the “old models.” I still get to see baby car at our mechanics shop. Baby car still has the dented front left fender from when Eliana backed out of the garage. Our mechanic always comments how it’s a great little car! [We borrowed baby car several years later to let Mark learn to drive on her.] Once Veeby had her new car, I asked about her monthly payment—simply to update our 55/45 spreadsheet. She texted me: John, You don’t need to worry about my bills. Alrighty, then—I was slowly catching on—Plan A was changing.

13 Christmas 2007

During a normal Holiday Season, we would have gotten our Christmas tree the weekend after Thanksgiving, and let it’s smell and visual sensations put us in a festive mood during December. However, our family knew that year was not going to be any shade of festive. To me, it felt like being on Death Row—watching the rest of the world enjoy the Holidays while holding the knowledge that they remained oblivious to the upcoming end of your life. Since Veeby laid on the beaches in France for a week, we needed to wait for mom’s return before buying our Christmas tree. By the time she got back, most of the trees had been sold. It was almost too late. Mom got busy on the phone and found a grocery store with one remaining tree, for $10. Veeby reserved it sight unseen…“We’ll be right there!” The kids and I discovered rather quickly that we couldn’t take mom’s car. She had a new car, and the tree needles might make a mess in her clean trunk. So, we took my car. The two oldest girls didn’t care to go, so Mark, mom and I loaded up to go get our Christmas Tree. It certainly was not a joyous or festive ride to the store. I don’t think anyone spoke. Once we arrived, we found the Customer Service desk where they were holding our “reserved” tree. Oh, My—the tree reminded us of that pitiful Charlie Brown Christmas tree. We were use to big full trees each year. This was the sickly runt of the litter Christmas tree. Mark and I laughed out loud…mom wasn’t laughing. Mom stood in line to pay the $10 while Mark and I placed our poor little Christmas tree inside a shopping cart and rolled towards the car to load it in. We laughed and sang O Christmas Tree, O Christmas Tree all the way to the car. We didn’t need to strap the trunk down—the entire tree fit very nicely inside with room to spare. Mom eventually arrived to the car after Mark and I were finished loading the tree. About to drive away and still laughing, I commented to Veeby, “We’ve never bought a $10 tree before.” She replied, “You still haven’t [bought the tree].” We stopped laughing. I asked her if she wanted money towards the cost of the tree [my $5]? She replied she didn’t want anything from me. Alrighty, then! The ride back home was very quiet. Mark and I continued to laugh about the entire experience for many weeks afterwards.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2008 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

14 Happy New Year…I Want a Divorce!

January 1st—Happy New Year! I received an “I need to speak to you” text from Veeby. Oh, No—that didn’t sound good. Getting “spoken to” was a whole lot different than “speaking with” someone. In the days since her decision to end us, we’d spoken about taking a year of Separation for Healing and we developed our Plan A. We concluded that my being in a separate [yet smaller] place during that time would allow me to pay 55% of their household expense, thus enabling her and the children to stay in our house. Even though I didn’t want the Separation, I was trying to be an understanding partner. I was being a nice guy…[what’s that saying about nice guys?]. We thought it best to not make any major life changing decisions in the new year—i.e., selling the house, moving kids, actually filing for divorce, etc. We were trying to be “amicable” but we didn’t really know anything about how to “do” the divorce process. Having been together for 33+ years, we would figure out that “divorce stuff” in the future. Indeed, Veeby spoke to my family and our friends…stating each time the words that we were “Separated.” Yet, Commanded to appear before her presence, I arrived. Queen Veeby then Proclaimed she had lawyered up and was moving on with the divorce. Wait…WHAT? I had only moved out of the house one month before to begin our year of Separation and Healing! Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? She continued speaking—that we needed to have a sit down meeting in order to hear all the details and asked, “How does next Wednesday look in your schedule?” She was definitely presenting herself as Large and In Charge. I was taken aback. I’ll probably never know exactly what, but something happened to Veeby towards the end of 2007. Perhaps someone suggested our Plan A was a bad idea, or not how normal divorces worked? Just days before Christmas, she described part of Plan A to my sister: “…he still comes by here two times a week to teach his piano students and plays on his piano.” Please note that the piano was mine—which was true—until the lawyers turned it into a “marital asset.”

15 Sage Smudge Cleansing Ceremony

Veeby began burning incense and candles around the house in the late Fall. With the coming of the New Year, she was finally ready to cleanse “her” house from any remaining negative energies. With friends whispering guidance in her ear, she performed a pagan cleansing ritual, using sage smudge. To further erase me [seemingly], and keep future negative energy from passing over the thresholds of “her” house, she poured what appeared to be salt around the doors in a “KEEP OUT” semi-circle —perhaps placing boundaries the evil spirits couldn’t cross? I don’t know, it just seemed a little weird. This is how my music students were greeted when they arrived for their first lesson in the new year—they had to walk over salt on the front stoop to come inside. There were piles of salt on either side of the front door to the house! Veeby was there and I asked her about it. She said it wasn’t any of my business and that it would eventually be washed away. So, I took her cue, got a bucket from the garage, filled it with water and washed it all away myself. I had students arriving for lessons and didn’t want to explain the weird entry way. I must admit taking the Cleansing Ceremony very personally. It hurt me to think she needed to cleanse me from her life. I didn’t feel that way about her.

16 Veeby's Lawyer #1

Veeby sought legal consultation and eventual representation from one of her office complex neighbors. A relative newbie lawyer, which I’ll call Lawyer #1, she was the first of what would eventually become six (6) different lawyers my “Ex” would utilize throughout the saga. I researched Lawyer #1’s credentials online, but never met or interacted with her. Lawyer #1 would ultimately have a short shelf life for Veeby’s legal needs. While Veeby described herself as separated and needing information regarding a divorce, an interesting thread emerged in their discussions. Since I dabbled in creating acrylic oil paintings, Veeby felt entitled to a percentage of any sales of my paintings…and a copyright ownership percentage…and wanted to maintain control as to whom I could bequeath them to in my Last Will and Testament, should I meet an untimely death. Wait, WHAT? Perhaps I should have hired some security guards to protect me from being killed off, which would make my paintings more valuable. Perhaps that was her plan? Significantly, Veeby told Lawyer #1 she made less than half her actual income. Mere days before, Veeby filled out the Child Support Guidelines Worksheet for our Plan A using her “real” income amounts and arrived at the 55/45 split. All of a sudden, she “lost” more than 50% of income? Plugging her “new” income amounts back into the same Worksheet tipped the scales to a creative different split of household income. “Presto, Change-O”…meet the new and improved 80/20 split…improved for Veeby…detrimental to me. S M O K E & M I R R O R S There is no evidence of a lawyer recommending she lie about her income. Veeby made that decision entirely on her own. Whomever was whispering in her ear, making suggestions or whatever, the weight of Veeby’s decision to lie about her income rests squarely on her shoulders. By skewing the financial numbers in her favor, I’m sure Veeby thought she could “work the system” and get more money out of me. Then there was Veeby’s propensity to play semantical games. She told Lawyer #1 “I gave him $4K back in November to ‘help’ him with all his expense in leaving—so he has money.” That was misleading to her new lawyer, since I’d already informed Veeby the month before the exact amounts I’d spent towards first and last month’s rent, security deposit and new furniture. All that “buffer” money was gone…it was used to get me out of “her” house. I screamed my head off when I became aware of her 80/20 split.

17 List of Demands

The Queen’s appointed Wednesday rolled around and per Her Majesties’ request, we met outside our favorite juice bar, where we use to go after aerobic classes. Veeby had changed her mind from our agreed Plan A and was about to tell me her new version, called “Filing for Divorce.” She brought a manila folder filled with documents and her list of items to “discuss.” I brought no documents. I planned to sit back, clasp my hands and just listen. While she presented herself as being in control at the meeting—trying to remain “cool and calm”—all the items Veeby spoke about were contrary to what she and I had agreed to before I moved out. Curiously, as she mentioned our children, they were either her children, or my children, but never our children. She handed me some paper and a pen, to write notes. Later, I saw what she actually handed me. I was to write my notes on the blank back side of her handwritten Child Support Guidelines Worksheet—the very form on which she wrote her “real” income and then used to figure out Plan A’s household expenses split. I’d never seen the actual form, I just went with her 55/45 calculations. She began by stating that she was most concerned about Mark, who was only 11-years-old at that time…which she mentioned six more times during the meeting. She didn’t want him to be hurt emotionally or physically by either of us. As if sitting a child down to tell them how things were about to change in their life, she began listing everything she wanted…her List of Demands. Here are a few highlights: Child Support: She needed our tax returns for the last three years, since Child Support would be based on our incomes. She’d already figured out that I would be responsible for 80% of the children’s upkeep, so I should just count on that! [oh yeah, she lowered her income amounts so I got bumped up to 80%…yippee!] Alimony: She would be requesting Alimony—FOREVER. She’d put 33+ years into our relationship and I owed her! She was NOT going to EVER get married again because she wanted my money! [which she declared while wagging her finger at me.] Visitation: She was agreeable to “work with me” regarding my developing and continuing a relationship with our kids [Thank you, Goddess]. However, the continuing relationship can not occur at “her” house any longer...it’s inappropriate and confusing to “her” children. [What?] As long as I coordinated with her [i.e., ask permission]. Retirement Funds: She wanted half! [We didn’t have much, but I later learned that splitting in half was the law, so it was really a non-issue.] Life Insurance: She had already taken me off her Life Insurance as a Beneficiary. However, she “expected” me to carry a Life Insurance policy, and name her as Beneficiary. She said when I died, she wanted that money. House Assets: She was “open” to dividing up “our stuff.” She specifically mentioned the big screen TV and the acoustic piano [both of which I purchased with money from a big project I’d done]. However, since she considered those as “house assets,” she wanted half of the money if I were to sell them. [New legal sounding words…she’d been talking to someone.] Garage Opener: She wanted the “clicker” back. [Not really a highlight, but funny she asked for the “clicker” back.] Files: She told me to return some files and folders that I’d stolen. [They were simply files and folders we kept in my filing cabinets which I’d moved to the condo—i.e., pet info, mortgage info, etc. Nothing was “stolen.”] Baby Books: She wanted our children’s early “Baby” books back...for her to keep. [Again, we simply kept them in the same filing cabinets.] House and Upkeep: It became “her” house, but she wanted it written into the divorce paperwork that I would be responsible for at least half of it’s upkeep. She wanted to be able to keep or sell the house at her discretion, without having to consult me. Yet, she would graciously allow me to get half of the profits if and when she sold it. [Thank you, Goddess]. Braces: She acknowledged that I was currently paying 55% of Noelle’s braces. She said Mark would also need braces and wanted it documented that I would be responsible for paying at least half of that future expense. Taxes: Veeby told me that for tax year 2007, she would be filing as Head of Household and taking both kids as deductions. She told me that I could file as married, but filing separately. [PERIOD!] Joint Bank Account: She wanted to close our banking accounts as soon as possible. Post Office Box: She brought up that she’d had the box for 14 years and then, acknowledged “as have you”—and we needed to figure out what to do. I told her I wanted to keep it for me [I assumed she didn’t want to continue sharing it] and that my music business was listed in industry databases with that PO Box address. Then, she closed her manila folder, but continued: Paintings and Copyrights: Veeby acknowledged that monies garnered on all of my acrylic oil paintings created while we were together could be used in lieu of Child Support—IF they were worth something—which they were not, but maybe someday they might be. However, since they weren’t worth anything right then, she wanted it written into the divorce paperwork that upon my death, all the copyrights and ownership for all my creative pursuits from the past, but also anything in the future, were directed to be given to my biological children. [CONTROL!] I told her that issue was already taken care of within my Will. Apparently, it didn’t matter to Veeby. She was concerned that I might acquire another partner, that the new partner and I might adopt children and I might be encouraged on my death bed to change my Will to exclude Eliana, Noelle and Mark. She presented a paranoid scenario that somehow, someone would contest my Will and it might be deemed as invalid—and she’s just trying to protect Eliana, Noelle and Mark. [Did I already mention the CONTROL theme?] Oh, yeah…she also wanted a financial portion of some “to be determined” percentage of all my creative works up to that point—you know, just for the time she had been my partner. [Anything else, Babe? A gallon of blood, perhaps?] Teaching: She mentioned that she was really Happy. She mentioned how happy she was three (3) times. Apparently, she was also Thriving…and finally at Peace. She hoped that I was happy that she was happy and thriving and at peace—OMG! However, part of her continued happiness meant I could no longer teach at “her” house. I would have to find another place to teach my piano lessons. REALLY? She then ended our little meeting by saying that all I needed to do was agree to her Demands, her lawyer would draw up the papers, and I could simply sign the forms and be done—poof! [I’m sure this somehow all made sense from her perspective. I should just “do” what she said, like our past normal dance steps—and she would go on her merry way, dancing a happy little jig.] I was amazed. I was dumbfounded. I hadn’t spoken much…there was no point, no need. Veeby had all the answers she needed. Again, she acted like she was Large and In Charge. Without further fanfare, we both walked to our respective cars. It was crystal clear to me—we were DONE. As I tried to back out of my parking space, she pulled up behind me in her car and blocked me in for about 30 seconds. I lowered my window and called out to her, “What are you doing?” Veeby held up her hand in the “I Love You” sign and yelled back to me, “You’ve lost your mind, John”—then sped off. My observations? Veeby was making a major assumption that she was going to “keep” the kids and I would get to visit. This was completely opposite our verbal agreements within Plan A. Plus, we had 20 years of Co-Parenting history with our children. I worked from the house and was always around our kids. It was a horribly unfair presumption…that she would keep the two remaining children and exclude me from their daily lives. Visitation? We had never used that word—it was a “divorce” word—someone else probably placed that word in her mind. Plus, that was no longer the model since we lived in a Joint Custody state. There was no more “Primary Parent” with the other parent only receiving “Visitation.” The laws had thankfully changed. Each parent had the right to continue to be involved in their children’s lives. Veeby was in for a rude awakening. The house was OUR house, not “her” house. Both she and I were named parties on the Deed = it was our house. Since we had refinanced the house several years earlier under just her name, she had obviously forgotten or was confused. We could only afford to live in the house because I was making the mortgage payments, not Veeby. We were legitimately deducting 25% of our household expenses on our taxes because I taught piano lessons and had my dedicated music studio there. Evidently, she began to think the house was hers alone, since I didn’t “live” there anymore? She was trying to prevent me from coming and going as I pleased. Even though we’d agreed to my teaching at the house two days a week, she’d begun to reframe it that she was “allowing” me to teach there. S M O K E & M I R R O R S I felt duped! I had agreed to Plan A parameters before I moved out, but then Veeby changed the agreement, with terrible consequences for me. It appeared I was going to be stuck in a one bedroom condo for a year and unable to teach from the new condo per their association rules. I would have gotten a bigger residence that allowed me to house the kids and had space to teach if I’d known Veeby was going to do this. While our Plan A was only a verbal discussion and agreement between her and I, it existed. Why on earth would I have moved into a small condo that wasn’t big enough for my grand piano or roomy enough to teach lessons? Why wouldn’t I have chosen a place with adequate bedrooms for my kids to live with me half the time? • • • • • Regarding her expectation of receiving monthly Alimony, I never expected either of us would pay or receive it. Veeby and I earned close to the same amounts…both had Master’s degrees, both were relatively young and both had a reasonable expectation of continuing to make a decent income within our chosen professions. When I input Plan A “real” income amounts into a couple of Alimony Predictor tools I found online, it was another non-issue. They stated, “It Is Very Unlikely That You Would Pay or Receive Alimony.” Only when Veeby changed her financial amounts could she make the argument for her receiving Alimony—which is probably why she changed her amounts—although, that would be deceptive and manipulative and lying, right? My original acrylic oil paintings…those were my babies…each one just as important as each of our children. Mere words are not enough to convey the disdain and contempt I felt towards Veeby for trying to take them…or any portion…from me. • • • • • Veeby seemed to be disconnected from the realities of where we were in the process of divorce. Although she had changed the rules from Plan A to her “Filing for Divorce,” the reality was neither of us had filed any legal paperwork. We were not legally Separated or anything. Still, Veeby happily broadcast to friends that she had, “…tons to tell you…my great vacation in beautiful France, my upcoming divorce settlement, my newfound strength and happiness….” [The word “delusional” came to mind.] There was no divorce settlement in place—just her Demands and how she thought it would play out. She assumed I wouldn’t stand up for myself because I rarely did. My preference to keep the peace through deference was our regular dance. Veeby wanted me to agree to her Demands, sign some papers and then support her in the style to which she’d like to become accustomed. She gleefully relayed the entire meeting: …I spoke with John yesterday and gave him all my requirements for the divorce. He didn’t say anything which is typical him, he just kept looking at me…It took all my strength not to let it get to me. I think I was pretty cool and calm. We’ll see if he wants to fight me on it or not. I told him he needed to find another place to teach. This week he would play around on his piano when he had a break between piano students. It was driving me crazy having to listen to him and I knew he was doing it to get to me. He also came to the dinner table where I was eating with the kids and sat down with us. I didn’t offer him anything to eat ;) Anyway, soon it will be over! Look how surprised she was that I would “dare” come and sit down with the family…our family…MY family. When one of my students was running late to lesson and I had some time until he arrived, I walked a few feet around the corner and sat down with my family in the kitchen while they were eating. I was working—I was earning money to pay the bills and support our family. Look how proud Veeby was that she didn’t offer me any food and wouldn’t be nice to me. Boastful about her incivility? I wondered what had happened to Veeby? I thought she’d refreshed herself during vacation on the beaches of France? • • • • • The next day, I did what I thought I was supposed to do—I closed our joint banking accounts. Apparently, I couldn’t even do that correctly! It’s so hard to get good help these days. John, You are mistaken, I DID NOT request that you to close our joint banking accounts…. Among the over 20 things I spoke to you about the divorce proceedings…was that we would have to talk in the FUTURE as part of the divorce agreement how we would pay the house bills which are payed automatically out of the joint checking account. You closed that account WITHOUT TELLING ME, I was not informed and I EMPHATICALLY STATE THAT I DID NOT GIVE MY CONSENT TO CLOSE THE JOINT CHECKING ACCOUNTS! …when I spoke with you I gave you a list of demands I wanted to negotiate as part of working amicably with you in filing for the divorce. Your response was to close our joint checking accounts without my consent?…. …I want the real estate papers and mortgage papers to the house which you took when you moved out, I also want the tax bill and real estate appraisal, which you have. I spoke to you also about getting copies of your life insurance and tax returns for the last three years. Please provide me with these requests. How were we amicably working out her List of Demands? I began to realize that the process of divorcing was like a game. It was the Game of Divorce—a strategic game that Veeby would play to win. I don’t like games very much. However, I don’t think the end game turned out like Veeby envisioned: Me = destitute and homeless. Her = using the majority of my income to help her live a Happy, Thriving and Peaceful life.

18 Hired Myself a Lawyer

It seemed like a good time to hire a divorce lawyer—who immediately asked me WHY ON EARTH [think lower] did I move out of the marital house? Why hadn’t I called her before doing that? Since I didn’t know the Game of Divorce, I hired Carol to represent me. She was good…I got me a good one! We met and I told her everything. In answer to her original question, I left the marital home as an expression of my love and caring for a hurting partner, with the understanding we were taking a self-imposed Separation. However, Veeby’s recent words and actions had begun to reframe my leaving as “John left us,” which was not the case. In the world of “spin,” Veeby was good at it, and very loud. Indeed, that was one of Carol’s major concerns—that I was being painted as having “abandoned my wife and children, which fed into Veeby’s claiming the house as her own. Apparently, my loving gesture to move out of the marital house was not a “smart” legal move. It seemed our Plan A had not included something called a Non-Abandonment Agreement which generally provided that during a separation, one spouse could leave the marital house without fear of being accused by the other spouse with abandonment of the spouse or children. I didn’t know what I didn’t know. Within our little Game of Divorce, I told Carol about Veeby’s recent “change in income” move. I also had proof of the manipulative change, but Carol said we needed to hold off on that for awhile. Veeby’s latest decree that I would not be “allowed” back in the marital house to teach, although my studio equipment and grand piano were still inside, made the situation much more complicated. I depended on teaching income to help pay all our bills, plus my new additional “rent” at the condo. I scrambled to find another location to teach my piano students—just another Veeby hurdle to jump over. I didn’t have funds to rent an additional teaching space, my condo would not allow me to teach there, local churches I contacted had liability concerns, plus I needed to remain in the same city for my clientele. What to do, what to do? I could no longer discuss options with Veeby since she’d clearly laid claim to the house. One of our last discussions at the marital house—when she was finished talking [and to then end our dialogue]— she threatened to call the police to have me removed from “her” property. There wasn’t enough income to pay my Plan A percentage towards their household expenses, plus my rent and expenses at the new condo, plus rent somewhere to teach. Holding up a protective shield against Veeby’s verbal abandonment accusations was getting tiring. Only one solution seemed to solve the dilemma: I needed to move back into the marital house.a Can you say…F I R E W O R K S ?

19 Locked Out of the Mailbox

The day after the List of Demands meeting, while I was doing what I thought I had been tasked to do—close our joint bank accounts—Veeby was doing exactly what I had asked her not to do…she locked me out of our Post Office Box. I hadn’t spoken much during the previous days’ meeting, but had told her I wanted to keep the PO Box. Of course, in the world of Veeby, that immediately translated into, “Oh, he WANTS this? All right, I’ll take that thing away first.” It took me a couple of weeks to figure out that I was no longer receiving mail. After I moved out, Veeby regularly checked the postal box, brought the mail home, left any mail addressed to me on the piano, and I picked up my mail when I came over. However, I was waiting for some music scores to be delivered—to accompany some violinists for an upcoming audition—which seemingly got “lost” in the mail. I asked Veeby about it, she claimed she hadn’t seen any packages, so I eventually went to the post office to check—only to discover what Veeby had done. When we originally moved into the area, Veeby arrived a few weeks earlier than me to set things up. Evidently, she’d opened the box under just her name and added my name later. Therefore, she was considered the box “owner”, and was able to simply take my name off the box and change the lock. Of course, she never informed me of that—I just stopped getting mail. So much for all those “time sensitive” musical scores I was waiting for. I later learned that she had received the packages, but hid them for several weeks. I rented a new PO Box for myself, located just four boxes over from “her” [our] box. However, any mail addressed to my company name would still go to the old box, which was under her control, and only Veeby could fill out the permanent change of address form to forward my company mail to my new box. I wondered what the chances were that she’d fill out that form? What’s that saying about hell freezing over? I didn’t mind the separation of our lives, and all the various accounts, but some communication about my mail would have been…civil. • • • • • Veeby was seemingly not very attentive to the details…or maybe she was. One of her next “moves” was to stop mail from being delivered to the marital house address, even though she and the children were living there. She filled out a postal Change of Address Form, selected a Permanent Forward Type, and incorrectly indicated it was a Family Move. Therefore, all mail addressed to any family member using the same last name would be forwarded to her PO Box. Well, what about my mail? She could have had my mail forwarded to my new condo address, or my new postal box, but she elected to forward it to her PO Box—which she could then CONTROL. Upon learning of this Game of Divorce move, I went online and correctly changed the Forwarding Order with the postal service so that mail addressed to her and the children would go to her postal box, and mail addressed to me would go to my postal box. Simple…at least it should have been.

20 Visitation?

As the end of 2007 turned into the beginning of 2008, Visitation became a much bigger theme for Veeby. I supposed it was a further manifestation of her global need for CONTROL. Right before Christmas, Veeby verbally assaulted me at the house, claiming that since I did not live there anymore, I could not simply come and go as I pleased [although I was still teaching there in December]. I could no longer come to see the kids at the house, but needed to take them to my condo. Also, I should really be spending much more time with the children! She accused me of “cheating her out of Alimony” [although we had already discussed the subject]. Eliana was already home from college for Winter Break by then and overheard that entire conversation from the hallway, and later commented to me how cruel mom had been. When Veeby was finished with her end of the conversation, she informed me to leave “her” house or she would call the police to have me escorted off the property. Wow…she seemed a little agitated. Typically, I didn’t teach during Winter Break, so I wasn’t seeing Eliana, Noelle and Mark as much during those weeks. The tension from Veeby when I was over at the house was measurable. One of the kids texted me: Hey, mom is pushing for us to hang out with you, but outside the home so you don’t come over. I’m not gonna stop you from coming and going, I just thought you should know she talked to us. I think it kind of shocked the children that Veeby was trying to get them to not allow their Dad to come over. The problem was due to our Plan A agreement—I was not living in a place that was set up to hang out with my children. We had agreed I would be doing that at the marital house. However, when I tried to hang out with Mark over at my place—for pizza and a movie—I still ran into problems! Veeby was ticked off that I hadn’t asked her “permission” but merely informed her of our plans. Veeby became the self-appointed “gatekeeper” in all matters concerning the kids and wouldn’t “allow” the visit. She texted me: John, I asked u to run visitation with Mark through me until we determine a set schedule. I told Mark so tonight. Please respect my wishes. By the time Christmas Day arrived, Queen Veeby “allowed” me to “visit” with our children for one hour—to open presents—but, only one hour. After all the presents had been opened, she told me she would call the police if I didn’t leave “her” house immediately. Happy Holidays, indeed. It seemed I just couldn’t win for trying. In Veeby’s world, everything would be just fine, provided she controlled when I could see our children. It had never been that way in our marriage, but she’d begun to enjoy her newly learned “My Way or the Highway” dance steps. • • • • • Perhaps her assessment I was a Cat, when she really wanted a Dog, was beginning to bother her? After all, I was no longer rolling over like the “good little dog” she longed for—allowing her to kick me around at her whim. Veeby was definitely trying to kick me! She seemed furious that I no longer “obeyed” her commands, like I had done for so long in our relationship. I had discovered and was beginning to “use my voice” by barking back—essentially “standing up to her”—which evidently ticked her off even more. Which was kind of funny, since she had wanted me to challenge and debate her points of view within various “discussions” throughout our years together. I felt like she was treating me like a “bad little dog”—that needed to be whacked on the nose with a rolled up newspaper until I obeyed again. Things were about to explode. Just like when Mount St. Helens volcano blew her top, the crater was getting larger, the intensity was building and the molten earth had been slowly showing it’s true intent. With one final text before plums of ash would fill the sky, Veeby wrote: John, If u want to fight we can. Think of your children before you go down that path. I could only imagine what the next day would bring: the eruption… the spewing of verbal lava… the absolute melt down…. B O O M !

21 Moving Back In

Thursday evening, I received an email alert from our home security company, reminding me their technician would be arriving the next day at the marital house address to reset the system and change the Master Password…per Veeby’s request. Wait…WHAT? Securing her castle [the marital home] became a high priority for Veeby. Not only did she want my garage door remote control back, but she was chomping at the bit to change the locks for the entire house. I later learned she had been advised against that, thankfully. Evidently, she figured out a work around and made arrangements to do the next best thing—she arranged to change the home security system password to prevent my entry. • • • • • I was about to take the extraordinary step of moving back into our marital house. The newest Veeby Commandment… Thou Shalt Not Teach at the Marital House …had backed me into a financial corner. Her unilateral decision negatively impacted my ability to continue my teaching studio. I felt it was punitive and very short-sighted on her part, but I needed to quickly figure out a solution. After consultation with my legal counsel, Carol, the only option that seemed to solve all the parameters of my dilemma was to move back in. I was pretty sure Veeby would not be happy with my decision. I enlisted the help of my friend, Ryan. Early Friday morning, we loaded his van for the first of three trips. I had more stuff now, since I’d bought furniture. I planned on moving only a few pieces back into the guest bedroom, until the end of the month, and then I would bring the rest over from the condo. Moving back meant I needed to break my Lease at the condo. I lost my last month’s rent. Thankfully, the rental agency worked with me and that’s all I lost. They could have enforced the year’s lease. Trying to avoid an altercation, Ryan and I waited until the middle of day—at such time, Veeby usually would have already left for work. However, as we rolled up, Veeby was standing in the front yard with the dog. DRATS! As Ryan backed into the driveway to unload, I hopped out and opened the garage door. I knew we kept some baseball bats just inside, and I didn’t want Veeby freaking out and bashing in Ryan’s van. I tossed them around the corner and into the bushes. As Veeby was trying to figure out what was going on, I walked up to her and (1) told her I was moving back in, (2) said if she had any questions she could call my lawyer, and (3) handed her Carol’s card. Of course, Veeby wouldn’t take the business card, so later I placed it beside her purse on the kitchen counter. Since Veeby was standing on the stoop by the front door, Ryan and I entered through the garage, and walked into the dining room. I didn’t want the dog and cat getting outside as we brought things inside from the van, so I put them in one of the back bedrooms and shut the door. Ryan and I began moving the existing dining room table and chairs into the garage. I planned on turning that area into my temporary office, since we didn’t use the formal dining room. We made sure everything was neatly organized in the garage, and there was still room for Veeby’s car to park inside. Ryan and I also moved furniture around in Eliana’s old bedroom, which by then was considered the Guest Room. I planned to make it my temporary bedroom. Veeby was—in the most diplomatic of phrasing—“noticeably upset” during all of this. She was yelling loudly and was on the phone with the police. She told them her ex-husband had come into the house without her permission [(1) We were still married, no legal paperwork had been filed, and I was not yet her “ex.”; and (2) I didn’t need her permission—since my name was on the Deed—to simply enter OUR house.] She told the dispatcher I was moving things out of the house. I kept explaining to her that I was moving back in, and we were simply moving things to the garage. She was swearing at me that I had no right to come into “her” house. I took a moment and tried to calmly explain, but rational and logical conversation was not being heard in that particular moment. So, Ryan and I just kept bringing my things inside from the van. Veeby left the house to take solace with our next door neighbors. [One of the bigger items I brought back over was my studio isolation Sound Booth. It was heavy, so Ryan and I had to carry the individual panels together. An important thread that will be discussed more in-depth later.] The police arrived—three squad cars, two males and one female officers. I must admit my heart was racing. My mouth went dry as I explained to an officer what was going on. Veeby told the female officer that I was moving things out of the house, and that she had not yet changed the locks—conveniently omitting that she had just changed the security code that morning—in essence, locking me out. Ryan correctly stated he was “just a friend with a van” when the third officer questioned him about his involvement. No laws were broken and it was just a very loud verbal disagreement. The police officially labeled the incident as a “Domestic Disturbance.” We had never had anything like that happen in our 33+ years together. • • • • • Veeby wasn’t happy about my moving back in, and I wasn’t happy about it, either. The officers left and wrote the following report: POLICE REPORT Veeby advised her ex-husband is coming into the house. they are verbal—possibly physical Veeby is yelling at him—telling him that he has no rights to the house vehicle in driveway is occupied by a friend of suspect male is moving things around in the house. Veeby and John had a verbal argument over moving possessions from inside their house. Veeby advised they are still legally married but are filing for divorce. I advised Veeby and John that they cannot remove items from the house since they are still married. Veeby also stated her attorney advised she could change the locks so John could not enter. I advised Veeby that she was not allowed to change the locks since John is still her husband. The argument was verbal and no one was injured. Ryan and I finished unloading the first van full of stuff, so we left to load up again. By the time we got back, Veeby was gone [thankfully]. Of course, she’d activated the security system and I didn’t have the new code. We rolled in with another van full of my things, I unlocked the house door and entered the house. The alarm went off, of course! Gosh, that was a piercing sound. I no longer knew the code to disarm, the security company called Veeby’s cell and she told them to call the police [of course]. I called the security company from the house land line—trying to turn off the alarm which was very loud and frustrating. Ryan and I couldn’t stop the alarm, so we just began to unload the van. We figured the police would arrive at some point. Sure enough, the police showed up, but only two cruisers that time. They checked our ID’s and we explained what all was going on. Eventually, the security company turned off the alarm [thank goodness], the officers left, we finished unloading and then drove back to the condo to grab the third and final load. Arriving back at the house with the last of my “stuff” for the day, the alarm went off when we entered the house…again…REALLY? I got back on the phone with the security folks and they led me through disconnecting the battery back-up, which appeared to be the culprit that kept re-arming the system. Alarm was disengaged and…it was quiet…yeah! Police arrived again…only one officer…I knew they would begin to figure it out. Moved the final piece of furniture back into the house and…done. Thanks, Ryan! • • • • • Veeby was still at work and the house was relatively quiet when the children came home from school to find “Dad’s moved back in…Yeah!” I explained a little bit to the kids, all the while knowing Mom would soon arrive back home and have a different perspective to share. Veeby’s sister and [newest] brother-in-law heralded the return of the Queen to the castle later in the afternoon. The new brother-in-law was a nice guy, but he was tasked with placing all new door handles, featuring locks requiring keys, on the Master bedroom and my old studio doors. Noelle and Mark each received a new doorknob with a “pop” lock. An air of paranoia wafted through the house. I had simply moved back in—that was all. Veeby was not in a space to listen or have a discussion as to why I needed this variation from our Plan A—which really was simply in reaction to her variation from our Plan A. She quickly laid down the “Fear” card from the Game of Divorce deck. Her fear seemed driven by her Power of Belief that she was in mortal danger. That became her official strategy—one she would pursue with a vengeance—often times painting herself into a corner. Really, though, Veeby was just ticked off—since I hadn’t obeyed the newest rules she was trying to impose. Later that evening, she made sure I knew she was upset. • • • • • I set up my office stuff in our formal dining room, which was adjacent to the living room where I taught piano lessons so there would be zero impact to the flow of our family life. I wouldn’t mind coexisting for a time while Veeby and I figured out how to make the finances work with her new rules. Since we had turned Eliana’s room into a Guest room when she left for college, I knew I could crash there with little or no impact as well. Other than one small little issue—i.e., it wasn’t how Veeby envisioned her new Happy, Thriving and Peaceful life—my plan seemed rational and solid. I was tired, since it had been a long and emotional day. Veeby arrived home after work, was mad and not talking—another Silent Treatment Tango had begun. While changing all the locks was a new and different move, I trusted in our familiar dance steps and knew the next day would bring calm. Veeby and I would have a chance to talk the next day. I turned in early and quickly fell sound asleep. At 10:45 pm I was abruptly awakened as Veeby began trying to gain entry into the Guest room. It appeared I had slept through the calm period and awakened in the middle of a storm. Knowing she was ticked, I had locked the door, which proved to be a wise decision. At first, Veeby was simply trying to “pop” the lock open with a paper clip or something, but when she couldn’t make that work, she began BANGING on the door. It sounded like she used a bat, and demanded that I open up the door so she could “get her things.” I told her—through the locked door—I’d been sleeping and she’d awakened me. I asked her what she needed, but she just repeated “Open the door” and “I want to get my things.” My heart was racing—from a deep sleep to absolutely racing. I told her to let me know what she needed to which she replied, “Oh, NOW you want to talk?” Truthfully, the way she was acting—I was scared to open the door. I wasn’t sure what she might do, but I knew there was nothing of “hers” in the Guest room. I texted both Noelle and Mark and asked them to call the police. I could hear both kids were in their bedrooms, which were adjacent to the Guest room, and were listening to Mom scream and beat at the door. Since the police had already been called to the house on three separate occasions earlier that day, I didn’t want to call them again, but I also felt Veeby was out of control. I believed if I opened the door, she would have been violent towards me…with that bat. She was acting more unusual than normal. Mark texted back that he didn’t want to get involved and Noelle never replied. When Veeby finally gave up trying to access the Guest room, she walked away from the door area while yelling, “I hope you don’t care about your computer.” A moment later, I heard her dragging cables across the marble floors towards “her” Master bedroom. I discovered the next morning those cables were attached to my computer monitor! She took my very expensive computer monitor—and locked it up in “her” room. Luckily, I’d kept my laptop with me in the Guest room. After the Veeby storm seemingly subsided for the evening, my heart raced for another 45 minutes before I was able to drift back to sleep. The next day, I followed Veeby’s lead and purchased a better door handle for the Guest room, featuring a lock which required a key. I wanted to be able to leave the house without fear that she’d gain entry to “my” new bedroom—and throw my stuff back out of the marital house.

22 Her Bruises Showed up Today

POLICE REPORT Complainant advices her bruises showed up today… Recall from yesterday Met with [Veeby] in reference to domestic disturbance from yesterday. Veeby wanted it to be documented that she had two small bruises on her right arm as a result of a pushing match with her estranged husband over property at the residence. Veeby stated that there was no intentions of physical harm to either party during the struggle. Veeby stated that she just wanted it to be documented. During this call this officer observed two very small bruises on Veeby’s right arm. This officer could not determine when and how she obtained the two marks. I later learned that while I was out buying new door hardware on Saturday morning, Veeby was over at the police station supplementing her comments from the day before. Unbeknownst to me at the time, Veeby concocted a claim that we had a “struggle” while I was moving back in. Yep, even though I don’t remember that any of those events actually happened, she claimed that I’d “shoved” and “pushed” and “grabbed” and “hurt” her…which caused “bruises.” Evidently, these recollections came to her overnight—after she was banging on the Guest room door, frustrated she couldn’t gain entry and then locked up my computer monitor. [I wonder how she got all bruised up?] Very interesting. Even more interesting were the facts that: • It was untrue…I never touched Veeby; • Ryan was there and didn’t see any physical struggle; • Veeby didn’t scream to the neighbor about any physical struggle; • Three police officers were also there, yet Veeby didn’t mention anything about a physical struggle to them. • Police report from the day before confirmed there was no physical struggle: “The argument was verbal and no one was injured.” Then, Veeby emailed me: John, You were physically aggressive and assaultive to me when you and Ryan stormed into the house while I specifically told you not to come in. You took it upon yourself to move all the furniture around, stacking things in the garage, and moving your things into Eliana’s bedroom. All of this you did without consulting with me. [It could be pointed out that Veeby’s changing the rules of our Plan A was also done “without consulting with me”—I’m just saying.] S M O K E & M I R R O R S In our 33+ years together, we had no history of physical abuse or domestic violence. However, that didn’t advance her goal. Veeby devised a plan to get me back out of “her” house. She alerted her Lawyer #1 that (1) she was going to get a Restraining Order; (2) she had bruises on both arms; and (3) I’d pushed her when I moved back in. In order to help move her little plan along, she needed to “update” her previous day’s Police Report with her newly acquired “recollections”—so she could take the Police Reports to the courthouse. Of course, I didn’t know what she was planning at the time, but in hindsight…the manipulative scheme she devised remains unbelievable to me. In a nutshell, Veeby began to claim that somehow I had shoved, pushed, grabbed, hurt and caused bruises—while I was carrying one of the heavy panels of my Sound Booth with Ryan. Oh yeah, I was also walking backwards at the time. REALLY! • • • • • During my first day back at the good old marital house, Veeby made sure to let me know she was most displeased. She wouldn’t talk with me or let me further explain my decision. Even though we had arrived at an amicable Plan A—and I had only been out of the house for a month—she had already territorially claimed the house as her own. Of course, she expected me to honor the financial component of Plan A, thus allowing her and the children to live there, but in her mind I had crossed an imaginary line by daring to move back in. Therefore, no civility was offered by Veeby. I quickly figured out what was written within the “internal household memo”—which I never received, but definitely felt. It read, “Alert—an Intruder has entered the dwelling. All communications with the Intruder are to be delivered using the cruelest of both words and actions.” I had seen Veeby’s Game of Cruelty in action—making fun of people, being just plain mean by cutting folks down in various ways—but I wasn’t used to being in the crosshairs. It now appeared I was the target of her fury—i.e., I purchased food and placed it in the kitchen and refrigerator—Veeby threw it all away. In the afternoon, I tried to speak with Veeby about my missing monitor. Barely speaking to me through “her” locked bedroom door, she refused to converse about the subject. As an outward evidence of her Happy, Thriving and Peaceful life, it was important to have a “party” that Saturday evening. Having paved the way for the fulfillment of her Restraining Order scheme the following Monday…it was time to celebrate. All attendees were treated with a verbal copy of the “Intruder Memo” during their phone invitations. In front of our guests, I took the opportunity to once again ask Veeby if she had seen my computer monitor. She simply smiled and looked at me—without answering the question. Once more, I asked her—saying the monitor had been on my desk and was now gone—had she seen it? Again, she simply smiled at me, but no answer. I then spoke the words, “Civility…be civil” before I walked away. Not one invited guest offered to intercede. They had chosen to stay in Veeby’s camp. I came back through the kitchen later on and grabbed a glass to get a drink in the fridge. Veeby and two of our friends were standing beside the refrigerator talking. I looked through the fridge, but didn’t see the bottled drink I’d purchased. I turned and asked Veeby, “Do you know where the drink is…that I bought yesterday?” Veeby and friends just continued talking—like I had not spoken at all. I closed the fridge door and waited for a break in their conversation, and then said, “You know, I live here in this house—I’m actually standing here in this room talking to you—have you seen my bottled drink?” This time, Veeby stopped talking, looked at me and smiled, but did not answer. I asked her if she had seen or taken the ice cream from the freezer—still no answer. Again, I simply said the word, “CIVILITY” and just walked away. How absolutely rude. I later found out she’d thrown it all away. 30 minutes later, Veeby and a female friend were talking about the fax machine no longer working properly. I knew something about that issue. I tried to explain the changes in our phone service and how to fix the problem, but neither lady would stop talking or listen to anything I had to say. I seemingly did not exist…I had been erased. I found myself in similar situations over and over again during the evening. Yep, I was definitely the new target in Veeby’s vicious little game. I must admit feeling saddened for our friends and family. While they could provide solace and a sympathetic ear, I believed friends should be wise by remaining neutral. It simply amazed me that those particular friends and family would choose to “align” themselves with Veeby by extending her “no communication” rules towards me. Why couldn’t they understand there were two sides to our story? Veeby’s newest Game of Cruelty—was just beginning.

23 Where's My Piano?

The next morning, I went off to rehearsals at the University per my normal Sunday routine. I hoped for a relatively pleasant day, despite the craziness of the last two days. Perhaps after work, Veeby would be calmer and we could talk? I clicked my heels together three times. While at work, I received a phone call from a neighbor who was out walking his dog past our house. He’d seen a big white moving truck in our driveway and three men, and watched as Veeby paid them. The neighbor said he couldn’t tell exactly what they were moving out, but he thought it might be my piano. Wait…WHAT? I raced home after work, only to find a big empty space in the Formal Living Room—my teaching space—where the piano lived. My grand piano was GONE! I found Veeby and her friend, Mary literally hiding in the Master bedroom, with the door closed and locked. I knocked and asked both ladies through the door, “Where is my piano?” Neither would answer the question nor reply in anyway. I told Veeby we needed to talk, and she needed to move my piano back immediately. Veeby eventually came out and we then transitioned into the formal living room…sans piano…with Mary tagging along. As both women sat down on the couch, I tried to talk directly with Veeby, but Mary kept interjecting comments. I reminded Veeby how everything had been discussed and arranged within our Plan A, but that she then changed the rules over the last 30 days. I felt insulted as Veeby and Mary giggled between themselves about their successful little coup—like little school girls torturing some poor boy at recess. I recounted how she had only just informed me the prior Wednesday of her latest rule change—i.e., I could no longer teach at our/her house—which was not discussed, but I was informed of her decision. That was just four days before and yet she took it upon herself to move the piano out of the house? It seemed utterly crazy to me. Teaching was part of my income, part of how I paid the bills—our bills. It didn’t make logical sense. Plus, she wouldn’t tell me where she had taken my piano. She just said that I was a “smart man” and I needed to figure out somewhere else to teach…just not there. I told her I had figured out a place to teach—at our house, per Plan A—which was why I moved back in! I would teach at our house until we sold it, then I’d figure out where else to move to. Veeby immediately mentioned that she could sell the house at any time. I corrected her—that she couldn’t sell the house without me. Of course, Mary chimed in that in a divorce situation Veeby could easily sell the house without my consent. I told them I didn’t think that was how it worked. I told Veeby that I thought she’d been getting some really bad advice from her counselor, friends and family. Of course, she sneered. [One of her social media friends encouraged her to just “ignore me” and pray that I would go away.] Veeby stated that she would give me PEACE, but only if I left the house [the word blackmail immediately came to mind]. She would “give” me “peace” if I “left?” When I processed that phrase through my finely tuned Veeby filter, it reduced down to a very familiar theme within our relationship: DO THINGS HER WAY, or there would be hell to pay. Veeby then dropped a bomb. She said that I had “physically assaulted” her when I moved back in. I had been standing, but I immediately sat down on the couch and wept. I looked up at Veeby and quietly said that it simply wasn’t true. I looked into Mary’s eyes, whom I’d known for a dozen years and told her that it simply wasn’t true—that I had never touched Veeby that last Friday. I reminded Veeby that we had no history of domestic violence in our relationship. Plus, why would I want to physically hurt her? As Veeby watched me getting emotional and tear up, she turned to Mary and “explained” that this was now the “manipulative John”…the “soft and tender John”…and said “he’ll probably do this in front of the Judge.” Until that very moment, I was not aware of Veeby’s accusation. I did not know that she had gone to the police station on Saturday morning to update her statement to include a “struggle” and “bruises.” No wonder our friends and her family had been shunning me. Veeby was telling them an absolutely manipulative lie to gain their sympathy and support. She told them I’d physically assaulted her. I was terribly hurt by Veeby’s cruel comments. I stood up, excused myself and walked away. • • • • • I walked away and turned the corner into our Family Room only to discover one more big empty space. The TV was GONE as well—just a bare TV stand remained. It wasn’t just the family TV set—it was our big 60-inch rear projection TV, with a complete “stereo surround sound” DREAM system. It appeared Veeby not only had my piano moved, but also the big screen TV! What was she thinking? What else was gone? Also missing were all the components of our entertainment center—i.e., sound system, speakers, sub-woofer and tweeter, blu-ray player, wireless internet router, Wii console, Xbox console, Nintendo GameCube, all the remote controls and cabling, etc. Without the router, there was no more internet available in the house, nor any cable TV, nor any gaming systems entertainment available for our children. I’d bought the big screen TV as a birthday present for myself several years before, but purposefully left it for my family to use when I moved to the condo. The kids and I had it nicely configured to watch blu-ray movies in surround sound, plus all the gaming systems were hooked up to the different monitors and the multiple speakers surrounding the room gave us awesome sound—it was slick. The children often had friends over and they would all play games at the same time. It was a great set up and I didn’t want to take that away. It gave me joy to let them utilize the TV and entertainment system. Veeby’s taking all that away no longer allowed a central place for the family to watch TV together, watch movies together, play video games together—it was simply gone. I explored further and found the black studio monitors [pair of speakers] had been taken off my desk, my computer keyboard, electric guitar and bass guitar were also gone. Miscellaneous desk supplies—i.e., yellow highlighters, post-it notes, paper clips, tape, rubber bands—were all gone. The two-line phone system in the house…was gone. There was no way to place a call over our land lines—no phones, no calls. The pictures that were on the wall in our Formal Living Room…were all gone. • • • • • Checkmate? We always had a chess board set up in our house. Veeby and I played chess on our early dates. Years later, we bought a nice onyx chess set on our honeymoon. 25 years later, we celebrated at the same honeymoon spot and purchased another set to replace the first one we’d worn out. Evidently, Veeby had been listening to me at our last therapy session when I stated: “There is no KING or QUEEN anymore. No more BROWBEATING. Neither one of us KNOWS IT ALL. We can DISCUSS things, but your DICTATING to me is no longer acceptable.” At least she heard the King and Queen part. She took those game pieces off the board, while leaving all the others! What a peculiar “move” on her part. Why? What was her intended symbolism by removing the King and Queen? Maybe she was trying to dictate her terms. Maybe Veeby was letting me know that she and I were no longer on the same playing field? Maybe it was a visual sign that she would control the board in our new Game of Divorce? Whatever Veeby’s motivation, her changes in Plan A, her Erasing choices and her most recent “making my things disappear” chess moves seemed quite bizarre to me. Her decisions were completely contrary to the family stability we sought within our carefully crafted Plan A. While her removing my piano could be viewed as a punitive “move” against me, how could her removal of the entire entertainment system and internet access not be seen as anything but punitive towards our children? I’m not sure her actions were well thought out. It seemed like her anger trumped any sound reasoning. I eventually figured out that Veeby had the grand piano and big TV removed from the house by a moving company, but had taken the rest of the missing “stuff” into her Master bedroom—where she had it all nicely hidden, locked up and in her CONTROL! • • • • • However, I still had a problem. I was scheduled to teach music lessons at the house the very next day, Monday. I needed to figure out how to teach my piano lessons without a piano. I owned an electric keyboard that I could temporarily use, yeah! If I could just find the…NOPE, she’d taken all the cables for that, too. There wasn’t time to find another location. I reasoned I would need to rent a piano for the lessons. However, the piano stores were closed by the time all the events of the day had calmed down and I began to problem solve my dilemma. So, early Monday morning, I called my friend who owned the music store where I’d purchased my grand piano. I told him my woeful story and he hooked me up with a small upright rental, and made sure it was delivered to the house before I began teaching. It cost me a little extra to expedite, but I successfully put out the fire Veeby lit the day before. • • • • • My piano remained Missing In Action for quite awhile—Veeby would simply not reveal where she’d taken my piano—if she’d sold it or given it away. Curiously, several days later a burned out grand piano showed up in the middle of our small local lake, perched upright and barely afloat on a partially sunken barge! I watched the breaking news story on the TV…and slowly absorbed the possibility that it might be my piano out there. I sat in disbelief and contemplated if Veeby would have arranged such an elaborate prank. Taking my piano and then dumping it’s burned carcass in the middle of the lake? Now, that would have been a statement! Was MY missing piano and the new “black and crispy piano” in the lake…indeed one in the same? The timing was strangely coincidental. Was this my poor Baby? The regional papers picked up the mystery piano story and ran an article. They interviewed my friend, the owner of the piano store from whom I’d just rented a piano. Knowing the details of my situation, he suggested to the reporter a possible explanation wherein one party in a bitter divorce scenario took the prized piano of their “Ex” and dumped it in the lake. His explanation was then quoted in the article. How funny! Even though the officer had told Veeby just two days before to not remove items from the house—i.e., “I advised Veeby and John that they cannot remove items from the house since they are still married,”—obviously his admonition didn’t apply to Veeby, or hadn’t registered within her brain yet. She moved MY piano out of the house in a overtly cruel and calculated blackmail attempt to get me to also leave. Luckily, the mystery piano in the lake was not my baby…whew! My piano was out there…somewhere. Only Veeby knew where she’d stashed it—but she wasn’t about to tell me.

24 Let's Go on Vacation

I got up early the following morning to prepare breakfast for the children before school—my regular routine until the month before. Veeby was noticeably upset when she began moving around that Monday morning. I got both Noelle and Mark off to school, then left for the condo to access the internet and make some calls. No more internet access at the marital house…Veeby had seen to that the previous day. Thank goodness I had the foresight to have kept my laptop computer close by me at all times…otherwise, I’m sure Veeby would have taken that, too. My first call arranged for a rental piano to be delivered to the house before my teaching began in the afternoon. I then drove over and signed some legal papers with Carol, then met the piano delivery crew around 1 pm. Veeby was there, but she stayed in the back of the house. The piano movers were in and out quickly. I moved furniture around for my students, took some pictures of the set up. I taped a note on the piano which said, “Veeby, Rental piano—DO NOT TOUCH”…and then took pictures of the new rental piano sitting in the room. I didn’t need the headache of her removing yet another piano in a further attempt to keep me from teaching at the house. The house was beginning to look and feel like Ft. Knox. The air changed inside the house—it felt stifling. Veeby had sneakily removed from the premises or locked up behind “her” bedroom door many of my things while I was at work. I felt frustrated that I couldn’t get my stuff, and I’m sure that was her intent. Success! I received several “suggestions” to simply break down her door and “go get my things.” However, that didn’t feel right to me. That felt more like destruction of property, another verbal attack and would probably not play well in my future. I tentatively arranged for a locksmith the next morning. That would be a service technician in “my” house, so no harm, no foul. I decided to ask Veeby once more to give me back my stuff—then I would have at least “tried” before using a locksmith to gain entry. I hoped that my being out of the house that Monday morning had allowed some time for Veeby to “cool off” a bit before I asked her nicely. Unfortunately, Veeby took off for work before I started teaching, so I didn’t have an opportunity to speak with her. My first student arrived and I had to answer the expected questions: “Where’s your grand piano? Where are the pictures on the wall? Are we going to have our piano lesson on this small piano? Why?”…etc. All asked, all answered—the first of many times with each student, I was sure. We transitioned back into music topics and began the lesson. During that lesson, I received a Fraud Alert call from my credit card company. I didn’t recognize the phone number, so I let it go to voice mail—[I was in a lesson]—but immediately called them back once we were finished. Providentially, my next student called in sick, so I had an hour break before the next lesson. The credit card company informed me that Veeby had used my credit card for some questionable purchases…and they just needed confirmation I had authorized her to do so. Wait…WHAT? Back in November, she and I had already separated all of our credit card accounts. Evidently, I’d forgotten about her “Associate” card attached to that particular credit card. She rarely used it—mostly to buy gas for our shared business car—but she used it that day. I was shocked that she would use it during these turbulent times. All right, credit card company, what did she buy? Apparently she stepped out and treated herself to a $5 juice at our favorite juicing bar—“All right, I’ll authorize that.”—I’m a nice guy. Then, she went to the grocery store and bought a $200 gift card—“All right.”—a little suspicious, but she and I would talk about it later. What else? “Well, John, she purchased a Disneyland vacation package this morning totaling $2000. Did you know about that?” [Cue fainting music, ending with a thud] Nope…didn’t see that one coming! Anything else? Evidently, the Fraud Alert kicked in when she tried to use the same card once more for $300 worth of groceries at the same store later in the day. Thankfully, the card was declined during check out. Needless to say, I submitted a dispute claim for the $200 gift card and asked them to cancel her card! I then called Disneyland for help. They canceled her reservation and credited my card for the entire amount. Thanks, Walt! • • • • • That was it…I finally reached the end of my rope. She charged $2000+ on my card that day—purposefully trying to financially mess with me—and she did a mighty fine job. A Disneyland vacation, when we were in the middle of separating…REALLY? Veeby didn’t ask me or alert me…she just bought $2000+ worth of stuff and fully expecting me to pay for it. That seemed like absolutely ludicrous and punitive behavior. Adding the $2000+ expenditure to her removing my piano, removing the TV, locking up my stuff, taking away the internet for the house, no longer talking to me—it was simply too much. Thankfully, at that particular moment I was alone in the marital house. Both kids had gone over to their friend’s homes to play after school that day, so I was able to “let off a little steam.” I used our claw hammer to pop off the locked door knob on the Master Bedroom, revealing most of the stuff Veeby had locked away. I didn’t see the big TV inside, but most everything else had been loaded into the closet. I discovered she had placed an additional lock on my music studio door [entrance was through the bedroom] so I didn’t know what else she had stored in there. My next student would be arriving soon…what to do? After having frantically arranged for a rental piano so I could teach…I decided to call my remaining students and cancel their lessons for that day—we’d do a “make-up” lesson some other time. I didn’t know when Veeby would be returning from work and I didn’t want her trying to replace the locks again—further preventing me from retrieving my belongings—so, I took the master bedroom door off the hinges and placed the door back behind the house. As a matter of fact, we didn’t need to have all those bedroom doors with locks on them, so I took off all the doors with locks—and stacked them all neatly behind the house. Yep, kids bathroom door, too. The other two bathrooms had sliding pocket doors…the family could just use those for privacy for a few hours. I would have time to switch out the door knobs later that night. FINALLY, we had no more locked doors inside the house! This also caused me concern. Sleeping in the same house with Veeby when she was so upset could be risky for my health, in a permanent and fatal sort of way. I decided to be wise and hide all the knives we owned. I threw them behind the Sound Booth panels which were stacked in the corner of our dining room. Out of sight and hidden, I stood a better chance of not being stabbed in the back during the night. Seriously! I had also been “encouraged” to take something of Veeby’s as leverage…possibly her computer. Again, I was not comfortable with that. I was trying to be above board in my dealings with Veeby, to “use my words” and discuss things. However—WAIT—that wasn’t working out too well, so scrap that! I changed my mind and disconnected her computer—I left the monitor, keyboard and mouse, but I took the tower. Of course, she would not be happy with that decision either. The rules were very clear in Veeby’s world: At any time, it was perfectly fine for her to take my stuff, but at no time was it ever acceptable for me to respond in kind. That would be crossing some imaginary “boundary.” With my students having been canceled and the doors now off their hinges, I called my kids to return home. We then discussed the events of the last few days and I explained the dynamics of my actions. Mark and I hung out in his room and watched some TV together. According to the cell phone records, Noelle called Veeby several times. Noelle was on the phone with her, waiting by the front door until she arrived back home. It appeared Noelle had “chosen a side”—which is exactly what I’d told her not to do. Teenagers! • • • • • When Veeby arrived home, she was in and out of the house within a two minute window…literally. She came in, told both kids to get in her car, grabbed the dog and left. [WAIT…come back…you forgot the poor cat]. I knew what to expect. I unlocked the front door of the house, sat down in a comfortable chair…and just waited. Within two minutes, the police arrived. Three cruisers this time, with lights flashing. Four big police officers knocked [“Come in”] and came filing into the house…and found me just sitting there. POLICE REPORT Veeby advised her husband is destroying the house breaking the doors, throwing items removed all the doors husband is still there Veeby is in her car outside husband should be there alone Veeby advised husband took battery out of the alarm so she can’t set the alarm they are going through a divorce The nice officers told me they’d just spoken to my wife and two children and they were all TERRIFIED to be in the house with me. Veeby had already informed them we were in the process of divorcing [again, no paperwork had been filed] and that I had another residence to go to. I informed them that I had broken my lease at the condo, and had simply taken the inside doors off the hinges, the doors were stacked out back if they wanted to see them. I reminded them that we had no history of domestic or physical violence at all in our years of marriage. I continued that she and I were both educated professionals and Veeby was merely making this a “move” in her Game of Divorce, so she could stand before a judge and claim “what-ever.” They all chuckled in agreement. I said, “You guys probably see this a lot?” One officer replied, “We see this same crap everyday.” The police walked all through the house. I sat and calmly told my side of recent events to the officers. It was decided that Veeby would take the children up to her sister’s house [an hour’s travel North] overnight. I was requested to sit far away so it was “secure” for them to come into the house to collect their things. Silly, but I complied. Playing the part of terrified wife, Veeby re-entered the house with the kids in tow. I had two muscle bound cops hovering over me as I sat, just in case I lunged towards Veeby in a fit of rage. At one point, as Mark walked through the room, I asked the officer’s “permission” to speak to him—they said, “Sure.” I asked Mark, “Are you afraid to be in the house with me?” He answered, “No” and walked away. Noelle also walked through the room. I asked her if I could speak with her, but she said, “No” and just kept walking. An officer asked me if I had a key to the back storage area—my music studio space. I answered, “No, but I wish I did, because that’s where she is hiding my computer stuff!” Again, they all chuckled. One officer suggested that once the wife and two children had left and the house was “secured”—that whatever I needed to do to gain access to that back storage area, in my own house, was my own business. Hey, that was a good idea! Thank you very much. Veeby and the kids left the house once more—and they still left the poor cat. I called a friend, borrowed a round hole drill punch and drilled through the music studio door to gain access. I took the studio door off it’s hinges and stored it off site with the friendly neighbor. I found my computer monitor [screen] laying on the floor inside my studio, along with my computer keyboard. The monitor seemed all right, but Veeby had popped off some of the keys from the computer keyboard. REALLY? Since everyone was out of the house, I brought all the doors back inside, took off all the “keyed” locks, replaced them with the simpler “pop” locks, then rehung all the doors to their respective rooms. That returned the house doors to how we had always had them…before all the craziness occurred. The events of the last several days only confirmed what I knew in my heart—it was time to follow through with my promise. During our last therapy session I’d told Veeby either she changed our dance steps or I would file for divorce from her and save myself. Indeed, it was time.

25 I Filed for Divorce

The next morning I called the children’s schools to make sure they had both arrived safely. Noelle was reported as being in school, but Mark was not in school. I gave Mark an “Excused” absence for the day with the front office. I called Mark’s cell phone and asked if he was okay. He said, “Yeah.” I asked where he was—he said he didn’t want to tell me. I said that was an unusual answer. He then said, “I don’t want to get Mom mad at me.” I told him everything would be all right and reminded him to just FLOAT through this difficult time. As promised, I filed for Divorce that Tuesday. A very sad day for me. By filing, I became the Petitioner, which left Veeby as the Respondent. Thus began my education of the legal system as it pertained to Family Law. I would eventually receive an unofficial Certificate of Participation from the “School of Hard Knocks”—having learned more than I ever wanted to know about all the rules from the Game of Divorce. VERIFIED PETITION FOR DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE First off, it’s not a Divorce. It’s actually called a Dissolution of Marriage. Here’s a simpler Reduction of all the legally filed paperwork: • “He” was divorcing “Her;” • My lawyer would dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s on my behalf; • Veeby and I had been married a long time; • The marriage was broken…and couldn’t be fixed; • We had three kids…two still lived at home; • Blah, blah, blah…. Mention was made of the multiple items that Veeby had removed from the house—those I needed for my livelihood and to support the family—most specifically, my grand piano. Carol requested an Injunction Against Disposal of Assets. Official mention was made regarding Veeby’s blackmail attempts, her threats of filing domestic violence allegations and her interfering with my teaching from the home. Veeby was served the Divorce paperwork two days later at 7 am.

26 She Filed a Restraining Order

1.11.08—a day I will never forget. I had my lawyer file divorce papers at the courthouse on my behalf. Veeby was also at the courthouse that day, filing her own paperwork, seeking a Restraining Order against me. Since she filed, she was the Petitioner and I became the Respondent. Her handwritten complaint was as follows: "On Monday, 01.10.08, the Respondent took out all the bedroom doors - from their hinges - including bathroom doors from the home. I arrived home from work at 8 pm and all the lights were on in the house. I walked towards the back of the house and saw my 15-year-old daughter in her room without the doors on in her bedroom. I observed the lights were on in my room and the door was missing - I also observed that the door to the bathroom was missing. I asked my daughter what happened, she said she got home from school around 4:00 pm and my bedroom door was locked as I had left it. She went over to a neighbor friends house and when she returned at 6:45 pm all the doors were missing. I went into my 11-year-old’s room and saw my husband sitting on the couch watching TV. I asked my son to come out of the room so I could talk to him. When he did I told him to go to my car which was in the garage. I told my 15-year-old daughter to get the dog and also get in the car. My husband came out of my son’s room past me and went to the kitchen and opened the refrigerator door. I did not speak to him at all. My children and I walked past him and into the garage and got in my car and drove away! I pulled into the parking lot of the gymnasium and called my lawyer. She advised me to call the police. I immediately did and they met me back at the house. I was afraid to go into the house by myself to get my clothes and the children’s book bags. I told the officers I was afraid of my husband, I am in the process of filing for divorce. The officers escorted me and my children into the house so we could get overnight toiletries and that is when I saw my computer which was in my bedroom with all my work files was missing. My 15-year-old says she knows her father took it. My husband moved out of our home on 12.01.07. On Friday 01.07.08 he showed up at the house at around 12:30 pm. I was getting ready to leave for work. I was carrying files and my purse. I opened the front door to let the dog out. When I did I saw a white van backing into the driveway. I recognized the van as belonging to my husband’s friend Ryan. My husband jumped out of the passenger side and walked over to the garage door and pushed the code to open the garage door. I asked him what he was doing. He said he had a right to be there and that I could call and talk to his lawyer. When the garage door opened he grabbed the baseball bats that were inside the garage. I got afraid at this point and ran to the front door and stood in front of it. His friend had opened the back of the van. I was afraid he was coming to take things out of the house. I told him to leave - he yelled at me that he had every right to be there. He walked straight into me and started shoving me out of his way so he could come into the house. He was carrying a rectangular grey looking board - at the time I didn’t know what that was - I thought it was something to carry things out on. He was holding this board under his right arm and pushing and shoving me with his left hand and forearm. His friend Ryan was holding the end of the board standing behind him. My husband grabbed my right arm and pushed me very hard to the left out of his way. I screamed that he was hurting me. He walked into the house with his friend. I dialed 911. He began moving furniture around in the dining room. I asked repeatedly for them to stop moving furniture. I said he could not take anything. The 911 dispatcher was on the phone with me. My husband kept yelling at me to talk to his lawyer. He was very agitated. I was afraid. The dispatcher said the police were on their way. I ran out of the house when my husband came towards the front door where I was standing. The front door had remained open. I ran to my neighbors house. Sherry was not home but Phil and his son Stuart were. Stuart was in the garage and I asked him to come help me - that John was taking things from the house. As we started to walk back across the yard the police arrived. A female cop spoke with me and a male cop went to speak to my husband. I was standing by the front door and shaking scared. I told the officer I am in the process of getting divorced the papers are not finalized and that he had moved out voluntarily on Dec. 20th. I had not changed the locks on him but he had come into the house in an agitated way and I was afraid of what he was doing. The male officer took my husband outside and talked to him. A third officer arrived - he came to talk to me and the female officer went to talk to my husband. He asked me if I had information about how to file a restraining order. He gave me the information. I told him I was afraid of what my husband could do. The female officer asked me if I had any problems if my husband moved some stuff back in. I was confused. I said “I guess not.” I went back next door to my neighbors, and my husband and his friend Ryan continued in the house. The officers went back to their vehicles and then left. I watched my husband drive away in the white van with his friend. I went back inside the house and found he’d moved his dresser drawer furniture from his condo into the guest bedroom, which has a bed in it. I found my cat and dog in my son’s bedroom. I got in my car and left. I met with my lawyer to instruct her to file the divorce paperwork. I had, per my lawyers instructions, met with my husband 2 days earlier - Wednesday, Jan. 5, 2008 - to inform him that I did want the divorce and if he wanted to work amicably. I told him my request and that we would have to work out an agreement. He did not say anything and left. On Friday he showed up at the house and moved his things back. He informed me he was back to stay. On Saturday morning, 01.08.08, I noticed bruises on my right forearm and upper arm from the struggle on Friday. I got the paperwork that the officer gave me. I called the police dept. and was told I could come down and they would document it. I went down and spoke to an officer. He filed a report and gave me a CAD#. I noticed later that day I had another bruise on my left arm. On Monday, 01.10.08, I went to work in the afternoon. When I got home at night he, my husband, had removed all the doors from our bedrooms and bathroom. As I stated I was very scared for my life and the lives of my children at this time. His behavior is unpredictable. He has told me and our children he does not want the divorce and I am afraid of what he will do now that I have filed for the divorce. I am very afraid because he is acting this way in front of his children which scares me. I am afraid of being in the house with my husband without a door to my bedroom and even when there is a door he breaks it down and takes it out. He removed the battery of the house alarm when he came back on Friday, Jan. 7, 2008. I was at work and got a total of calls 10 times. They would call me to say the alarm was going off. I advised them to call the police. I called them back but could not get any information because my husband changed the passcode. When I got home that night I saw the battery alarm had been disconnected and was gone. I cannot even put the house alarm on. I do not feel safe if my husband is in the house. I am afraid for the safety of my children. My husband is acting in a bizarre way." WOW…where to start? Grab a cup of coffee, folks. Sit back, put your legs up and enjoy the little show. In the World According to Veeby, she would often ask me a series of questions, usually in rapid succession. I quickly learned that if I interrupted her and tried to answer one, she would then yell “foul” and accuse me of becoming “defensive”—when I was just trying to answer the first dumb question. It was hard to know where all the relationship land mines had been hidden, until I heard the little “click” as I verbally tread. So, without trying to sound too defensive, I would like to “explain” a little bit, please. • • • • • Veeby wrote she was “afraid” almost a dozen times above—she was very familiar with all the legal code words to use. She often wrote legal reports for her clients to submit to the courts. Veeby regularly wrote analysis reports for her clients to submit to their employers, to obtain authorization for additional sessions. Veeby was well aware of what to say and how to say it. Ergo, she was: “scared for her life,” “didn’t feel safe,” “was concerned about the safety of her children,” etc. Additionally, she needed to paint me as a bad guy, so she wrote that she was afraid of her “husband,” I’d grabbed baseball bats, I yelled at her, I walked straight into her shoving her out of my way, I pushed and we struggled, I was agitated, my behavior was unpredictable and I was acting in a bizarre way, etc. Months earlier—while we were still in therapy—I “used my words” and “spoke my truth” and stated that I did not want a divorce, and that was true. I told our children the same thing at our family pow-wow weeks before. However, Veeby was skilled at twisting my words into new shapes that worked much better for her purposes. All of a sudden it was presented as: “He has told me and our children he does not want the divorce and I am afraid of what he will do now…” S M O K E & M I R R O R S One of the many lessons I learned during the ordeal was that absolutely anyone can walk into a courthouse or police station and claim whatever they want—which will open a “case” and generate an “incident report.” So, to help fulfill her scheme to get me back out of our house, Veeby marched down to the courthouse, crafted her detailed perspective of recent events and asked for a Restraining Order to be issued against me. Unfortunately, she took our youngest son, Mark, along as a visual aid in the application process. [She let Noelle go to school that day. She could have just as easily let Mark go to school.] I understand that many people do need the protection that a legal Restraining Order provides, but I did not feel our situation warranted it at all. I believed that Veeby simply used the system to play her Game of Divorce. • • • • • In addition to her handwritten statement, Veeby had to fill out the official legal form, titled: TEMPORARY INJUNCTION FOR PROTECTION AGAINST DOMESTIC VIOLENCE WITH MINOR CHILDREN. Within that form, Veeby claimed that she believed she was in “imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence” because: • I had committed or threatened to commit domestic violence; • I had intentionally injured or killed a family pet: [she listed] - family cat - thrown in pool - family cat - thrown outside in snow when living in Denver in 1993 • I had destroyed personal property belonging to Veeby; • I had engaged in other behavior or conduct that led Veeby to have reasonable cause to believe she was in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence; • Veeby then inserted her handwritten statement [above] when asked to “briefly describe the latest act of violence or threat of violence that causes her to honestly fear imminent domestic violence by Respondent.” • She wrote that I owned and/or possessed nunchucks; • She claimed that she needed Exclusive Use and Possession of Home that the parties shared, and could not get another safe place to live because: “…my children and I have lived in this home since May, 2002. I need to provide a safe place for them and this is the only place I can stay for them to continue in their schools.” • She claimed that the home was “solely owned by Petitioner/[Veeby];” • Veeby sought sole custody of the minor children; • She stated the minor children had not witnessed domestic violence by Respondent; • She requested that the Court prohibit time-sharing by Respondent with the minor children because Veeby genuinely feared that I imminently would abuse, remove or hide the minor children from her. She wrote in her explanation: “My husband said to me on Sunday, Jan. 9, 2008 in front of my friend Mary that he will not coordinate any visitation of his children with me. He does not want to run anything by me. I am afraid he will take the children whenever he wants. He had been doing this when he moved out Dec. 2007. He was coming and going into the house whenever he wanted and taking my 11-year-old son and not telling me.” • • • • • When I read all of her accusations…I simply cried. It was one of the worst hurts I’d ever felt. Veeby purposefully wrote and filled out the form in such a way as to hurt me. I was numbed and shocked. Veeby knew how close I was with our kids. I could never have imagined she would do this to me. I had never played this Game of Divorce—didn’t know the rules—and was learning as it unfolded. Once again, without becoming defensive, I feel the need to further explain my side of the story. • • • • • To indicate on the form that I had thrown our family cat in the pool was absolutely and verifiably false. Veeby needed to put “something” on the form to indicate she was in fear for her life, so she took an incident that occurred at our home when I wasn’t even there and attributed it to me. Apparently, while I was at work on a Sunday morning about a month before, the cat happened to fall into the pool. Noelle heard the cat meowing for help and rescued her. When I came home, no one mentioned the incident to me. Later that evening, I just happened to hear Veeby and the children discussing if the cat would be all right. I asked and they filled me in on the morning’s drama with the cat. When I later informed the kids Veeby had accused me of throwing our cat in the pool, they all chuckled. One of them sent me a text: “Ha Ha, if anything she’ll try to pin the cat’s falling into the pool on you. Otherwise, you didn’t drown anything.” It was intentionally misleading to indicate that I’d hurt a family cat—18 years previously—and that contributed to her being “afraid” that “she was in imminent danger of becoming a victim of domestic violence.” Years ago we lived in Denver and had two cats. When we moved into a new apartment in the area, one of the cats was not happy about our decision to change locations, so she defecated on my pillow on our bed to punctuate her unhappiness. As a dramatic gesture, I took the cat by the scruff and tossed her into a snow pile outside the door. She wasn’t hurt, and we brought her back in, of course. Amazingly, the cat had a much better attitude after her little snow adventure. Was Veeby afraid I might throw her into a snow bank? There was no evidence to support Veeby’s claim that I had destroyed her personal property. While she screamed to police dispatchers I was destroying the house, breaking the doors and throwing items, it was merely dramatics acted out to further her cause. Each time the police arrived, nothing had been destroyed, broken or thrown. • • • • • One of the silliest inclusions on the Restraining Order form was that I owned and/or possessed nunchucks…a martial arts weapon. We did not have any nunchucks in the house. I wasn’t trained on them and would have probably hit myself on the head if I ever tried. However, Veeby’s sister and former husband were trained in the martial arts—i.e., black belts, hand to hand combat, weapons, etc. I wondered who might have helped Veeby fill out the forms? Nunchucks…hilarious…but it did look good on paper that she might be in harm’s way. However, it was a lie. In her attempt to gain Exclusive Use and Possession of Home, Veeby incorrectly claimed that she was the sole owner of our house—however, that was not true. Actually, both she and I were listed on the Deed, and I had been paying our mortgage for years. Even though I specifically told her she was incorrect in her thinking on this subject, she continued to insist. She could have easily selected the little box on that form that correctly stated the home was “owned by Petitioner and Respondent jointly,” but instead selected the “solely owned by Petitioner” box. I’m sure there was some thought that it might look better to a judge if it was her house and she needed me kicked out. Further, her handwritten “reason” she couldn’t get another safe place to live reduced to “she had lived there with the children since 2002.” Well, my goodness, I had lived there with the children since 2002 just as well…circular reasoning. Veeby correctly stated that our minor children had not witnessed domestic violence by the Respondent. YEAH, one point for me! Of course, that was because NO domestic violence had occurred in our house. My initial move out of the house, my moving back in, then removing the doors and changing the locks—all not observed by the kids, nor violent in any way. However, both Noelle and Mark witnessed Veeby’s violent pounding on the guest bedroom door and screaming at me the evening I moved back in. I wondered if that counted? I began to realize that the children were being used as a way to hurt me. While I eventually learned it was a normal “move” within the Game of Divorce, I wasn’t expecting that behavior and it did hurt. Veeby not only sought sole custody of the minor children, but also suggested her fear that I would somehow abuse, remove or hide my own children. At the time, that was really silly to me…a bunch of nonsense. In contrast, I wasn’t afraid that she would abuse, remove or hide the kids. It was pure silliness to suggest I would somehow “take” them from her. We created our children and we both loved them. Our lives were centered in the same town, plus I’d been the kid’s stay at home/work from home Dad their entire lives. Significantly though, Veeby had threatened to grab the kids and disappear to the country of her origin several months prior—on the same day she went to that Consulate to renew her documentation. It occurred to me that perhaps I should be afraid she would follow through with her threat. • • • • • She mentioned “he will not coordinate any visitations of his children with me” as a rallying theme. I clearly told her my issue was with the term “visitation”—that was our discussion—that she was not the “Primary Parent” of our children. Again, neither of us had filed legal paperwork and we had a working Plan A in place, or so I thought. I pointed out that we had Co-Parented our kids for more than 20 years and that she was referencing an older model of parenting after divorce. Again, it wasn’t what we had agreed to within our Plan A. After moving out to the condo, Veeby reprimanded me on several occasions for not spending more time with the kids. Even so, in order to keep up the S M O K E & M I R R O R S charade, Veeby then reframed my dropping by the house to see our children as my “coming and going whenever he wanted”—which became a negative, “How dare he!” thing. Also, “…taking my 11-year-old son and not telling me”—seriously? What a crock. On ONE occasion after moving to the condo, Mark and I arranged to have a little father and son adventure. After teaching at the house on a Tuesday night, Mark came back to the condo with me for a sleepover…and I took him to school the next morning per normal. Veeby knew about it and even made sure Mark had his toothbrush before we left. I wasn’t taking “her” 11-year-old son, but was taking our youngest son to sleep one night at the condo with Dad. She was just ticked that I hadn’t asked her “permission” but rather informed her of our plans. How dare Mark and I plan something to her exclusion. S M O K E & M I R R O R S Of course, there’s lots of background information which needs to be filled in regarding Veeby’s long-winded handwritten statement and allegations: • “On Monday, 01.10.08, the Respondent took out all the bedroom doors - from their hinges - including bathroom doors from the home.” I took off ONE bathroom door, to replace the doorknob, leaving the pocket doors on the other two bathrooms for privacy. Also, on two previous occasions, I’d removed the door from a daughter’s room—when she was acting out. Coming home from school and finding no door on her room got her attention. The door was always put back, of course. During those times, her parents were sending her a clear message: “Our house, Our rules…adjust your attitude”—which she did. • “I arrived home from work at 8 pm and all the lights were on in the house. I walked towards the back of the house and saw my 15-year-old daughter in her room without the doors on in her bedroom. I observed the lights were on in my room and the door was missing - I also observed that the door to the bathroom was missing. I asked my daughter what happened, she said she got home from school around 4 pm and my bedroom door was locked as I had left it. She went over to a neighbor friends house and when she returned at 6:45 pm all the doors were missing.” Veeby made it appear as if she didn’t know any of this had happened prior to her arrival home from work. However, cell phone records indicated Noelle called Veeby five (5) times before she arrived back home. Veeby was fully aware of what to expect, which is why she was in and out of the house in two minutes…and never spoke with me. • “I went into my 11-year-old’s room and saw my husband sitting on the couch watching TV. I asked my son to come out of the room so I could talk to him. When he did I told him to go to my car which was in the garage. I told my 15-year-old daughter to get the dog and also get in the car. My husband came out of my son’s room past me and went to the kitchen and opened the refrigerator door. I did not speak to him at all. My children and I walked past him and into the garage and got in my car and drove away!” She recounts correctly that I was watching TV with Mark in his room. However, when she spoke with the police dispatcher, she described me as “destroying the house…breaking the doors…throwing items.” When making up events, it’s best to be consistent in the retelling. • “I pulled into the parking lot of the gymnasium and called my lawyer. She advised me to call the police. I immediately did and they met me back at the house. I was afraid to go into the house by myself to get my clothes and the children’s book bags. I told the officers I was afraid of my husband, I am in the process of filing for divorce. The officers escorted me and my children into the house so we could get overnight toiletries….” As previously mentioned, four officers arrived and Veeby acted “terrified” since I’d taken the doors off. She came in with the kids to get their things and chose to go elsewhere that night. At least Mark gave me a big hug before they left. Thank you, son. • “…and that is when I saw my computer which was in my bedroom with all my work files was missing. My 15-year-old says she knows her father took it.” By taking down the locked doors, I was able to retrieve at least some of my stuff. My grand piano and the family big screen TV were still missing and it seemed Veeby wasn’t planning on bringing those back any time soon. In order to simply have some leverage, I grabbed her computer. I wanted to have the “Trade Ya” conversation, but that never occurred. Instead, she wrote it up that I was a bad guy for taking her computer. Of course, she conveniently left out the part of her taking all my stuff…big and small. • “My husband moved out of our home on 12.01.07. On Friday 01.07.08 he showed up at the house at around 12:30 pm. I was getting ready to leave for work. I was carrying files and my purse. I opened the front door to let the dog out. When I did I saw a white van backing into the driveway. I recognized the van as belonging to my husband’s friend Ryan. My husband jumped out of the passenger side and walked over to the garage door and pushed the code to open the garage door. I asked him what he was doing. He said he had a right to be there and that I could call and talk to his lawyer. When the garage door opened he grabbed the baseball bats that were inside the garage. I got afraid at this point and ran to the front door and stood in front of it.” Prior to our arrival, I’d told Ryan I was fearful of Veeby going a little crazy—quite possibly attacking his van with the baseball bats we stored near the entrance of our garage. He chuckled a little at the thought, since he’d known Veeby for years, and probably didn’t feel threatened. I believed it was wisest to avoid the risk altogether. Ryan saw me throw the bats out of the way…behind the front bushes. Even though Veeby’s account describes her as being afraid, evidently she wasn’t afraid enough to run away, but instead ran and stood in front of the front door. That would be accurate—that’s why Ryan and I entered the house through the garage door. • “His friend had opened the back of the van. I was afraid he was coming to take things out of the house. I told him to leave - he yelled at me that he had every right to be there. He walked straight into me and started shoving me out of his way so he could come into the house. He was carrying a rectangular grey looking board - at the time I didn’t know what that was - I thought it was something to carry things out on. He was holding this board under his right arm and pushing and shoving me with his left hand and forearm. His friend Ryan was holding the end of the board standing behind him. My husband grabbed my right arm and pushed me very hard to the left out of his way. I screamed that he was hurting me. He walked into the house with his friend.” Such disinformation! The actual facts would negate her written version as anything other than a made-up story aimed for a judge’s ear. When I moved back into the marital house, I brought the Sound Booth I used for my recordings. It was big and heavy, almost 7 feet tall and weighing over 550 pounds, so I broke it down for easier moving. The wall panels were heavy and long enough that it took both Ryan and I to carry each panel, using two hands each. It was not physically possible to hold a wall panel under my right arm while I supposedly pushed and shoved Veeby as she indicated. Firstly, it was too heavy for me to hold my portion of it’s weight by merely clutching a panel under my arm. Secondly, and more importantly, the side length of the panel was taller than would fit between my armpit and the ground—and still be able to walk and push and shove. Not to mention that I was walking BACKWARDS and UP the steps entering into the house with Ryan on the other end—facing forward and walking towards the house. Therefore, let me clearly state: It was physically impossible and I vehemently deny touching, pushing or shoving Veeby at anytime during my moving back in. • “On Saturday morning 01.08.08 I noticed bruises on my right forearm and upper arm from the struggle on Friday. I got the paperwork that the officer gave me. I called the police dept. and was told I could come down and they would document it. I went down and spoke to an officer. He filed a report and gave me a CAD#. I noticed later that day I had another bruise on my left arm.” Very Important Point—IF I had pushed and shoved Veeby before the police got there, she would most definitely have let them know once they arrived. It wasn’t until the following day that she added her claims of having been pushed or shoved—with bruises—into the police report. She specifically told Lawyer #1 of her intent to file a Restraining Order and she needed the documentation. • “I dialed 911. He began moving furniture around in the dining room. I asked repeatedly for them to stop moving furniture. I said he could not take anything. The 911 dispatcher was on the phone with me. My husband kept yelling at me to talk to his lawyer. He was very agitated. I was afraid." "The dispatcher said the police were on their way. I ran out of the house when my husband came towards the front door where I was standing. The front door had remained open. I ran to my neighbors house…Sherry was not home but Phil and his son Stuart were. Stuart was in the garage and I asked him to come help me - that John was taking things from the house. As we started to walk back across the yard the police arrived. A female cop spoke with me and a male cop went to speak to my husband. I was standing by the front door and shaking scared. I told the officer I am in the process of getting divorced the papers are not finalized and that he had moved out voluntarily on Dec. 20th. I had not changed the locks on him but he had come into the house in an agitated way and I was afraid of what he was doing.” I do not remember yelling at Veeby and I didn’t consider myself agitated, per se. I was working with Ryan and moving heavy items, so perhaps my breathing heavily might be perceived as agitated? Perhaps my being verbally direct with Veeby was not my normal calmer self? I don’t know. I do remember telling her over and over that I was moving back in—moving things back IN—but she seemingly couldn’t hear me nor understand what was going on. At my lawyer’s suggestion, I had a copy of the Deed to present to the police which showed both Veeby and myself as owners of the house. I was trying to anticipate and hopefully disarm any escalations. Even though the report filed by the police mentioned that they specifically told her she was not allowed to change the locks, that’s one of the first things she did later that day. Veeby began changing the locks and locking down the house. • “The male officer took my husband outside and talked to him. A third officer arrived - he came to talk to me and the female officer went to talk to my husband. He asked me if I had information about how to file a restraining order. He gave me the information. I told him I was afraid of what my husband could do. The female officer asked me if I had any problems if my husband moved some stuff back in. I was confused. I said ‘I guess not.’” I believe Veeby was “confused”—because she no longer felt in control of the situation. Her Happy, Thriving and Peaceful apple cart was toppled. • “I went back next door to my neighbors, and my husband and his friend Ryan continued in the house. The officers went back to their vehicles and then left. I watched my husband drive away in the white van with his friend. I went back inside the house and found he’d moved his dresser drawer furniture from his condo into the guest bedroom, which has a bed in it. I found my cat and dog in my son’s bedroom.” Yes, big bad me had locked the dog and cat safely away in a back bedroom. What a terribly responsible thing to do! [At least I didn’t try to drown them in the pool.] • “I got in my car and left. I met with my lawyer to instruct her to file the divorce paperwork. I had, per my lawyers instructions, met with my husband 2 days earlier - Wednesday, Jan. 5, 2008 - to inform him that I did want the divorce and if he wanted to work amicably. I told him my request and that we would have to work out an agreement. He did not say anything and left. On Friday he showed up at the house and moved his things back. He informed me he was back to stay.” Veeby’s email to me from three days before—where she acknowledged her “list of demands”—needed to be rewrapped. By using the softer “request(s)” to be amicably worked out between us, would probably sound better to a Restraining Order judge. • “On Monday [01.10.08] I went to work in the afternoon. When I got home at night he, my husband, had removed all the doors from our bedrooms and bathroom. As I stated I was very scared for my life and the lives of my children at this time. His behavior is unpredictable. He has told me and our children he does not want the divorce and I am afraid of what he will do now that I have filed for the divorce. I am very afraid because he is acting this way in front of his children which scares me. I am afraid of being in the house with my husband without a door to my bedroom and even when there is a door he breaks it down and takes it out.” I needed to remove her newly locked bedroom door to get my stuff. I removed the rest of the doors to change all the locking doorknobs, that was it. I was originally expecting to teach later after my lesson break, so I stacked the doors outside to be finished later that night. I simply didn’t want the doors to be put back on their hinges before I could replace the doorknobs. No doors were broken, nothing was being tossed around, and no family pets were harmed in the making of this saga. All the legal code words she wrote in her handwritten complaint, was Veeby just playing the system to her advantage. She was never in harm’s way. Indeed, physical altercations were never a part of our relationship. I was the one scared enough to hide all the knives in the house once I took the doors down. • “He removed the battery of the house alarm when he came back on Friday, Jan. 7, 2008. I was at work and got a total of calls 10 times. They would call me to say the alarm was going off. I advised them to call the police. I called them back but could not get any information because my husband changed the passcode. When I got home that night I saw the battery alarm had been disconnected and was gone. I cannot even put the house alarm on. I do not feel safe if my husband is in the house. I am afraid for the safety of my children. My husband is acting in a bizarre way.” Again, the security company helped me disable the alarm since Veeby had changed the Master Code. That’s why she received 10 calls from them. Also, she could have easily “put the house alarm on” if she would have plugged the system back into the wall socket. S M O K E & M I R R O R S So, all of the above comprises an illusionary tale presented to a judge pleading for him to grant Veeby a Restraining Order against me—and some Judge actually signed the dumb thing! I suppose it’s better for the judicial system to ere on the side of caution, but REALLY? When I learned of her accusations—and knew that the majority were made up and false—I couldn’t believe it. It felt like I had just been stabbed in the back by one of those darn kitchen knives. How did that happen? • • • • • I was completely unaware during that entire Tuesday that Veeby was putting her “get him out of my house with a Restraining Order” plan into motion. I didn’t know where she was. I only knew that she was gone all day and I could breath freely. Having just regained access to my music studio [newly designated storage area], I moved my CD collection and old album collection from the house studio to another storage location, then came back to teach my regular schedule of lessons—until 7:55 pm. At 7:55 pm, I was served a TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER by two officers. I was just finishing up a lesson with a student, when they knocked and entered. I was not able to teach my 8 pm student—I had to turn her away when she arrived. The officers informed me that I was to have NO CONTACT with Veeby—or Noelle or Mark—until a Hearing, approximately 14 days from then. She had been given 100% temporary sole custody of both kids. She had been given temporary exclusive use and possession of the house. I was to be escorted out of the house by the police…RIGHT THEN. They told me that it was now considered a Domestic Violence case, and any violation would land me in jail for not honoring the Restraining Order. I called some neighbors and asked them to help me quickly throw some of my clothes in their car. An officer walked through the house with me as I collected a few of my things for my car. I had to leave the furniture I’d moved back in. I had to surrender the house key and the garage remote control—and then the officers made sure I drove off the property. Veeby was parked in her car with the kids just down the block—waiting to “take possession” of our marital house. Since I had not yet returned my key to the condo, I was able to spend the night there. All I knew was that I had not done anything from which I needed to be restrained…yet, I had just been evicted. I didn’t know anything about Restraining Orders…I just knew this was a huge hurt to my heart.

27 Moved Back Out…AGain!

I woke up the next morning with the realization that I had just been ejected from the marital house. With help from a Restraining Order, two police officers and a couple of friends, I was moved back out…again…to the little condo. The officers from the night before were nice—they indicated they knew I’d just gotten screwed big time. I was learning the Game of Divorce as it unfolded. I felt dizzy. I drove to Carol’s office to give them a copy of the Restraining Order. They then requested the divorce case and domestic violence case be heard by the same judge, instead of two separate judges, which was eventually granted. I received a Hearing date…for 17 days later. I needed to line up a new place to teach my private lessons. Courtesy of the Restraining Order, I was no longer able to teach at the house until the Hearing. I spoke with a couple of locations—none of those places worked out. I did not want to lose any of my students, so I altered my schedule. Allowing for travel time between students, I arranged to go to their homes for piano lessons. What I really wanted to know was: Where had my piano been taken? Mark had already invited me to attend an Art Museum event on the upcoming Friday evening in which he would be honored. According to the Restraining Order, I couldn’t contact him to let him know I would miss the event, was excited and proud of him, and would be thinking of him. I wrote him an email, but couldn’t send it. I emailed it to him many weeks later on. Mark, As I write this email, it is the Wednesday before the Friday you will receive special recognition for your 6th grade Martin Luther King Theme artwork at the Museum. I just want to remind you, I am SO proud of you and glad that others are beginning to recognize your artistic abilities as well. I was definitely planning on attending this special event. Unfortunately, life threw me a curve ball last evening when the police arrived to serve me some legal papers, preventing me from seeing you or making any contact with you for the next two weeks. I am sorry that I will not be there on Friday evening. If I were to go, the police would place me in jail for violating their request. I have never experienced this level of hurt before. I ask for your patience during this time. If I could have been there, I would have been there. I’ve ALWAYS been there before—I’m the proud Dad behind the video camera—and plan on continuing to be at your special events in the future. KEEP FLOATING, SON. Love, Dad I then spoke with Eliana, who was very upset about the unfolding events. I was able to have a great Dad moment and calmed her down. I told her I was putting a life preserver around her and throwing her into the turbulent seas, but that if she would just FLOAT on top of the waves—while they crashed all around her—she would be all right. We cried together, but it really calmed us both. I told her to be a good big sister with her younger siblings, and to stay in touch. A long and emotional day—thank goodness I could compartmentalize. I had to teach a class at the university later that evening.

28 17 Days

Thus began 17 days of not being able to see our children. I found that no contact or communication with my kids absolutely devastated me. If felt like hell on earth, but I soon learned…I had only just entered the gates. Being a very involved father meant I was at every parent-teacher conference, every elementary school event and graduation, every middle school ceremony and every high school straight “A” breakfast—I never missed one. Of course, I often had a video camera in my hands, blending in with the other parents. My lawyer, Carol, immediately began trying to set up a timesharing schedule with Noelle and Mark. She contacted Veeby through Lawyer #1 and then submitted a proposed Agreed Order on a Temporary Parenting Plan to the judge. We knew it would be “in the best interest of the minor children.” Of course, Veeby’s camp would not agree, claiming it was not in the “children’s best interest” for me to see the kids. Even though I was to have no contact with Veeby and our children, I was still trying to remain financially responsible with the household bills. When I tried to pay the cable bill, I was informed Veeby had taken me off the account and “made a payment.” With no communication, I didn’t know how much she’d paid—payment in full or a partial payment—and I didn’t know if I owed her for my half or not. Later, I would discover other services she’d taken over, but then refused to pay. Plan A’s division of the household bills was quickly coming unraveled. The war cry from Veeby and Lawyer #1 appeared to be “kick him when he’s down.” Several days after the Restraining Order was put in place, they accused me of going to the children’s schools in an attempt to see them. Wait…WHAT? Lawyer #1 wrote Carol and condescendingly suggested that I either hadn’t read the Restraining Order or simply couldn’t understand it. She instructed Carol to “control her client” [moi]…or they were going to “tell on me” to the Judge for any and all violations! At first, I was shocked at the accusation. It was completely false, but also vague as to what I supposedly did. Did I go to the school office and try to sign the kids out? Did I drive by in my car to “see” my children from a distance? What did I allegedly do? I hadn’t tried to see the kids—I could read—I understood. I believed Veeby made this up, just another barrel she could throw in my way, just another accusation to put me on the defensive. I also thought Lawyer #1 was a little snide in her writing, but I hadn’t seen anything…yet. Carol’s paralegal, Kelley, responded with my adamant denial of their accusation and requested more information—i.e., “If you have spoken to someone directly at the school, please provide their name so that we may depose them.”—but no further reply or information was received. It felt like they just drove by and took a shot at me. I felt overwhelmed and a little numb to the the barrage of obstacles Veeby had thrown in front of me—with the Restraining Order, and now this. I found myself trying to FLOAT—trying to hold my breath until some far off Hearing date before some judge. During that time, I had my support people reminding me to just relax and “cool it”—not to do anything rash. I heard them…I wasn’t going to mess with the process. I was just amazed at how it was unfolding. Again, I had never before played the Game of Divorce, so I was learning as I went. It was good to have Carol and her team behind me.

29 Counter-Petition

After I filed my Petition for Dissolution of Marriage, Veeby then filed her “Answer” to the issues raised within my Petition. She then filed a “Counter-Petition” as well. Basically, “HE wants to divorce ME? Well, I want to divorce him, too!” Lawyer #1 filed Veeby’s Answer—which admitted and agreed with most of my Petition, except: • She wanted sole parental responsibility—based on her claims about my actions and behavior; • She finally admitted we jointly owned the house; • She finally admitted she had “removed some personal items.” However, there were specific paragraphs within my Petition that Veeby didn’t agree with—therefore she “Denied” and “demanded strict proof thereof:” • Veeby denied that I was a piano teacher; • She denied that she removed my grand piano or any other items; [they must have vanished by themselves?] • Denied that she was interfering with my livelihood in any way; • She absolutely did not install locks on all the doors in the house;[they just mysteriously “appeared?”], and • Veeby demanded proof that I had actually “hired” Carol’s law firm to represent me. [Evidently, receiving legal paperwork from Carol on my behalf wasn’t enough proof?] Of course, most of the information she “Denied” was verifiably TRUE. I wasn’t sure why she needed to demand proof…other than a legal exercise to prolong the process. • • • • • Then…[drum roll, please]…her COUNTER-PETITION FOR DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE WITH DEPENDENT OR MINOR CHILDREN A Reduction of just some of her legally filed paperwork follows: • “She” was also divorcing “Me”; • Her lawyer would do all the legal work on her behalf; • Yep, the marriage was irretrievably broken; • He may have engaged in marital misconduct; • He may have depleted marital assets; • She wanted sole parental responsibility of kids; • Don’t forget, Judge, HE has a Temporary Domestic Violence Injunction against him; • Child Support—She wants a lot; • Alimony—she wants a hefty monthly stipend, please; • He should pay all medical insurance for the children; • She considered all the jewelry and cash she removed before filing paperwork as Non-Marital Assets…[so it’s okay]; • Of course, all remaining assets should be equitably distributed; • He should pay off any remaining debts we incurred…not her; • Again, “upon information and belief” he depleted marital assets and she would give juicy details later; • He took my computer…don’t let him sell it! • • • • • Reading her Counter-Petition was maddening. There were so many untruths and “upon information and belief” innuendos—absolutely unbelievable! Not only was the marriage irretrievably broken, but she incorporated the term “marital misconduct”—which included a broad range of allegations—as an attempt to influence the court’s decision regarding financial awards. She also suggested I may have “depleted marital assets” so as to wave another red flag before the Court. She was basically asking for an unequal distribution of our assets. Within the next section, I was accused of “engaging in certain conduct that has been detrimental to the children and against their best interest. Moreover, he has consistently been in violation of shared parental responsibility and has been unilaterally making decisions for the minor children, without consulting Veeby.” So, on the one hand—there was a certain vagueness about her accusations. There was no specificity as to what I was supposedly doing that was somehow hurting our children. The entirety of our parenting had been “shared,” so what changed? How was I violating shared parental responsibility when we had no divorce agreement or Parenting Plan in place? The kids were already living with Veeby in the house per our Plan A. My condo was too small and not conducive for them to live with me. Besides, were these words from Veeby or creative legal talk from Lawyer #1? On the other hand—Veeby complained I wasn’t spending enough time with the children. So while she was suggesting I spend more time with the kids, if I took them to the movies or out to eat or we went over to the condo, the time I spent with our children magically morphed into my making UNILATERAL DECISIONS and was somehow AGAINST THEIR BEST INTERESTS? S M O K E & M I R R O R S The kids and I were just living life—and dealing with the change in routines, courtesy of Veeby’s decision to end the marriage. If the children and I went somewhere, I had never before had to get Veeby’s “permission”—I was Dad and simply went out with the kids. We would typically leave a note where we’d gone at the house or send a text, if needed. Now that our Separation was turning into a Divorce, Veeby’s power of belief seemingly changed into a fear I was going to take “her children” away from her. Where would I take them? My life with our children and my livelihood were centered in that area. She seemingly operated from that place of fear. In contrast, Veeby could go and do whatever she wanted with the kids under the same scenario without my screaming she was making Unilateral Decisions. I believed it simply boiled down to fear and control for Veeby. S M O K E & M I R R O R S Then I was accused of “… engaging in inappropriate behavior and this has caused turmoil and confusion for the children. A Parenting Plan which specifies a timesharing schedule and allocates responsibility for the daily tasks associated with the children should be entered. The minor children should continue to reside with Veeby and spend the majority of their time with Veeby during the pendency of these proceedings and thereafter, through their minority and John should set a set timesharing schedule that is in the best interests of the minor children, taking into consideration John’s conduct and unilateral decision making.” It appeared the “inappropriate behavior” included my (1) moving back into our house; (2) taking down the doors to get my stuff and changing the locks; and, (3) canceling her Disneyland vacation, etc. Which of course was completely different than any accusation of “inapprop-riate behavior” I might claim regarding her (1) moving my grand piano out of the house to prevent me from teaching there; (2) moving the big screen TV out, and disassembling the entire entertainment system the family used; and, (3) making claims of physical assault. No other reason needed to be given why the children should reside with her…until they were 18. It was completely obvious [to Veeby] that my actions were “wrong” and her actions…didn’t count. S M O K E & M I R R O R S I did not appreciate the continued storyline within the Counter-Petition of my having “assaulted” Veeby or having “forced his way in” or “breaking off” the doors and “removed them from the home.” I continued to claim those accusations were not true and were misleadingly represented. The wording used by Lawyer #1 suggested they were factual events, when in fact they were disputed events—and the determination Hearing was several more days away. • • • • • Before Lawyer #1 got involved, Veeby and I had already discussed finances as we set up our Plan A. While we didn’t use the labels “Child Support” or “Alimony,” the financial amount I would give her monthly would have allowed her and the children to stay in the house and pay more than half of their household expenses. It was a significant amount of money, leaving me just barely enough for my little condo and a little food. At the time, I didn’t mind making that sacrifice for my family. • • • • • However, when I read the Counter-Petition’s request for Alimony section, I made a terrible discovery—someone had rewritten our history. [I grabbed a bag of popcorn and sat down to read it again.] Veeby claimed that during the marriage we had agreed I would work full-time and she would either not work or only work part-time to care for the minor children. [WHAT?] She further claimed she had always been dependent on my financial support during the course of the marriage and she didn’t have any other way of supporting herself—so of course, I should give her tons of money every month. In truth, during our marriage Veeby and I had always toggled the children’s care between our work schedules…ALWAYS. She was never a “stay at home wife,” nor was I the sole bread winner. She worked and I worked. We combined our incomes to create a life together. The parenting schedule was simple: when she was at work, I took care of the kids, and vice versa. For the last 15 years, she met with private financial clients five (5) days a week as her regular work schedule. Before that, she worked full-time for eight (8) years at a college in Denver, and full-time within a bank for years before that. To claim that Veeby only worked on a part-time basis was misleading. Her seeing 20-25 private financial clients per week at her hourly rate—which was more than double my rate for music lessons—allowed her to make about the same income as me. There were also extra hours she spent writing her appointment notes, making phone calls and filling out necessary financial forms—all of which translated into a nice full-time “private practice” job. The only way to represent a larger disparity between our incomes, thus creating an illusionary Alimony argument, was to intentionally misrepresent her income on legally submitted forms. Reading her claim that “Veeby is dependent upon John for her support and has been dependent upon him for support during the course of the parties’ marriage” was infuriating. • • • • • The Counter-Petition also alleged that I was “refusing to pay Veeby any sums for alimony and/or child support.” Of course, that was ridiculously false. I had continued to meet my financial obligations towards the mortgage and household bills since I moved to the little condo. Bank records easily proved the transfer of money from my account into our joint account for the payment of bills…at her 55/45 division…period. The Restraining Order then prevented me from coordinating upcoming bills directly with Veeby. Even though the joint accounts were then closed per her request, I went ahead and paid her electric bill and Noelle’s braces payment in full. It was not reasonable that she expected to have it both ways. She took away my ability to teach lessons at the house and legally Restrained me with no contact or communication. Yet, she still expected I would continue to pay my portion of her household bills? However, that’s exactly what I did! I continued to pay my portion of our mortgage and household bills. I was not a deadbeat dad. I was a responsible and caring father—soon to become a “former” husband. Additionally, she wanted me “restrained and enjoined by Court Order” from touching her computer or disposing of marital assets. Evidently, she desired that I just be RESTRAINED in all facets of life. I fully expected legal papers to be filed that would restrain me from eating and breathing as well. I had not sold or gotten rid of any of our “things” or assets. The only thing I had in my possession was her computer…and I hadn’t even turned it on. There were no files on it that I needed to access. It was just her work files and database, which I’d created for her. I simply wanted some leverage to trade her stuff for my stuff. However, she then did the whole Restraining Order thing—and then we couldn’t talk except through the lawyers. In an apparent oversight, she omitted all the assets she’d taken out of our home, which was detrimental to my livelihood. Lying dormant within all the Counter-Petition verbiage was one little phrase, hidden in plain sight: “…upon information and belief has been romantically involved with another woman.” Ever since the mere possibility was placed in her mind, the power of her fear spun that little thread into a full blown tapestry of possibilities. Veeby didn’t seem able to drop the needle and thread, instead choosing to stab me with that sharp little needle every chance she got. She simply couldn’t hear or accept the fact that she was wrong!

30 Veeby's Lawyer #2

Just one day before the Temporary Restraining Order Hearing was to occur, Carol received notice that Veeby had changed lawyers. Wait…WHAT? After Lawyer #1 filed the Counter-Petition, Veeby replaced her. Lawyer #1 had provided legal guidance, filed the Answer and Counter-Petition and corresponded back and forth a little with Carol. However, Veeby replaced her with a different lawyer. I had no idea what happened…just that Lawyer #1 was out. Goodbye! Carol made contact with the new opposing counsel…Lawyer #2…and provided a detailed summation email. We wanted to bring her up to speed, and hopefully resolve all the spiraling craziness. However, Lawyer #2’s nasty bulldog reputation preceded her. I soon came to understand for myself. I found Lawyer #2 to be loud and obnoxious. I found her writing style to be extremely inflammatory in tone. From the very beginning of her legal representation, the vile accusations and innuendos contained within her written words hurt me. I eventually toughened up to the tongue lashing and mud slinging. Evidently, Lawyer #2’s way of practicing law was not as civil nor polite as I expected it to be. I met Lawyer #2 just before entering the Temporary Restraining Order Hearing…and immediately was not impressed.

31 We Had a Little Hearing

Prevented from communicating or contacting my children for 17 days, we finally had a little Hearing to consider Veeby’s Restraining Order accusations. The Restraining Order Hearing took place on a Thursday morning and began at 9:45 am in the Judge’s chambers. In attendance was the Judge, myself with Carol’s representation, Veeby with Lawyer #2’s representation, and my friend, Ryan, as the “star” witness. Carol and I only learned the previous day that Veeby had replaced her first lawyer and retained the services of some “big guns” lawyer. I met Lawyer #2 briefly before we all filed into chambers. I remember wondering if she’d had time to learn all the facts about the case. My concerns were warranted as Lawyer #2 proceeded to misstate the “facts” throughout the Hearing. My friend, Ryan, could testify and confirm that I had not physically hurt Veeby in any way. Veeby didn’t line up any of the neighbors or police officers as witnesses. Her friend, Mary, came along for Veeby’s “emotional” support, but wasn’t allowed to attend the Hearing. Before we were called into chambers, Lawyer #2 asked to speak with Carol to try and “work things out” prior to going before the Judge. Carol asked them to drop the Domestic Violence charges, bring back the grand piano and TV, and let me teach at the house on Mondays and Tuesdays [our original Plan A.] We were willing to stipulate Veeby could have exclusive right and possession of the house the rest of the time. Lawyer #2 would not agree to this, so we all filed into chambers and began the Hearing. Ryan and Mary got to wait outside in the lobby. • • • • • The Judge who held my fate…seemed nice upon my first impression. Evidently, he was “into” clocks—they were all over his chambers—that’s how I knew we began at 9:45 am. After he “swore in” Veeby and myself, he asked her some initial questions. He needed to hear from the “victim” of domestic violence just exactly what she thought had happened. A fly on the wall within the Judge’s chambers would have heard Veeby tell the Judge she was “very, very scared”…“feared for our children’s safety and [her] own safety”…“didn’t know what was happening”…“was very scared” and “was very, very confused.” Supposedly, I “grabbed and pushed” and “grabbed [her] arms [which caused] bruises from that” and “Yes, I am afraid of him.” Then Lawyer #2 called Veeby as her first [and only] witness. They produced pictures of the master bedroom door which showed scratches around the doorknob from my having pried off the lock—they said the door was “broken.” Of course it was not mentioned that the majority of the scratches on that door came from the dog of the previous owners of the house. Although not visually appealing, the door was fully functional. Some blurry pictures were also admitted into evidence which showed Veeby’s arms held up against a dated newspaper—like a hostage—as proof that…I’m not quite sure what it proved. I guess it proved she had small bruises on her forearms…and she accused me of causing those. Lawyer #2 made a big deal about the bats, that I was waving them in the air and threatening Veeby. According to Veeby, everything was relatively amicable until I arrived back on January 7th and “started swinging bats and attacking me and grabbed my arms. That’s when everything changed.” I was surprised that what began as my genuine concern for Ryan’s van, would be blown up by Veeby into “[John] was swinging bats at me.” Of course, instead of running away, she told the Judge she stood in front of the door to prevent my entry. All pure silliness. No bats were swung and no bats were harmed in the making of this saga. Veeby began omitting information concerning my studio, claiming that “He had nothing left in the house that was his” and “He has nothing left in there [studio]. He took all of that when he moved out” when she clearly knew that was not the case. Indeed, she placed a second keyed lock on my studio door—in addition to the newly keyed lock on the master bedroom door—to further prevent me from accessing some music equipment and teaching supplies [among other things] which I had stored in my studio. Back when things were “amicable,” we agreed that I would use the music studio to store some of my things, since I didn’t have room for everything in the small condo. When everything went sideways—she basically locked down the house. A lot of my items were then taken and squirreled away in “her” master bedroom. I was able to take lots of pictures of all those items…once I took off the locks on the doors. The evidence exists. Veeby’s semantical games continued with word play surrounding my “studio”—i.e., my teaching studio versus my music studio. It was a game she thoroughly enjoyed, almost like an under-age teenager lying about their age to access a cool club. When discussing my private teaching studio and the missing piano, she testified that, “He doesn’t have a studio in the house…he has a piano.” Knowing her as well as I did, I knew her statements were purposefully misleading—trying to sway the Judge’s understanding—and all the while trying to avoid responsibility for her actions. Carol then began asking Veeby about the missing grand piano and TV. It was absolutely hilarious! Here’s what that fly on the wall heard: ~ from the transcript ~ [Carol (C), Veeby (V), Judge (A), Lawyer (#2)] C: The picture that you just put into evidence, isn’t it true that that’s your husband’s website picture trying to get students for his music studio in the home? V: I do not know what he has on his website right now. C: [chuckle] That’s how the living room looked prior to January 9th, correct? V: That’s our living room at our house. C: Can you look at this picture? Do you recognize that picture? V: That’s our living room at our house. C: And what’s not in the living room? V: There’s a lot of things not in the living room. C: The piano’s not there, correct? V: Correct. C: Because you had it removed on Sunday while he was at the university, isn’t that true? V: Sunday…he went to his job at the university, correct. C: And you had a moving company come and remove the piano out of the house? The 600 pound piano, correct? V: I don’t how many pounds it weighs. C: But, yes? V: The piano is no longer in the family living room. C: The question is, did you hire or cause his piano, that he used to teach his piano students, to be removed from the house? V: It’s not his piano. The piano belongs to the family. A: Ma’am, Ma’am, it’s a simple question. Did you have the piano taken out of the house? V: The piano is not in the house anymore. C: Did it get up and walk away? Tell me how it got out of the house? Do you know where the piano is? V: Yes, ma’am. C: Because you moved it, correct? V: I did not move it. A: Did you have it moved? V: It was moved. C: On the same day that the piano went “missing,” did you also have the TV—his 60-inch TV that he bought for his birthday four years ago—removed from the home as well? A: Did you have the television moved? V: The television is no longer in the family home. A: Ma’am, ma’am, ma’am…it’s not a trick question. 
Is that a yes or a no? [exasperated sigh heard] V: I did not move the TV. A: Did you have it moved? V: It was moved. C: Who moved it? V: Not me. #2: Who moved it, if you know? V: It was moved by some movers. C: That you hired? V: No ma’am C: You didn’t pay? V: No. C: They were friends? It doesn’t matter. I’m sure the Judge understands what’s going on. Veeby’s avoidance word play as she verbally wiggled around and wouldn’t answer either Carol’s or the Judge’s questions was perhaps not the smartest choice. The Judge eventually tired of her spinning word webs and called her on it: Ma’am, ma’am, ma’am, ma’am! Look, I’m sitting here, I’m the Tryer of Fact. I understand the two issues, but Ma’am, it sounds to me like you’re getting cute with your answers. Just answer the question…it’s simple. [then, he let out a long exasperated sigh] • • • • • My personal favorite was the word play that SHE didn’t move the piano nor the TV. When directly asked by the Judge, “Did you have it moved?” and Carol asked, “Who moved it?” and even her own lawyer asked, “Who moved it, if you know?”…Veeby simply answered, “Not me.” Of course, Veeby conveniently forgot to mention her email exchange with the movers the day before the piano and TV mysteriously vanished: Mover Man: Regarding piano moving tomorrow, my address is [###]. My phone is [###–###–####]. Please let me know if you can be here to move the piano and large screen TV tomorrow, Sunday Jan. 9th in the morning. Thank you, Veeby The Mover Man responded the same day: Hello, Got your email, and I will call you as well. • • • • • Lawyer #2 called me as a witness and tried very hard to convince the Judge that I was “angry” when I moved back into the house. She insisted within her questions that I was angry—and that’s why I physically assaulted Veeby—because I was angry. I continued to calmly state I wasn’t angry. She tried to paint the picture that I pushed and grabbed Veeby’s arm to force my way into the marital residence. I kept thinking about how this poor misguided attorney had been misled by Veeby’s tale. The first day, no claims of physical assault. The second day, Veeby claimed small bruises. Following days, it grew into pushing and shoving. At the Hearing, the word “scratches” was introduced. I’m pretty sure I saw Veeby’s hand had a hangnail in those pictures as well…luckily, she didn’t notice. Door removal…what a funny thread. As weird and strange as it might have appeared to the Judge, the removal of doors within our house had been done a couple of times before—as a discipline strategy with our kids. Since we didn’t use corporal punishment for our children, we were often creative in their discipline. It’s actually a discipline option discussed on the internet and Veeby was ever vigilantly guarding the children’s development. I believe there was never really an issue for Veeby regarding her safety without the doors…it was just a “move” within the Game of Divorce she was playing. Again, no doors were broken. I took the doors off their hinges to gain access to my stuff, changed the locks and then rehung the doors. I was questioned several more times by Lawyer #2 about the whole “anger” theme. When I was finally allowed to speak a little more freely, I told the Judge my side—and I felt like he listened. I restated that I had no history of violence against Veeby, and had never hit her during our 33+ years together. Next at bat [bad pun intended] was the star witness…Ryan was up! The Judge later complimented him as the most credible witness at the Hearing [MVP award]. Ryan confirmed what I’d been saying the whole time—that I had not touched Veeby. He also reaffirmed that the Sound Booth side panels were too heavy to have allowed me to carry one under my arm while pushing and shoving with the other. On cross-examination, Lawyer #2 suggested that he was lying for his friend [moi]…and Ryan got royally ticked off. The Judge finally began to wrap up the Hearing. What was supposed to only be a 15 minute Hearing, turned into a 45 minute show. • • • • • Within the Judges concluding remarks, Veeby was slapped on the wrist for removing the piano and TV. The Judge said he’d “never heard of anything like that in all the years he’d been there.” He called her actions “weird” and “really, really, really, really unusual”—that’s FOUR (4) “really’s!” I earned one “beyond weird,” one “strange,” and one “really, really strange” for removing the doors [even though I put them back]. Since I only had “one pair” and Veeby received “four of a kind,” I guess she “won” that round. Evidently, Veeby was more “unusual” than I was “strange.” The Judge didn’t believe Veeby’s “swinging bats” allegation. Unfortunately, the Judge couldn’t see clearly through the “he touched her” issue, since Ryan wasn’t glued beside me the entire time. Erring on the side of caution, the Judge extended the Temporary Restraining Order [Injunction] for an additional 45 days, but only specific to Veeby—not the children. Essentially, he built in additional time for both parties to “cool off.” [I was relieved to later learn that since no criminal charges were filed against me, once the Restraining Order automatically terminated 45 days later, it would not remain on my record.] • • • • • The Judge ordered Veeby to put the piano and TV back by Monday 3 pm. He allowed me to teach in the house on Mondays and Tuesdays for the next 45 days—allowing Veeby Exclusive Use and Occupancy the rest of the time. He encouraged me to move to a bigger place to allow for the children and my teaching. [I was also supposed to get a key to the marital house, but Veeby never gave me a key = CONTROL!] The Judge clarified the current Family Law statutes—the old model [where there was a Primary Residential Parent with the Other Parent just received “visitation”] was no more. The new paradigm was 50/50 Time Sharing with a Parenting Plan in place, to be figured out through counsel. Carol then asked if I could see my children that evening, pointing out that it had been 17 days since I’d seen them [thanks, Carol]. The Judge asked if there was any objection from Veeby’s camp. Of course Lawyer #2 objected! The Judge then did the right thing and let me see the children immediately and through the entire weekend…yeah! I took the opportunity to ask the Judge if I could get my stuff back—i.e., the furniture items I’d moved back into the marital house. Since I had been walked off the property without my bureau—[thanks to the Restraining Order and those big, burly police officers]—my clothes were in piles on the floor back at the condo. Of course, Lawyer #2 exclaimed, “That’s kinda ridiculous.”—which ticked off the Judge. He proceeded to call her assertion as “unreasonable” and since he was also the Judge in the Family Case, he just might remember all the craziness emanating from Veeby’s camp. He went on to state, “… if it was okay with Veeby for him to take his stuff…the bureau…to his apartment in December, why in the world…in anybody’s wildest stretch of the imagination…would it not be okay for him to get it back into his place? Tell me! Give me one good reason…one bad reason…give me a bad reason. There is none. Because there is none! So let him get his stuff.” • • • • • Finally finished with the official Hearing, everyone filed back out of the Judge’s chambers. I learned that all that had been stated during the Hearing then had to be written out by the attorneys and then signed by the Judge as an official “Order.” However, Carol and the Judge immediately left together for a different trial in another courtroom close by—so, the rest of use had to wait about an hour until that was finished. Lawyer #2 began writing the issues into an Order for the Judge to sign, but we basically had to wait until Carol returned. Eventually, Carol rejoined us in the waiting area and the two lawyers finished writing out the details of the Order. Since Lawyer #2 had just come on board as Veeby’s counsel, and both lawyers knew each other professionally, Carol began telling #2 the long list of things Veeby had been up to. When Carol spoke about charging a $2000 Disneyland vacation on my credit card, Veeby literally screamed that she had NOT done that—stated we had no proof—and besides, “It was only for Eliana’s birthday weekend!” Wait…WHAT? Even in her denial, Veeby admitted. Carol and I tried to help Veeby a little. Since I would have to break my lease and find another place to live and teach from, we offered she could just wait to move the piano to the [to be determined] new location around March 1st, since I could just use the rental piano to teach at the marital house until then. However, Veeby stated she didn’t have any money to move the piano back. We reiterated we were trying to give her a month before she had to move the piano, but again she claimed she didn’t have money to move the piano and TV back into the house. I’d finally had enough “trying to be nice” and asked Carol to just write it into the Order the way the Judge had stated—that Veeby was to have the piano and TV moved back into the marital house in three days time—by Monday at 3 pm. Once written and agreed upon by all parties, the Judge returned and signed the handwritten Order. His signature on the Order not only extended the Restraining Order specific to Veeby for an additional 45 days, but gave me Exclusive Use and Possession to teach at the marital home on Mondays and Tuesdays. Veeby left immediately…Lawyer #2 expressed that Veeby was “too overwhelmed” and simply had to leave. • • • • • I needed to quickly find a Rule Book for the Game of Divorce. I wanted to further understand what was going on and exactly how “the system” worked. As I began to explore and research the legal system and the state statutes, I found it interesting that our state considered perjury—which included statements made before a Judge in an official proceeding—a third degree felony. Further, our state defined “false official statements” as “whoever knowingly makes a false statement with the intent to mislead a public servant in the performance of his or her official duty shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided in….” Hmmm. I believed the passive-aggressive nature of Veeby’s semantical games would probably allow some wiggle room, since she could always claim there might have been an “unintentional misstatement or mistake” so therefore, it would not be considered intentional perjury. Wiggle, wiggle…wink, wink.

32 I Get to See My Kids…NOT

After I received my copy of the freshly signed Order from the Judge, I immediately drove to Noelle’s high school to pick her up. I’d take her out of school a little early and explain what all had happened. Upon arrival, I went to the front counter and spoke to Ms. Lana. I explained that I was sure Veeby had already informed them about the Temporary Restraining Order [she affirmed by nodding] and that I had a copy of the newly signed Order allowing me to see my kids. I let her make a copy for the school records and asked that Noelle be called to the office for early dismissal. However, they wouldn’t—or couldn’t—until they received “permission” from Veeby to release her. Ms. Lana informed me Veeby was already on her way to the school. Wait…WHAT? Who called Veeby? After I’d been standing at the counter for 15 minutes, Veeby walked in—with Mary still in tow—and upon seeing me standing there, Veeby began yelling, “I have a Restraining Order against this man! He’s not supposed to be within 500 feet of me!” Alrighty, then. All the office staff turned to look in our direction at the little incident in progress—wondering if they should call campus security to the front counter. Ms. Lana scanned Veeby’s driver’s license, gave her a Visitor’s Pass and the royal procession began. With head held high and cell phone scepter lovingly positioned in hand, she slowly walked right in front of me—welcomed into the sacred Hallway of School Administrators. I was told to sit down and wait. Five minutes later, an Administrator came out and informed me that Noelle “did not have the ‘key’ I wanted and that she didn’t want to see me.” Huh? I didn’t understand. I hadn’t asked for any “key” and I wanted to see my daughter. However, Noelle never came out to see me. For some reason, the school was protecting her…from me…even though the Judge had just determined it was fine. I found out later that Veeby had called ahead to the school while driving and they pulled Noelle out of class to meet with mom. She was waiting for mom in the Guidance Office—and boy, did she get some guidance. With an administrator present, Veeby spoke directly to Noelle—and told her what all had just occurred in Court—and that she didn’t have to go with me, etc. [The Administrator informed me of this the following day]. So, sadly, I didn’t get to see Noelle at all that day. I felt thwarted by Veeby’s actions. She blatantly tried to prevent me from seeing Noelle, in defiance of what the Judge had just told us. Later, I would come to understand the proper use of the word “contempt” in such situations. Still in shock, I then went to Mark’s middle school—fully expecting Veeby to follow me there as well, but she didn’t and Mark’s school released him into my care. He and I sat in the parking lot for about thirty minutes while I told him what all had just transpired, including the previous 17 days. I explained that he’d be spending the weekend with me. He and I then went to the Mall to hang out for about an hour. We shared cookies and milk, I taught him a cool coin trick, we walked to an optical store to get his glasses adjusted—we had a good time just hanging out. After he had some time to process things a bit, he said he wanted to sleep at the [marital] house that evening. I could understand that, so sure—but I asked him to sleep over at the condo with me the very next night, which he did. We left the Mall and I drove him over to mom’s place. I called Carol after dropping off Mark back at the house, to fill her in on Veeby’s latest actions at the school. We discussed the concept of Parental Alienation Syndrome. Carol wrote Lawyer #2 and then filed a MOTION FOR TEMPORARY PARENTING PLAN which highlighted Veeby’s recent shenanigans.

33 Put His Piano Back

Finally—validation from the Judge at the Hearing that Veeby’s removing my grand piano and TV from the house was “weird” and “really unusual” and generally “didn’t make sense.” The Judge actually said: I don’t know what was going through [Veeby’s] mind when she decided to take the piano and the television out of the house. Especially the television. I’ve never heard of anything like that in all the years I’ve been here. I mean, that’s like weird. That’s like really, really, really, really unusual. And if John gets his livelihood from piano lessons, in significant part, I mean, ya know, that’s like—it doesn’t make sense because it’s going to affect the Child Support, it’s going to affect other economic aspects of the case. It just doesn’t make sense. The Judge then ordered her to return those items: The piano and the television need to be back in the home by Monday at 3pm, and I’m going to allow John to teach his pupils on Mondays and Tuesdays in the marital house. In the waiting area after the Hearing, Veeby insisted she didn’t have money to move the grand piano and TV back into the house. While she’d had the funds to move the grand piano and TV out of the house, she no longer had the resources to remedy her predicament. That was really hard to believe given that she’d recently found the funds for a week long vacation in France, just bought herself a new car and most recently purchased a new laptop computer. I wondered where she was getting all that money? Later that afternoon, however, Veeby contacted the movers to schedule the return of those items: Hi, Mover Man. I need to speak to you urgently regarding the piano and TV. I need to schedule to have you return both to my house ASAP. Could you call me as soon as possible? Thank you, Veeby The next day…another wrinkle. Lawyer #2 contacted Carol to say that they would try really hard to get the piano and TV back by Monday, but if they couldn’t, at least I would have the rental piano. At least I finally had some comfort and confirmation that my piano hadn’t been burned and dumped into the local lake…so it was a good day overall.

34 No Towels and No Soap

The lawyers began exchanging letters and phone calls at a frantic pace the Friday after the Hearing. I could only watch as my bank account swirled down the drain. Lawyer #2 expressed their concerns over Veeby’s missing computer, baby keepsake books and financial records she needed—which we’d always kept within the filing cabinets—that just happened to be living over at my condo. Carol expressed our concerns about the return of all my stuff I’d moved back into the house. It was finally agreed between counsel that (1) I would return her computer, baby books and financial records when I arrived at the marital home on Monday and confirmed that the piano and TV had been returned; and, (2) Veeby would move all my stuff to the garage so I could easily pick it up—a nice and easy exchange, right? I quickly found out that nothing would ever be “nice and easy” when dealing with Veeby. Later that day, Lawyer #2 filed Veeby’s Financial Affidavit with the Court. They filed official documents claiming less than 50% of Veeby’s actual income. What a bold move on “her turn” in the Game of Divorce. I was completely shocked! Monday rolled around and Veeby’s computer and financial records were loaded in my car, for the hostage exchange. I was looking forward to getting some of my items from the garage back into my condo. While I was supposed to get a key to the house, it didn’t feel comfortable for Veeby, so I agreed that Noelle could just let me in since she would normally arrive home from school by that time. Unfortunately, Noelle did not let me into the house until after 3 pm. I needed to set up some room divider panels prior to my student’s arrival. Not only did I not have a key, but I also discovered Veeby had removed the outside garage door keypad. I had no way of entry if Noelle was not prompt in letting me in. CONTROL! By the time Noelle finally opened the door, my student had already been dropped off for his lesson—and had been standing outside with me for a few moments. Noelle didn’t return my greeting upon opening the door…she just retreated back into the house. The student and I both entered, only to find the grand piano and TV had miraculously reappeared…yeah! Unfortunately, they were awkwardly placed side by side in my teaching space. I needed to move the TV out of the way before I could teach my first student. My student on Monday went to wash his hands before the lesson, as he’d been taught to do, but he immediately informed me there was no soap and no hand towel in the bathroom. I couldn’t believe it! I peered inside and found that Veeby had stripped down the half-bathroom used by my students. She didn’t leave any toilet paper and had taken down the picture off the wall as well. I called out to Noelle to please bring some soap and a hand towel, but she would not reply. I went down the hallway to get those items from the 2nd bathroom and gave them to my student to use. Veeby took the toilet paper…WOW! I stopped by Noelle’s room and asked her to help me move the big screen TV back into the Family Room, but she refused. I went back and asked the student for his patience for a moment while I got everything moved around and prepared. I was able to slide the TV into the Family Room and placed it in front of the TV base. I again called out for Noelle to help me lift it up onto the stand…I was trying to be a nice guy…but she again refused to help. So, I left it on the floor in front of the base stand. I came back into the teaching space and moved the piano into a better position to teach. Then we began the piano lesson. • • • • • While I was critiquing my student’s progress from the previous week, I began to notice the pictures on the walls, the pillows on the couch, the candles on the tables, the lamps in the room—were all gone…they had all been removed. The warmth of my teaching space had been eliminated—the room seemed frozen and barren. I’m sure Veeby would have moved the furniture out of the room if she could have figured out a place to hide them. After that lesson, I had a break before my next student. I couldn’t wait to get to the garage—to see my stuff and decide what all I could load into my car. According to the recent Order, I was only allowed to move things from the garage to my car and/or back to my condo during the 3 - 8 pm time frame…only on Mondays and Tuesdays. It would prove difficult to both teach and move my stuff during a five hour window each of only two days. When I moved back in earlier in the month, I had placed my kitchen table, chairs and Sound Booth components in the dining room. I knew I would reassemble them later on, so I safely stored them out of the way in the corner until then. I noticed they were no longer in the dining room while I was teaching, but I fully expected to find them in the garage. Boy, was I wrong! When I opened the inside door which led out to the garage, instead of finding all my stuff, I saw my bureau, my desk [minus the drawers], my kitchen table [minus the chairs] and some acoustical tiles that went inside the Sound Booth. The rest of my stuff—that I fully expected to have been placed in the garage—was not there. No Sound Booth, no chairs, no night stand, no coffee table, no CD inventory. WHERE was all my stuff? I came to learn that she had most of my stuff once more under lock and key in the back of the house. REALLY? I’d left the Sound Booth right there beside the door which led out to the garage. Veeby could have moved it 20 feet and it would have been done. The Sound Booth panels were heavy, yet she moved them—i.e., had them moved, as in “Not me.”—further away from the garage. Veeby’s word was no good. What she had agreed to through her lawyer, she did not honor. She seemed to be enjoying her Game of Divorce way too much. I had her stuff and was prepared to leave it for her. Veeby chose to keep my things a little longer. CONTROL! When my last student left, I took down the room divider panels and gathered my things to depart. Per the verbal agreement through our lawyers, I went ahead and returned her computer, left the baby keepsake books and some financial records Veeby needed. Even though Veeby had not fully honored that agreement, I followed through with what I said I would do. As I was about to tell the kids goodbye, Noelle was already hovering. She instructed me that my student had gone and I needed to leave the house. As I backed out of the driveway, I saw Veeby sitting in her car down the street. She raced towards me with her lights off and pulled into the driveway as I drove away. The next day, I alerted Carol as to the previous days’ events. She was nice enough to write a polite letter to Lawyer #2 highlighting the disarray left by Veeby. When I arrived to teach later that afternoon, I immediately noticed that the big screen TV had been moved out of the Family Room and placed in the corner of the dining room. Had it been “bad” while I was gone? Was IT in a “time out” in the corner? • • • • • Evidently, even though Veeby had just paid to have the big screen TV returned to the house, per the Judge’s Order, she refused to hook it back up and use it! Seriously, though, she had a well thought out and valid point. How dare I try to leave the family a 60-inch big screen TV for the Family Room! Why, nobody was going to make her watch TV on a big screen unless she wanted to. She’ll watch her movies and shows on a smaller 27-inch TV if she wants to, gosh darn it! The kids can sit on the couches placed far away and just squint. They’ll be just fine. My first student on Tuesday alerted me that the bathroom was missing soap, a hand towel and toilet paper. Hadn’t I just lived through this the day before? I got the supplies needed from the 2nd bathroom. • • • • • Interestingly, when Noelle would not provide bathroom supplies for my students the previous day, I had to go get those items myself. At that time, I noticed Veeby had placed another keyed doorknob on the Master bedroom door. Many additional scratches appeared on the door, plus several tiny little holes seemingly drilled into the door and then covered up. I snapped a picture of the door’s new look and later placed it side by side with a picture of the door on the day I removed the locks. The bedroom door definitely looked more beaten up by the end of the month. Although the court Order allowed me to continue teaching my private lessons at the marital house until I could find a new location to move in to, Veeby kept applying not so subtle pressure to hurry up and leave “her” house. She had changed the rules of our Plan A agreement and I was left scrambling to remedy the situation. The lawyers kept spending our money—I mean, they kept communicating back and forth. They discussed Veeby’s claim that I had not provided ANY support or money toward the marital expenses, which was false and we easily disproved. Oldest daughter, Eliana, needed us to complete our joint tax return so she could get her college financial aid application turned in, so Carol requested Veeby’s financial information. Carol also introduced my concern about the affect of the divorce on the children and that I wanted to get them into therapy as soon as possible—to process things for themselves. Carol asked if Lawyer #2 have any thoughts about the proposed Temporary Parenting Plan? Carol had concerns about Veeby changing her life insurance beneficiary while we were still married and had minor children. Seemingly normal “separation” type issues still needed to be worked out. I determined that when I came to teach the following week, I should try to remember to bring my own towels and soap! Oh yeah…and toilet paper, too.

35 Smile…for the Security Camera

When I went to the house to teach the following week, yet again there was no hand towel, soap or toilet paper in the half bathroom my students needed to use. However, Veeby had raised the stakes. She also removed all the soap and hand towels from the 2nd bathroom, and from the kitchen, and even under the kitchen sink. There was nothing left for me to grab up for my students to use. The only other place that might have the needed supplies was the master bathroom—which was behind her locked door. My poor student. He’d already dutifully rinsed off his hands with water and was just standing there with dripping wet hands, so I went back to the 2nd bathroom and brought him a large bath towel to dry his hands on. The teaching space had not been returned to it’s previous warm and inviting setting. Still no lamps, no pictures, etc. Nothing had been placed in the garage for me to pick up. It appeared that Veeby continued to control the house—for whatever dark pathological reason she needed to exert that control. To further clarify that she was Large and In Charge, Veeby added yet another little twist. Security cameras appeared. A video surveillance system had been installed—with special “night vision” lenses—mounted both inside and outside the marital house. Why on earth…except to continue the charade of being scared for her life? A surveillance camera was installed just inside the front door of the house. Interestingly, the placement was not aimed at the front door to catch whomever might break in. Instead, it was aimed into the teaching space. The family never hung out in the front formal living room—that had been set up as my teaching studio. It felt like a reality show was being filmed while I taught. My students surely didn’t sign up for that! It was an invasion of their privacy for sure. I didn’t know if the footage was being streamed over the internet or recorded on a tape backup system. I didn’t know just who might be watching as I taught…or why. I didn’t know if the system was capturing audio, or only video, or if the dumb thing was even hooked up and working. All I had were questions and Veeby surely wasn’t sharing information nor communicating. Perhaps it was just a fake camera glued to the ceiling to create paranoia? The next day, I brought some tape and some paper…and covered up the dumb thing. While Veeby was supposedly hurting financially—and screaming to her lawyer to scream to my lawyer to scream to me—evidently there were funds available to purchase a surveillance system. Even though I continued to significantly contribute to the family’s finances, Veeby was claiming she could no longer pay her bills. Yet, observing how often she took the kids out to the movies and then to a restaurant, it was hard to believe her story of hardship. • • • • • I later learned that Noelle was helping her mom operate the newly acquired surveillance system. After I taught the first two days with the new video cameras in place, phone records showed that Noelle was on the phone with the security company for significant chunks of time, probably figuring out some of the technical issues. My concern was for Noelle—that mom had her running surveillance to capture her father in the act of doing WHAT?…teaching? I believed this would be detrimental to Noelle’s whole outlook on life. She had already been exhibiting some teenage angst prior to all this divorce drama and I was pretty sure participating in surveillance of her dad would not be good for her emotional well-being.

36 In a Million Words or Less

The separation and eventual divorce affected all three of our children as would be expected, but it seemingly affected Noelle the worst. In some ways, she experienced more of the normal rebellious teenager issues than the other two kids. She had to find her own way, and often needed to recreate the proverbial wheel from scratch. Veeby and I often hurt for her, as we watched her struggle with the normal growing up stuff. Watching our little butterfly struggle to break free of her cocoon, we often had to allow her to struggle herself in order to be strong enough on the other side to survive in the world. When Noelle was in 10th grade, one of her teachers asked all the student’s parents to do a little homework assignment at the beginning of the school year about their child—to give the teacher a little more understanding about the students, but from the parental perspective. Veeby completed the homework on our behalf by writing this: "In a million words or less, what can I say about Noelle? Noelle has always been a careful, cautious child. She is an avid reader and loves to learn. She is highly motivated. We have never had to stay on her to do homework or projects. When she started high school last year, her personality changed dramatically at home. She grew very withdrawn and distant from the rest of the family. Her entrance into high school coincided with her big sister leaving for college. Noelle was suddenly the oldest sibling in the house. She has a brother who is 4 years younger than her, Mark. I believe, according to her teachers last year, that Noelle has continued to be genial and pleasant in school with teachers and friends. At home she is going through her own individuation process and needs to pull away from us. We are hopeful she will be able to re-engage with us when she is ready. My hope is that she continues to love to learn and opens herself up to those experiences. I believe she likes your class very much. She is sensitive and kind but seems to have become much more cautious at showing that side of herself. Please let me know if you see anything out of the ordinary in her personality. We are wishing her a productive and happy school year. Thank you." Veeby’s words accurately reflected that time period in Noelle’s life and her pulling away from our family. While her teenage angst began long before the Game of Divorce was put into motion, the space Noelle needed to create for herself to “individuate”—would eventually be reframed as [somehow] my fault. The door will always be open and the lights will always be on to help find your way back. Come back, Noelle

37 Absolutely NO TALKING

I found myself enduring the longest Silent Treatment Tango Veeby had ever danced with me. She tried to erase me with her lack of words and hurt me with her hateful actions. While she could easily slice and dice me verbally, she was choosing to act as if I had simply died to her…it felt like I had become a ghost. All the while, she was definitely communicating—by removing my grand piano, the big screen TV and locking down the rest of my stuff. Her latest removal of towels, soap and toilet paper from the bathrooms, and not placing my stuff in the garage, was just an amplification of the Tango music. Yep, she was expressing herself quite clearly. Of course, Veeby could easily rationalize her lack of verbal communication since the Restraining Order had been extended. She could play the “in fear for her life” card within the Game of Divorce, but it sure did make Co-Parenting our children extremely difficult. Emails I sent her—simply trying to coordinate spending time with the kids—went unanswered. For me, that was an ultimate rudeness and showed Veeby’s lack of civility. During that time, I heard about Veeby’s financial hardships through Lawyer #2 communications to Carol. Continuing my “pursuit” dance moves, I tried to talk directly to Veeby, by asking Carol to send this letter to her on my behalf: Veeby, I have received word that you are having difficulties paying some of the household bills. I would like to help. However, other than for the children, I am finding it difficult to find motivation to help you. While you have been my partner for 33+ years, your actions and behaviors—and how you are choosing to end our partnership—have been shameful. While you may have gotten out of our “boat” and “washed up on the beach of love,” you are now throwing bombs back towards the boat. I am saddened that you feel the need to completely dismantle everything we’ve created. Your actions have now put into motion quite a different scenario for our children’s lives. I honored my agreement with you and gave you half the money towards the mortgage on Feb. 1st. I also paid more than half the regular joint bills for January—even after your Restraining Order. On the one hand, you’ve texted me that I no longer need to worry about your bills. On the other hand, you still need help from your partner of 33+ years. And despite how badly you’ve been behaving lately, I don’t mind helping out with the joint household bills. You need to clarify to your lawyer that I have been helping out all along. Your household bills due at the beginning of February include…. I am willing to contribute $700 towards February bills—considerably more than half the amount needed. I am hurting financially as well right now, but you and the children are my family. I have honored my commitment to you and paid more than 50% of the joint household needs since lasts December. Going forward, there will be two separate houses for our kids. You and I will both have to figure out how to make our housing affordable and safe havens while our children are still growing up. Veeby, slow…down. I am not your enemy and I pose you no potential harm. You may want to consider not buying things like laptops and security cameras. You may need to limit the movies and Chinese food for a time. Furthermore, you need to stop lying about how much money you’ve made on your Financials. You know the detailed financial reports I gave you are accurate. You wrote those exact same numbers on a post-it note...long before I left the marital house to give you the “space and time you needed to heal.” That is your handwriting.—I am not making up the numbers. You need to stop preventing me from seeing our children. You need to stop preventing me from getting my remaining personal property from the house. By filing a Restraining Order, you’ve prevented me from communicating with you directly during this very difficult transitional period. You need to stop lying that I physically assaulted you. You and I both know that I never did the things you’ve stated in the complaint…that was just a game you played to get me out of the house. Three police officers, nor Ryan, witnessed any physical touching between us. At no time during that event did you report to the officers that I’d touched or hurt you in anyway. You know that I have never physically hurt you in any way. And, if you have truly convinced yourself that I shoved you around and gave you bruises on the day I moved back into the house—then, you are truly mentally ill. You need to stop playing around with our taxes. There is no reason to not file jointly. I expect we’ll get a refund, plus this will negatively impact Eliana’s financial aid for next year. File jointly, per normal this year, then you and I will get to file as single next year—we’ll figure out deductions for the children later. You need to agree to let me come to the house and retrieve all my music equipment and personal items still stored in the music studio space and house. You don’t have to be there—have Noelle let me in and watch over the process. You want me out of the house, so let me get my stuff, and I’ll be out of the house. You need to put back all the pictures and teaching space items. This space needs to be professional for my clients. Taking all those little items is absolutely silly. You need to control your actions and behaviors in front of the kids. You’ve stated previously that you are now going to have to raise the children all by yourself. Let me reiterate—that is simply not true. You and I have Co-Parented our children for the last 20+ years and we will both continue to raise and love on them. The only change being we now have two separate households. You need to stop throwing obstacles in the path. Let us go to mediation, finalize the details, and be DONE. I’ve already returned your computer [I never turned it on] and several bags of files and folders that we kept in my file cabinets. Your former partner, John • • • • • Veeby was talking, but only with her lawyer. However, her representations to Lawyer #2 about having already moved all my belongings out to the garage—somehow never materialized. Lawyer #2 swallowed every single word Veeby fed her without question. The emails flew back and forth between the lawyers who continued to work out the details of our divorce for us. I found it interesting that although Veeby and I had previously addressed and worked out many of those topics within our Plan A, for some reason we were revisiting them—painfully slowly and one by one. I supplied Carol with financial records of Veeby’s income for the last dozen years of our marriage. Carol wrote and encouraged Veeby’s camp to amend their recently filed Financial Affidavit—and to tell the truth about Veeby’s income on their next filing. To which, Lawyer #2 basically responded, “…bite me.” We broached the subject of a Temporary Parenting Plan—with the hope of reaching an Agreed Order between parties, which would save court fees and attorney costs. Carol was advised quite condescendingly by Lawyer #2 that I should make arrangements for the children’s care on “my” weekend—and not expect to simply “drop them off to their mother.” Wait…WHAT? Blah, blah, blah…. The lawyers talking “for us” was all well intentioned, but still ineffectual and simply prolonged the process. If only Veeby would be real and be truthful—and communicate—we could get to the end of the Game of Divorce much more quickly. While Veeby wanted me to leave, she wouldn’t let me go.

38 Give Me Back My Stuff!

In the craziness of my moving out in December—then moving back in January, and then “invited” to move back out courtesy of a Restraining Order—the dividing up of all “our stuff” never actually happened. When I moved out that December, I left most of the furniture in the house for Veeby and the kids, and purchased just enough new furniture to furnish the small condo. The aftermath of the Restraining Order, and it’s temporary extension, effectively let Veeby determine what she would “give” me since she was awarded Exclusive Use and Possession of our house. Whatever she placed in the garage, I was allowed to have. We had two couches, we had two dining tables, we had a house full of furniture and I wasn’t “allowed” to discuss the distribution of our stuff with Veeby, but had to go through the lawyers—due to her well played “Restraining Order” move within her Game of Divorce. I was having a difficult time getting the stuff I’d moved back in simply placed into the garage so I could move it back out. I kept wondering why Veeby was being “allowed” to not return my stuff—in open defiance of the Court’s Order as well as the lawyer’s negotiations. That didn’t make sense to me and I didn’t understand. She was definitely playing games—telling her lawyer she’d already placed all my things in the garage when really, she had not. Veeby moved some things to the garage, but also moved some things back into her locked bedroom. Misled Lawyer #2 continued to write vile letters, effectively slinging mud up on the game board, which only made it difficult to see. The rules had been pretty clearly spelled out within the Court’s Order, but I found myself playing with an opponent that was blatantly creating her own rules. Frustrated right along with me, Carol then filed a MOTION TO RETRIEVE AND FOR RETURN OF PERSONAL PROPERTY and followed up with letters to Lawyer #2 confirming that I would pick up ALL of my personal belongings from the marital house that upcoming Monday. When I arrived to teach on Monday, FINALLY—in the garage were the majority of the items I’d left and stored in the music studio space. However, still noticeably missing were all the panels from my Sound Booth…REALLY? Also, no electric guitar, or bass guitar and still no black studio monitors. UNBELIEVABLE! Why wouldn’t Veeby simply place everything in the garage and just be done? There was no explanation or communication. There was no note saying, (1) “Hey, I ran out of time loading all this stuff into the garage, but will have the rest out for you tomorrow.” or (2) “Hey, sorry it’s not all here, but I needed some help to move the heavy Sound Booth.” or (3) “Hey, I smashed your guitars and sold your studio monitors.” There was just nothing but the stuff she was in the mood to give me on that particular day. No matter how many lawyer letters had crisscrossed the internet—NO ONE could make Veeby DO anything she didn’t want to do. CONTROL! I alerted Carol, and then we shared expletives regarding how Veeby’s actions made us feel. I was trying to play by the rules handed down within the Court’s Order. After all the frustration, I’d considered just walking into the house and taking my stuff—which would have been fair, but would probably have landed me in jail—and possibly have the Restraining Order become permanent. How was it that Veeby did not have to play by the same rules and seemingly had no consequences for her contemptuous actions? Carol and I decided it was time to move the grand piano out of the marital house, so I began making the arrangements. The next day, I took all my classical music books and teaching assets from the marital house—and the lawyer’s exchanged even more mud slinging letters. Lawyer #2 barked through her written correspondence and vehemently defended her client. It was sad to watch #2 spew such vile letters, knowing Veeby had placed blinders on her attorney and was enjoying pulling her strings. Talk about needlessly p r o l o n g i n g t h e p r o c e s s. OMG! Veeby was obviously telling #2 one semantical version, “…[he] took all of his personal belonging from the garage yesterday…,” but not the full story. 
Veeby knew she had kept some of my belongings, but didn’t tell her lawyer. Veeby probably enjoyed the illusionary feeling of CONTROL in that situation. She probably enjoyed the thought of her actions costing me more money. She probably assumed I would be paying her legal fees at some point, so she wasn’t concerned with the money or the waste of our time. What she had said was “she wanted a divorce”—but what she was doing was pushing away its finality. I knew Veeby well—and I knew she was merely showing her true colors—which exposed her blackened heart. • • • • • From my point of view, the time for negotiations had drawn to a close. Through counsel, I had tried to navigate the legal system and negotiate civility with an uncivilized warrior. It was time for stealth mode. The lawyers were trying to move us towards the mediation table, but I knew Veeby wanted it ALL. She didn’t want to negotiate, but rather she wanted to be punitive and keep everything. I just wanted to be done and move on. I had been successful in finding another [larger] residence, so I made arrangements to have the rental piano returned and the grand piano moved to my new location. I also decided to leave all the furnishings at the marital house—to just walk away—with the exception of the furniture in the teaching space. I would only take the items I would have asked for during a mediation session, but knew she would never have “allowed” it—just because she seemingly enjoyed the fight. The piano company and a separate moving company were scheduled to be at the marital house at the same time. Between them, they would take my grand piano and the teaching studio furniture over my new place. Since Veeby would not use the 60-inch big screen TV I’d left for her and the kids…I decided to take that, too. My primary worry was that Veeby would continue to play games—and not place those heavy panels from my Sound Booth into the garage. It would be so much easier if the moving company could grab everything in the same trip. Less screaming to hear on the other side of this special “black operations” mission. Carol alerted Veeby’s lawyer about my moving the pianos, confirmed the date, and restated we needed the Sound Booth, also. The Sound Booth became Veeby’s weapon of choice. A tool I used in my recording studio, a tool she held hostage, a tool she wielded against me. Within her reply, Lawyer #2 never admitted she had been mistaken, but finally stated “…my Client will have the Sound Booth available for his removal as well.” That drove me crazy! One day #2 screams “he got all his stuff already” and the next day simply state, “oh yeah, he can get that other thing he’s been asking for all this time.” I did not feel that I had been unreasonable by simply asking for what I needed—i.e., give me back my stuff! • • • • • The stars aligned on the appointed day—both the piano and furniture movers arrived as precisely planned [check]—no Veeby around [check]—and, the Sound Booth had miraculously appeared in the garage [double check]. The move began—quickly and surgically. I took the leather couch from the teaching space, one of the two “marital” couches. I left her the larger orange sectional in the Family Room—it was in her favorite color and was the couch I never wanted nor liked, but she’d chosen it and it worked for her. I left both dining tables—one was a glass top which sat on a beautiful walnut pedestal. The other was a long wooden family table in the kitchen we used most of the time. I took the big screen TV—and I knew exactly how she would spin that—“Greedy John took the big TV and left us with a little TV set”—and, she didn’t disappoint. She wouldn’t use the big screen TV, but she also didn’t want me to have it. That’s reasonable, right? Both Mark and a friend of mine were there during the move, to serve as witnesses if accusations were later hurled. Everything was loaded and then driven over to the new residence and unloaded. Nothing harmed, nothing fouled…a successful semi-covert venture! Knowing that Veeby would later return to “her” house and observe the empty teaching space, sent shivers down my spine. That scene from the movie, The Exorcist—where the possessed girl’s head slowly spun completely around—haunted my thoughts for the rest of that evening. • • • • • The moving mission was successful and of course Lawyer #2 expressed her displeasure with my taking the other teaching studio items. What was I supposed to do? Veeby and her Lawyer #2 kept playing games. Veeby would play the game and inept Lawyer #2 would write a vile letter which simply regurgitated whatever Veeby fed her—amply filled with semantical half truths. It was maddening. Of course, she had security camera footage—and I purposefully did not cover up the security cameras on the day things were moved out. I wanted it documented that I did not damage any of her other furniture. Without stating directly, Lawyer #2’s letter alluded to my basically “stealing” the furniture, claiming they hadn’t “authorized” whatever. It can’t be stealing if it was my furniture. It could even be considered our furniture. The fact that I left 90% of the household furniture for Veeby and the children has to be factored in. Then, there was the big screen TV—which I originally left for them, for some reason she removed it—then she wouldn’t hook it up for the family to use once she was Court Ordered to return it. So yeah, if she wasn’t going to use it, I took it and would use it. • • • • • Veeby masterfully pulled the strings of her legal puppet, who gullibly absorbed Veeby’s “spin” and then wrote little knife jabbing sentences like, “My client believes that John will only act like an adult if there are consequences he needs to face.” What on earth? Our former dance steps simply rewritten on paper. If I wasn’t doing whatever in the way Veeby thought I “should” [god, I hate the word “should”], then I was “wrong” and needed to “grow up”—or “be taught a lesson”—presumably by the more “adult” acting [i.e., mature?] Veeby. That little sentiment…would seemingly become her war cry going forward as Veeby sought to enlighten me as to how to act more like an adult. Evidently, to be an adult meant being mean, nasty and punitive in actions and how I represented myself within the world. [No, thank you.] Veeby never returned several items—they just disappeared into the ether. Electric guitar, bass guitar, pair of black monitors, various remote controls were simply GONE…poof! I tried to “use my words” and “ask for what I needed”…good tricks all those therapy sessions through the years had taught me to do: Veeby, May I get the drawing of [a bridge] done by [artist] from the half bath? She gave that to me when I left that area. I would like to have it, please. And… Veeby, Please look for the black studio monitors. I last saw them stacked in the master bedroom closet. Also, may I retrieve the remote control for the big screen TV? It was also in the master bedroom closet, on top of the black studio monitors. Veeby replied: I think you have taken enough things from this house. I guess you have no shame given you are still wanting more. Yeah...I’ll keep looking. Veeby really didn’t have to look very far. The remote control and pair of black monitors were in her closet. Veeby never returned the TV remote—I had to buy another one. She never returned the black studio monitors—I had to buy another pair. She never returned the special picture. She never returned either guitar. Her decision to withhold items seemed immature and petty to me.

39 Moved into a House

I was fortunate. When the Judge encouraged me at the Restraining Order Hearing to find a larger place to move to, I didn’t have to go on a massive realty search. One of my students became aware of the details of my current situation—knew I needed to move to a bigger place with room for the kids and the ability to teach from that location. A close family friend of theirs was looking to rent his place, and it just happened to be in my town and close to the children’s schools. All the pieces fell into place. The house just happened to be in a very exclusive section of our town—where the doctors and lawyers lived. Consideration for my financial situation was taken into account—plus a “friend of a friend” discount was applied—and a rental deal was struck. The piano was moved in, the big screen TV was moved in, the Sound Booth and the rest of the teaching space furniture from the marital home were all delivered to the new house. I brought over my stuff from the condo a little at a time. I was hoping to provide more stability for my children and my piano students at my new location. The three bedroom house allowed both remaining kids to have their own bedroom. The grand piano was placed in front of a large glass wall in the living room—with a gorgeous view behind which created a warm and friendly teaching space once more. I was not only fortunate, but I was very thankful.

40 Who Does This Benefit?

Another beautiful day, traveling down Divorce Lane towards mediation, when out of the corner of my eye I saw another accusatory email from Lawyer #2—just right before it hit me from behind like a bumper car at a carnival. Her email contained misinformation regarding some Life Insurance policy and further claims that I’d changed the beneficiaries! Wait…WHAT? Who kept filling the lawyer’s head with all this stuff? [Oh…yeah]—I wrote Carol to disprove the allegation: Carol—Per our conversation yesterday—that #2 is claiming I’ve changed my Life Insurance Beneficiary—again, this is NOT true. I have not changed my Will nor Life Insurance policy, and am absolutely amazed that Veeby would make such a claim to her lawyer. I’m attaching screen shots from my life insurance company’s website showing TODAY’s date at the bottom—clearly indicating Veeby is still the beneficiary of my life insurance policy, no address info has been changed, and the monthly amount I’m having deducted from my bank account remains the same. Again, all absolutely ridiculous. I eventually discovered that the policy in question was not my life insurance policy, but the Death and Dismemberment policy we had in place since our post-graduate years. Premiums were only paid quarterly, so that’s why it wasn’t on my radar. I let Carol know: Carol—The policy in question—that Veeby “was unaware of until the letter came in the mail…” has been Effective since 1983 [24 years] through Trust Insurance. It is not a life insurance policy, but a “Death and Dismemberment” policy for me and the entire family. I am the Insured, not Veeby. This manilla folder has lived in our file cabinets since 1983 and we have paid the premiums through our joint account since that time as well. According to Trust Insurance, an invoice requesting payment was sent to me at the old PO Box, which Veeby now controls. Instead of forwarding me the invoice [which was addressed to me] for payment, she called Trust Insurance directly to find out information about this policy. Trust Insurance has confirmed to me that they would not discuss this policy at all with anyone else except either her or myself. I have not contacted Trust Insurance recently and my phone records will bear this out. Lawyer #2’s wording in her letter implies that Veeby was not aware of the policy until the Change of Beneficiary form arrived—implying that I’m trying to change my beneficiary on this policy. Lawyer #2’s words are misleading and inaccurate. Veeby received the invoice, then SHE called them to request a copy of the policy and the change of beneficiary form. This is documented within Trust Insurance’s phone records and was read to me from the notes of that conversation. Veeby may not have remembered or been aware of the policy until the invoice came, but it’s not correct to infer she didn’t know about it until the Change of Beneficiary form arrived. It’s inaccurate and misleading to word it that way. The policy has now lapsed [since I was not given the invoice], but I have made arrangements to pay it today and keep it in effect. Currently, there is NO BENEFICIARY listed on this policy. If something happened to me, any payments would automatically still go to Veeby. Additionally, if she were to try to make a change or create an actual Beneficiary, I would have to sign the form to make it active. I have not filed any forms, changed or created any Beneficiary to this policy. Lawyer #2 usually wrote her questions as statements using accusatory overtones. Why not phrase it, “We have some questions about a change of beneficiary on a certain policy?” The whole style of Lawyer #2 seemed to be: Use inflammatory wording to make wild accusations, and then figure out the facts and details—if needed. In the end, no Beneficiary had been changed…at all. The only person changing their Will and changing their Life Insurance beneficiary was Veeby. The rest of the allegations were just more accusations to muddy the legal waters. S M O K E & M I R R O R S

41 I Got to Be Dad Again

I had been able to spend time with the kids—at least Mark—the weekend after the Hearing. During the following weeks, my ability to hang out with the children was thwarted as often as possible by Veeby. It was a very happy Wednesday when I received an email from Kelley that the Judge had finally signed some “time-sharing” form: We received the Order today for the time-sharing. When do you want to start your time-sharing? Like immediately, please. The “time-sharing” form really turned out to be an AGREED ORDER ON TEMPORARY PARENTING PLAN which outlined “who” got the children on which days of the week and how to split some upcoming holidays and the children’s birthdays. It further gave Veeby “exclusive use and possession of the Marital Home” except when I was entitled to teach there on Mondays and Tuesdays. The AGREED ORDER further outlined how the kids would be with dad on Mondays and Tuesdays, then they would be with mom on Wednesdays and Thursdays, and the weekends were to be alternated. This was the court approved model that allowed for there to be 50/50 time-sharing with the children. Thus, we began a new court mandated routine began in our lives. Carol let Veeby’s camp know that I would begin my time-sharing that upcoming weekend, since I’d had no time with the kids for awhile. • • • • • Our children had endured their own turmoils up to that point—with Mom and Dad separating and then all the craziness that followed. While I was hopeful to renew a better relationship with Noelle, I was realistically doubtful she would come over to my new place. I needed to ponder that situation a little more to know how to respond. Mark also expressed concern about beginning the new time-sharing schedule. He didn’t want to spend that first weekend with me—it was a change for all of us, for sure. Also, how exactly would I be able to pick up their clothes and stuff at the marital house since I had that darn Restraining Order still in place? The kids would need enough stuff to get them through the upcoming weekend and into the following Wednesday school. I was hoping for a little grace as the new living situation was figured out. I never realized just how much I had come to accept and enjoy the role of “Dad”—until it was taken away from me through a Restraining Order—and that really hurt. On Friday, I got to pick up Mark a little early from school, like it was no big deal. I took the newly signed Temporary Parenting Plan to the school office and let them make a copy to keep for their records. He and I then drove over to the new house I was renting. As we entered the security guarded front gate, he said, “We’re going to live here?” He knew it was a very exclusive neighborhood. Since I hadn’t moved in yet, I showed him the outside of the house. We walked around and looked in the windows…hoping to actually “get in” the very next day. Then, we leaned against the car for awhile and I told him this would be where we’d live for a couple of years. I told him it was not supposed to be a punishment to “spend time with Dad.” I explained the recently revealed time-sharing schedule and that it would become our new “normal.” NO, it was NOT the way mom and dad had originally told he and his sisters how it was going to be. All of the Plan A routine we’d explained—had changed. Veeby called Mark while we were driving around the new neighborhood. She gave us “permission” to go to “her house” to get his things—[thank you, Queen]. On the drive over, I reminded him to get enough clothes and things to last until he went to school the following Wednesday. He said mom had told him he would only be staying over the weekend. I showed him what the AGREED ORDER indicated regarding the new schedule, and how that would become our new schedule going forward. Again, Mark asked about the two days here, two day there schedule—and WHY was it that way? I told him that’s the way it was told to me by the Judge. He needed a new frame to understand the recent changes in his life. I told him his childhood story would simply become, “My mom and dad divorced when I was 11,” but that didn’t mean his life was going to be ruined at all. We all just had a new schedule, and we’d survive together. In truth, he and I had an opportunity to create a new relationship between us. We would make lemonade out of life’s lemons. I believe he heard me and understood. • • • • • I was being told by the courts how my life would look going forward, as well. I went from being around my children all the time to being told I got to “have them” on a weird rotation, that it was fair, and I should be happy about it. Evidently, this time-sharing plan was the new and improved model. The Judge had informed us that the children used to be assigned to one parent as their Primary caregiver and the other parent [usually the father] would only get to see the kids every other weekend…WOW! The time-sharing schedule I was handed already tore me up inside. I didn’t know how I would have dealt with the older model of only seeing my children every other weekend. When we arrived at the marital house, Mark went inside for over 15 minutes to collect his things. Noelle finally came out with him, carrying her brother’s computer monitor and Mark had placed his other stuff in a rolling backpack. I told Noelle, “Hello” and that I would come back the next day to pick her up. Mark was cute—before leaving he asked, “Should I bring my swimming suit?” I said, “Sure…that way we’ll have options.” We left Veeby’s place and headed to the grocery store. It was just normal routine stuff, but very important for he and I to establish our new normal. He mentioned he wanted to get back to the condo [our last night there] and get his computer all hooked up before he was scheduled to meet some friends online to play a game. Later, we walked across the street to the local cinema and watched a movie, then came back home to cook a frozen pizza and some cookies. Unfortunately, the internet service was not working at the condo that evening, so he was bummed, and started getting tired. He decided he didn’t want any pizza after all, and we even nixed the cookies. Mark said he was tired and went to bed early—on a Friday evening! Being Dad, I knew Mark was a little overwhelmed with all the changes. Hearing one thing from me and probably hearing something different from mom—must have been confusing. Through counsel, I had been trying to arrange for some therapy for both kids, but Veeby and Lawyer #2 were not being helpful…they preferred throwing down obstacles.

42 Oh No You Don't!

I was concerned for Noelle and Mark—and the emotional trauma the separation, turned divorce, then Restraining Order events had caused—and how the kids were understanding and processing it all. I hadn’t been around them much—too many obstacles had been thrown in front of me to slow me down, courtesy of Veeby. I wanted to arrange some therapy for them, so they could process everything in an age appropriate way. Carol wrote a letter for me and at first, Veeby sounded agreeable, provided I pay for everything, of course. I lined up a therapist to see the kids. I could take Mark and made an initial appointment. I believed it would be best for Noelle if her mom took her—they could arrange a time that worked for them. I forwarded the therapist information over to Veeby through counsel. My insurance would pay for at least eight visits per person, so excellent! I made some therapist inquiries and lined up a session…only to immediate receive the first “Oh No You Don’t” letter from Veeby’s camp. Evidently, I hadn’t done something the “right” way. In my experience, Veeby was often not attentive to the details—the following being just one example. I made Mark’s initial appointment on a Monday at noon. Since I only “had” Mark on Mondays and Tuesdays per the new Temporary Parenting Plan—and I began teaching immediately after school on those days—I was trying to take care of Mark and make it work given his school schedule and my work schedule. Mark would have been taken out of school during his lunch, seen the therapist between 12-1 pm, then back to school by 1:15 pm approximately. His math class only began at 1:34 pm. I was trying to make lemonade with the time frame I had been given. I reached out to the school counselor to confirm, then let Carol know: Carol—I spoke with the 6th grade guidance counselor at Mark’s school this morning. He gave me more information regarding the “Rotator Schedule” used by the school. They use a schedule which daily “drops” one class period, which alternates. This coming Monday, will be a “drop 6” date, so he will miss his history class. His math class will be at the normal time. However, the normal time for classes is different than the Bell Schedule provided to us by Lawyer #2. Plus, his math class is not until later in the day. He will not miss it by keeping the noon therapist appointment. Mark has his math class during 5th period which begins at 1:34 pm. The therapist appointment is at 12 pm. He will be brought back to school after his therapist session to attend the rest of his school day and classes per normal. Given that I only have Mark available to me on Mondays and Tuesdays, he gets out of school at 3:30, and I begin my teaching AT 3:00 pm, there is no way for me to get him to any other appointment times on the days I have him. This therapist does not have Friday or weekend hours. The appointment for Mark’s initial therapy session will remain as scheduled...this coming Monday at noon. P.S.–Veeby read the bell schedule wrong. On the faxed over Bell Schedules that #2 sent, it lists correctly the regular schedule on the left of the page. IF a school day needed to have ALL seven periods happen on a given day, they would use the middle “All Periods Schedule” which Veeby has incorrectly starred. THAT schedule would have his math class beginning at 1 pm, but this is incorrect for a regular school day. Mark’s regular math class time is fifth period...held at 1:34 pm. I went ahead and called the therapist to see if he had any other options. He was willing to alter his schedule and meet Mark at 9:30 on Monday morning instead. That was great! That would allow him to go to school per normal, steer clear of his math class and I would just pick him up for the earlier appointment time. I went ahead and changed the appointment to 9:30 am. No harm, no foul…math class conflict avoided…whew! Oh No You Don’t!—again? Yep, Veeby wrote Lawyer #2: Subject: Mark missing school to attend therapy Mark’s school counselor called me today to let me know that John called him today to argue that he needs to take Mark out of school on Monday at noon to a therapist appointment. The school counselor informed me that he advised John against this because standardized testing preparation is starting and Mark needs to be in all his classes. As I explained to you, Mark has all advanced classes and is not doing as well as he has in the past. As I told you, I have no problem with Mark or Noelle going to therapy, just as long as they do not have to miss school. It serves Mark nothing to miss school at a critical time of the academic year; this is certainly not in HIS best interest. John needs to find a therapist that will accommodate the children’s schedules with late afternoon, evening or weekend hours. The therapist may be a great therapist but he certainly is not the only therapist available to work with Mark or Noelle. As a parent who is looking out for the interests of the children, this concerns me greatly that John would insist that this appointment time will remain when clearly it is not in Mark’s best interest as I and the counselor at the school have stressed. I do not believe John’s schedule needs to be considered in scheduling the appointment for Mark, but Mark’s best interests need to be served. The school counselor has already informed John that Mark should not miss ANY of his classes at this time, no matter what rotator schedule of classes he misses. Since his lunch is from 11:00–11:30 am, he will be missing more than one class going to an appointment at noon. The fact that John is not considering what is best for Mark, goes to my point that John acts unilaterally in serving only his interests. I believe it is imperative to bring this before the Judge and request a hearing to address how John’s behaviors are in detriment to our children. The fact that we are having to incur added time and money to defend the children when obviously what needs to be done is a simple change to a therapist that can accommodate their needs, should be costs that John should pay. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I couldn’t win for trying. My intention of simply trying to care for our kids through therapy was reframed as “making unilateral decisions that are detrimental.” Of course my schedule had to be considered—I only got to care for Mark on Mondays and Tuesdays—it wasn’t my being thoughtless or self-centered. This was about Veeby’s need for CONTROL. This was about throwing down obstacles. This was about playing the Game of Divorce, but at the expense of our kids. S M O K E & M I R R O R S When I spoke with the school counselor, he mentioned the preparations for standardized testing. I explained to him that our family was in crisis and that Mark had always done well on those type tests [he and his brothers were all in the Gifted programs, says the proud dad]. I reassured him that I would take Mark out for the therapy appointment and then bring him back to school. What concerned me more was that [supposedly] the school counselor had called Veeby to “alert” her? Further, why did we have to get Veeby’s “permission” or “approval” to get some much needed therapy for our son? At the advice of counsel—because of all the commotion the thread created—I canceled the appointment with that therapist. I considered it backing down, which I had always done, since Veeby screamed louder than me. I considered her screaming behavior very rude—which prevented me from screaming back. Lawyer #2 sent Carol an additional “nasty gram” that we needed to get a different appointment time that wasn’t during school hours. It appeared Veeby had hired a megaphone to scream for her. The point, of course, was HOW DARE I try to get therapy for the children—without getting her permission! She was their “mother” and was the only person able to care for them properly. What was I thinking? • • • • • Eventually, I found a different therapist for the kids—one who had weekend appointments. I wrote Veeby to ask for her blessing: Veeby, Please check out the practice of [therapist], to see if they meet with your approval. They offer Friday and Saturday appointments. How would it work best in your schedule to take the children to sessions? I am willing to take both kids as needed. A whole month went by with no reply from Veeby. I was frustrated by her lack of communication…so, I wrote her again: Veeby, Having written you previously…and without having received any reply or communication, I have set up an appointment for Mark. Since Noelle is withholding communication, it is probably best if you would set up appointments for her. Therapist contact info below. • • • • • Eventually, I just booked a therapist appointment for Mark. After several weeks, I was disappointed to learn that Veeby had not provided the therapy option for Noelle. I asked Carol to reach out to Lawyer #2 to get that ball rolling. Lawyer #2 replied that her client could not afford the $70 for the therapist that I lined up. Surprisingly, Veeby followed up with a text message: John, The therapist you chose wants $70 a session. Unless you want to pay for it, I am taking Noelle to a less expensive therapist. I chuckled when I received that text…Veeby charged her financial clients much more than that for her expertise! I responded that I didn’t think that was the correct amount—I would check on it and get back to her. I called the therapist’s office and spoke to the receptionist, Renee. She said she was still reeling from her conversation with Veeby—claiming, “Veeby just wasn’t listening to me.” It was sadly humorous to hear how upset she was having just spoken with Veeby. I calmed her down, told Renee I would pay the co-payments for Noelle’s therapy. It was only $70 for the initial visit and then the cost reduced for additional visits. I texted Veeby: Veeby, Please call Renee back at the therapist’s office to arrange an appointment time for Noelle. I will take care of the co-payments. Veeby never replied back. She eventually took Noelle to one therapy session—which ended up costing her nothing—and she never took Noelle again.

43 Swerve

I wouldn’t have ever believed it possible—until it happened to me. No one would ever believe me—because it sounded too strange. Then, however, it happened again—and I felt validated. Swerve 1 The behaviors of my soon to be Ex-wife were becoming more “interesting” with each passing day. After the Restraining Order Hearing—while Veeby was still acting “in fear for her life”—we had a chance run in. Well, almost a run in. It was on one of those days that the Judge had “awarded” me access to the marital house to teach my students. Veeby was late in vacating the premises, for whatever reason. As I drove up our street toward the house, I saw her car back out of the driveway and then accelerate towards me. She suddenly swerved into my lane—as if playing “chicken”—and then went right back over into her side of the street as she passed me. It was freaky. I told Carol. We had a discussion regarding the viability of a psychological evaluation request. She then wrote a letter to Lawyer #2 to address Veeby’s outrageous behavior. Swerve 2 Oops, she did it again. Perry and Phil—two of our neighbors—were talking outside on Phil’s lawn. Perry was walking his dog, had stopped for a chat with Phil and were standing next to the curb. Evidently, Veeby zoomed out of her driveway, gunned the car and drove very close to them on the left side of the street. Seemingly to scare them? She succeeded. Phil asked why she was in such a hurry? Perry tried to smooth over the event for the older neighbor by suggesting Veeby was just trying to scare his dog. Apparently, there was no better way to continue good relations with the neighbors than to swerve her car towards them—and then race angrily away. Completely understandable behavior, really. The mere possibility of the neighbors testifying at a Psychological Evaluation seemed like a perfectly good reason to run them over.

44 Taxes 2007

Our oldest daughter, Eliana, was in college and we needed to complete the Financial Aid forms online for her…to begin the whole financial aid process for the coming school year. A completed tax return was required, so by the beginning of the new year, Veeby and I had each already gathered our financial documents. However, Veeby would not provide her information so I could complete our tax return. Instead, she was advised and decided to file a separate return. She began creating her tax return in mid-January, unbeknownst to me. She simply wouldn’t communicate or share information in this area. I went ahead and filled in all the financial information I could on our joint tax return. I would be ready to simply input her amounts when she gave them to me. When I took her computer for leverage, there were two yellow “post-it” notes attached to the monitor—on which she had written her actual income for the previous year. THOSE came home with me!10 days later, Veeby wrote her Lawyer #1 and claimed she made 1/3 the amount she’d written on the yellow post-it notes. She eventually filed her Financial Affidavit with the court claiming the same 1/3 amount as her income. Veeby hired a family friend and CPA advisor to complete and file her taxes. [I think it would have been a wiser decision for the old owl to decline getting involved at all.] However, he filed her return claiming “head of household,” took all three children as deductions, took the entire [my] home office deduction and wrote off all the mortgage interest [that I paid]. There was no equitable division of deductions. Veeby had him file the tax return without informing me or my counsel—even though we had been asking for information through a mountain of letters. With the eerie feeling that she was about to file, I contacted the CPA friend. He confirmed Veeby had hired him and he’d already filed her return. Then, he said he was prohibited from giving out any further information. He recommended I file a return, claim whatever deductions I thought I could, and simply wait for the IRS to reject my return. That process would then inform me which deductions Veeby had taken on her return, and I could then refile. Great. Since I had pretty much already prepared “our” return, I changed the “joint” return to a “head of household” return, claimed all our normal deductions and electronically filed the return that evening. • • • • • The kicker? My return was accepted by the IRS and Veeby’s was rejected. Apparently, the CPA friend snail mailed a copy. I don’t know. Boy, I didn’t see that coming! I received a huge and unplanned refund—which went straight towards my legal fees. I’m pretty sure Veeby didn’t receive any refund that year. I truly hope she didn’t have to pay. I had a feeling that it would eventually be spun that I had “done” this terrible thing with the taxes—had purposefully set out to hurt Veeby. Nothing could be further from the truth. I tried to communicate, but Veeby would have none of it. The day Veeby found out her tax return had been rejected—I felt the sweetest positive energy being sent my way from the marital house.

45 Mediation Madness

At the beginning of our divorce journey, I was unaware that a divorcing couple typically went through something called “mediation” before a Judge would officially pronounce them divorced. There were issues that our state required to be worked out between “the parties”—like Child Support, Alimony, Parenting Plan, etc.—before a divorce could be finalized. The goal of negotiations was to arrive at a “Mediated Settlement Agreement,” also known as “MSA.” While Veeby and I had done our best on our own—arriving at Plan A—we quickly realized only the professional Game of Divorce players knew the official rules…the lawyers. She and I simply didn’t know what all we didn’t know. A date for mediation was set up with some different lawyer, who would “mediate” the event. In the preceding weeks, Carol and Lawyer #2 exchanged emails and information in preparation. Everything needed to be fairly and equitably divided between the parties. Since Veeby was still “in character”—i.e., still in fear for her life—she and Lawyer #2 were kept in a separate room away from Carol and myself—and the mediator ran back and forth. We began the negotiation process with a template and tweaked it as needed. After six (6) hours of negotiations, another two (2) hours to print, tweak and reprint the final version, Veeby and I placed our initials on each and every page, it was notarized and we had our MEDIATED SETTLE-MENT AGREEMENT. Voilà! Some of the topics our MSA discussed with microscopic detail were: Shared Parental Responsibility; Parenting Plan; Entitlement to Information, Participation, Love and Affection of Minor Children; Time Sharing; Therapy for the Children; Equitable Distribution of Assets and Liabilities; Impairment of Credit; Alimony; Child Support; Non-Covered Medical Expenses; Extra-Curricular Activities; Life Insurance; Health Insurance; Income Tax Exemptions for Children; Attorney’s Fees, etc. ad nauseam. • • • • • I offer a few additional clarifications and observations: Within the section called THERAPY FOR THE CHILDREN, Veeby and Lawyer #2 specifically put in the last sentence, “Therapy sessions shall not be scheduled during a time when the children are in school.” This was due to my previous attempts to get Mark some therapy. By omission, the children could see medical doctors or have lab work done during school hours, which Veeby did…but NO THERAPY! The EQUITABLE DISTRIBUTION OF ASSETS section expressed the intent of an equitable division of assets, but let it be clearly understood—there was NO division of assets. Because of the Restraining Order situation, a rational conversation between Veeby and myself was not possible. We never divided up our stuff. Veeby simply threw away anything of mine she didn’t want. I initially moved out under an “amicable” Plan A agreement, but then everything went sideways. I needed to sign off on the MSA in order to simply move on, but it was definitely a compromise on my part. There was a quaint little section called AGREEMENT MADE IN RELIANCE ON PARTIES’ DISCLOSURE in which we acknowledged that all the MSA’s financial provisions relied upon the accuracy and truthfulness of the other party’s disclosure of their respective financial condition. I was extremely aware that there was no accuracy or truthfulness in Veeby’s disclosure of her financial condition. Her financial disclosures were verifiably untrue. However, I needed to move on—so I signed the dumb MSA. Lastly, we verified that we freely and voluntarily entered into the agreement, it was a full settlement and contained our entire agreement. Sure—keep reading—we’ll see how that all ended up in a little bit. Most importantly, Veeby really, really, really, really wanted the marital house [four of a kind!]—but she really, really, really, really didn’t have enough income to pay the mortgage. I had always paid the mortgage on our behalf. I believed she was under a delusion that somehow I would continue to pay for the house. That was due in part to original 55/45 split under Plan A. However, I believed she was not connecting all the new little dotted i’s and crossed t’s. Her earlier “playing the system” to her advantage had turned into the Game of Divorce due to Veeby’s Divorce and Restraining Order moves. No longer would I be able to skimp by in a small condo and substantially help her and the children stay in the marital house. Within the new paradigm, I believed it would have been financially better for her to sell the marital house—thus, reducing her expenses—and then move into a smaller place. I tried to tell her, but she was no longer listening to anything I had to say. By acquiring the marital house, she also took over the 2nd mortgage payments—our Home Equity Line of Credit [HELOC]. I didn’t think she would have enough money to go around for all her bills, but I also remembered her previous text: “You don’t need to worry about my bills.”—so, I let it go. Something called a QDRO [Qwa-dro] was mentioned—a Qualified Domestic Relations Order—and was included in the MSA, to deal with my measly retirement funds. The ALIMONY section had already been addressed within our original Plan A agreement. While she would have liked to have received one million dollars every month as Alimony, it wasn’t gonna happen. You can’t get water from a stone. However, I did pay more than was required in Child Support. I was trying to help her out monthly and be a nice guy—true. [A lot of good that did.] Within the CHILD SUPPORT section, the state provided standardized charts to follow based on the couple’s financial information. I didn’t want Veeby to be hurting financially and would do what I could to help out towards that goal. At the same time, Veeby wasn’t playing fairly. Veeby had changed her income amounts hoping to show a wider disparity between our incomes—to show more “need” for me to supplement her with monthly Child Support. However, the mediator saw through Veeby’s ploy and imputed income to her during the mediation process. If Veeby were playing fairly—i.e., using her actual income values—my Child Support amount would have been negligible. Again, trying to be helpful at the time, I accepted a Child Support amount that was much more than what the state chart listed I should pay monthly [when using her actual income]. As an additional help to my former partner, I agreed to no reduction in that amount once Noelle left home and only Mark remained—and until Mark graduated from high school. If I only knew then how things were about to unfold, I would not have made that gracious financial decision in her favor. • • • • • The very next day after mediation was Noelle’s birthday. Within the following email exchange, I received a little ray of hope in what had been an otherwise bleak winter: Veeby—I would like very much to see our daughter, Noelle, tomorrow for her birthday—just for a few moments, even though the extension of the Restraining Order is in place until this coming Sunday. Would you please allow me to come see her at your home [briefly] on my way to work...after 6 pm? She replied: John, Mark and I will be making a cake for Noelle tomorrow afternoon. I have spoken to Noelle that you will swing by to see her around 6 pm. Perhaps the snow was melting? Perhaps we would be able to Spring forward and develop a healthy working relationship—for the children?

[Little girl trying to look innocent after getting caught stealing cookies from the cookie jar.]

46 That's Not My Handwriting

The silliest thing happened during our mediation. In an attempt to better her position and hopefully get more money, Veeby had decided to under-report her income. This was verifiably true and she knew it at the time. Carol and I clearly alerted Lawyer #2 as to Veeby’s actions, and suggested they correct Veeby’s official Financial Affidavit filed with the court. But like an ostrich that sticks its head in the sand and hopes no one sees, they chose to not listen to our helpful suggestion. This point came up during mediation, and I’m pretty sure I placed the subject on the table for discussion. Yet, Veeby would not admit she’d altered her income. I then produced a printed detailed report of Veeby’s income for the past three (3) years and gave it to the mediator. Of course, Veeby suggested I had manufactured the report—made it all up. The report showed in precise detail the payments from various companies, direct payments from clients, whether she’d received a check or cash from the client, etc. Veeby denied that she received any direct payments from clients, claiming she only received money from the various companies. Well, that was a red flag for the mediator—who was familiar with that industry and knew that Financial Analysts usually accepted direct payments from clients—that was how that industry worked. Veeby’s credibility with the mediator was shrinking. Veeby’s tried to wiggle out of the situation, but seemed to only tighten the noose. Then, I produced those two yellow “post-it” notes—on which Veeby had written her actual income from the previous year. After showing the two yellow “post-it” notes to the party in the other room, the mediator came back and relayed that Veeby had said, “That’s not my handwriting.” I couldn’t believe it. I laughed out loud. I was dumbfounded. Of course it was her handwriting. However, we instantly became detectives, one and all. Carol, the mediator and myself pouring over a multitude of Veeby’s handwritten cards and letters I’d brought with me—[Hey, I had good foresight]—comparing the handwriting to the little yellow notes. We compared against Veeby’s handwritten Restraining Order statement. We compared against Veeby’s handwritten Financial Affidavit Worksheet. The mediator actually had Veeby write something on a piece of paper right then, so we could compare. Of course, they were all the same. The mediator was smart—she knew what was going on. In a situation like that, income gets added or “imputed” to the party, which is what the mediator did with Veeby. Even so, after mediation I researched handwriting experts—in case we needed to disprove her denial claims in the future. However, my knowing Veeby for so long, I could just as easily “testify” as to her handwriting, if needed. To end that mediation session, Veeby and I had to initial each page of the Mediated Settlement Agreement. How funny to then see her initials—on every page—that matched the writing on the yellow “post-it” notes. It seemed that slinging mud could cover up the truth. However, after cleaning the mud away, the truth was still there—shining just a little brighter from the cleaning process.

47 Immediate Bump in the Road

Immediately after mediation, everything was great and driving down the freshly paved divorce road went quite smoothly—for exactly four (4) days. Then I received an email from Veeby that would foreshadow all interactions going forward: John, As per you and your lawyer’s time-sharing, Mark will be home with me this Monday overnight since it is a school holiday and falls on my weekend. Wait…WHAT? I quickly came to understand that no specific Parenting Plan had been created. We’d simply incorporated the Temporary Parenting Plan as our time-sharing schedule within the MSA, which stated: “…time-sharing of the minor children shall be as follows: John shall have the children on Mondays and Tuesday overnight and bring the children to school on Wednesday mornings. Veeby shall have the children Wednesdays and Thursdays overnight and bring the children to school on Friday mornings. The parties shall alternate weekends from Friday after school until Monday morning return to school. If there is no school on a Monday or Friday, that day attaches to the weekend time-sharing for the parent having that weekend.” This was the very first bump in the road and needed to be clarified as it would become precedent setting. Veeby seemed to consider the upcoming Monday as if it were a “school holiday.” Monday wasn’t a holiday like Labor Day or Memorial Day. Monday was simply the beginning of Spring Break and our Parenting Plan did not designate time-sharing during all the various holidays and school breaks. Our MSA simply stated Veeby and I would “alternate all major holidays amicably and reasonably.” WHAT? [I really should have read all that fine print.] Accepting the MSA with vague language and non-specific division of holiday and vacation time-sharing, would become a nightmare to clarify. From my perspective, I no longer believed that the words “amicable” and “reasonable”—or “logical” and “rational”—could ever be used in a sentence pertaining to Veeby. The Parenting Plan that the Judge signed after the Restraining Order Hearing was always meant to be a temporary document—that’s why it wasn’t too specific. To have attached it as our permanent Parenting Plan was simply an oversight by both parties. At mediation, we were more focused on Veeby’s under-reported income and the ramifications of that regarding Child Support. I would later learn that we should have created a very specific Parenting Plan—one that would have addressed every special date and included very specific pick up and drop off times for the children. I didn’t know what I didn’t know. I hadn’t lived through divorce before. The pressing issue at that moment boiled down to semantics again—rather than intent. I interpreted “if there is no school on a Monday or Friday” as intended for an observed holiday on a Monday. Veeby interpreted “no school” as no school. However, that wasn’t as simple as it would appear. Reasonably, “…no school on a Monday…” was not intended to apply to Spring Break or Winter Break or even Summer Break. There would be many “no school” days—on all Mondays during the summer. Would the same argument be made then? The temporary nature of that Parenting Plan wrecked such havoc. Seemingly, if Veeby had the kids on a Monday holiday or “no school” day, she then planned on “keeping them” the entire Monday, including overnight into Tuesday. That would mean I wouldn’t see them until after school on Tuesday—when I usually worked. Then they would hit the bed, wake up, go to school on Wednesday, then go BACK to her place for two more days before I would see them again—after school on Friday. I would definitely get the short end of that stick! Our children typically slept quite late [noon-ish] on non-school days. If Veeby were to play fairly, perhaps the kids could sleep late per normal on the Monday in question, then come over to my place around the time they would normally arrive home after school. That would allow us to split the day. Instead, Veeby wanted to keep them the entire day and include an overnight stay—as an extra day for her—which short changed me. • • • • • At face value, it would be logical that the opposite Friday scenario would balance it all out, but in actuality it would not. If there were ever a holiday or non-school day on a Friday—say, going into “my” weekend—the kids would already be over at mom’s on Thursday night. Instead of waking them up early on a Friday morning and dragging them over to my place, I would let them sleep late per normal. By the time they’d get up, eat breakfast and clean up to be picked up, it would be close to the normal after school pick up time. So, I wouldn’t “get them” for the extra full day on a Friday like Veeby would “get them” on a Monday non-school day. Petty? Walk in my shoes. That wasn’t a silly issue to me. Since the pressing issue was the very beginning of my understanding of exactly how the whole time-sharing concept worked, it was a huge deal. In that scenario, I wasn’t willing to only see the kids for six (6) hours—after school Tuesday until bedtime—during a nine (9) day time period. It seemed unfair…and needed to be further clarified. I emailed Veeby several times, but she would not reply. Seemingly, she had already made her “decree”…so why was I still talking? I proposed splitting that week of Spring Break…which was reasonable, amicable and flexible…but the suggestion was met with pure SILENCE. Only after enduring several more emails from her former partner, did she “grant” a singular reply email—which exposed her “bring it on” attitude: John, I would welcome a hearing in front of the Judge to “clarify” our differing interpretations of “holiday” or “no school” and what that means regarding time sharing agreement. Until then, Mark has no school on Monday and will attach to my weekend. Seemingly, she felt Large and In Charge. So, the lawyers got involved. Lawyer #2 was initially dismissive and wanted to leave the issue to be mediated after an Uncontested Final Hearing. However, it was “contested.” I needed the issue clarified as soon as possible, not months later in another costly mediation session. Carol intervened with Lawyer #2 and asked if their ridiculous interpretation would indeed include every Monday there was “no school” during the winter and spring and summer breaks? However, Veeby’s camp would simply not discuss the matter any further. So, I asked Carol to file a MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION AND FOR MORE DEFINITIVE PARENTING PLAN to clarify the measly Temporary Parenting Plan. It seemed the old adage “good fences makes good neighbors” might be especially true in our case. • • • • • We tried to remedy the issue out of court between parties—by sending Veeby our suggested clarified Parenting Plan. If only Veeby would read and discuss the darn thing, we could incorporate a better Parenting Plan and proceed to end the Game of Divorce. Of course, Lawyer #2 did not want to address my Parenting Plan concerns. She wanted to schedule a Final Hearing and be done. Carol told her we wouldn’t agree to a Final Hearing until the Parenting Plan issues had been addressed. Lawyer #2 filed their RESPONSE TO [John’s] MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION AND FOR MORE DEFINITIVE PARENTING PLAN claiming we should just try to work things out through mediation. Yeah, like that had worked out so well the last time. S M O K E & M I R R O R S I just couldn’t understand the resistance from Veeby’s camp to simply discuss a more detailed Parenting Plan. The Temporary Parenting Plan adopted within our MSA was so minimally worded and didn’t address most of the normal “who does what and when” that a regular Parenting Plan normally laid out. What was the harm in at least a discussion? While Carol represented our thoughts to Lawyer #2 to no avail, Lawyer #2 went ahead and stubbornly set a hearing date on their motion for an Uncontested Final Hearing. Then, in the world of Court, I won. We had a preliminary hearing before the Judge to explain my concerns regarding the minimally worded Parenting Plan and the need for further clarification. He agreed, but deferred the Final Hearing until Veeby and Lawyer #2 sat down with us again at the mediation table. Of course, Veeby’s camp could have simply talked to us and we could have come up with an Agreed Order. That’s what we’d been trying to accomplish. THIS CAUSE was considered by the Court on the following Motion(s): John’s Motion for Clarification and for More Definitive Parenting Plan THE COURT having considered the grounds for the Motion, taken testimony, heard argument and considered the applicable law, it is FOUND, ORDERED AND ADJUDGED as follows: DEFERRED. The parties are Ordered to go to mediation before setting down their Final Hearing. [Ordered to Mediation] DONE AND ORDERED…the Judge Mediation was arranged for two months later. Veeby was hoping to change her name at a Final Hearing the following Monday, but since she’d refused to discuss the issues with us…at all…she’d have to wait a couple more months. It seemed she would keep my last name a little while longer. I invited her to talk one more time: Veeby, I am still open to having a dialogue about clarifying the time-sharing issues. If you are willing to talk, perhaps mediation can be avoided and there would be no additional costs for you. Additionally, once this all gets worked out, a Final Hearing could be arranged much earlier. She never responded. Oh well, you can lead a horse to water….

48 Wrote Her Parents

I consider myself a stand-up guy. I have no problem standing up to injustices—or getting in front of any messes that include me. Within the Restraining Order paperwork, there was specific mention that I could not contact my in-laws, who lived just 10 minutes away. Four days after the Restraining Order expired, I contacted them. Having known them for more than 30 years, I felt the need to tell my side of the story that included their daughter, my soon to be ex-wife. I cared what they thought and how they viewed me. I didn’t want them to think I had assaulted Veeby and needed to set the record straight. I wrote them a long letter [abridged version below]— reassuring them that I had not physically harmed Veeby. Dear [in-laws]: I apologize for not accepting your phone call several weeks ago. I have not been allowed to contact you until now. You were associated with a Restraining Order placed against me that only expired last Sunday. I have wanted to speak with you many times to express my concern for Veeby and what she is going through. At my last knowledge of her relationship with you both, she had cut ties with you [again]…this is why I escorted you out of the driveway many months ago...at her request and while she watched from the bedroom window. My hope is that she’s reached out to you both during this turbulent time, seeking some healing in your relationship and some emotional support from you. I really hope you have been able to be there for her. As you know, Veeby and I have had our share of ups and downs. I have made decisions in the past that have hurt her...and she has hurt me as well through our time together. I have apologized to you folks for my previous hurts against your daughter. I have gone through much therapy with Veeby in our years together. Veeby and I have grown up together. We have many good memories and lived through many happy times. We have brought three wonderful children into the world...and have loved them fully. Unfortunately, her actions over the last several months have not kept our good times in focus at all, but she seems to only be focusing on our hurts and disagreements. In early November, Veeby made the decision to dissolve our marriage and end our partnership. This was not my decision, but hers. I did not feel at the time that we needed to divorce, but she did. I honored Veeby’s request to have a year of separation and healing by moving into a small one bedroom condo last December. She and I had arranged an amicable separation when I left in December…to give us space to heal. Unfortunately, everything we agreed to was eventually abandoned. Veeby has lashed out in every way possible during the last several months. I have hurt for her, yet have watch her completely disassemble what was our life together. I have consistently told all three children that mom is hurting right now and they need to love on her. I have consistently told the kids that their job is to love on mom, love on dad...and not take sides. In January, Veeby accused me of “physically assaulting” her. Further, claiming that she was “in fear of becoming a victim of domestic violence,” she obtained a Restraining Order against me. You folks have known me for 30 years. You know my heart. I want you to know that I have never physically harmed Veeby...it’s just not something I would ever do...nor have ever done in all our time together. As my in-laws and the parents of my partner of 33+ years, it’s important to me that you know...directly from me...that while Veeby produced pictures of bruises on her forearm to a Judge, I did not touch her in anyway. I have the buddy who helped me move stuff and three police officers who attested to there being no physical assault...just a verbal argument. There is a police report stating the above. If Veeby had bruises, she did not get them from me. I am completely baffled as to exactly what has happened to Veeby. I have been and remain very concerned over all of her recent behaviors. I believe Veeby has been receiving terrible advice and acting on the same. I would never do to her what she’s been doing to me. No matter what Veeby thinks and assumes about me and/or us, I believe her recent behaviors are completely inappropriate, bordering on the bizarre. I say this out of concern, not condemnation. If you are unaware, please contact Veeby immediately...she needs your help. I used to be able to calm her down and disarm her rants, but she no longer wants or allows me to be there for her. I hope you already are in touch with her...if not, please contact her...she needs you. I will continue to love Veeby...for the rest of my life...she is the one distancing from me. However, her recent actions reveal an absolute “I hate his guts” mentality. There’s no reason at all to have done such a horrible thing to our family. She and I agreed to an amicable separation...a year of space and healing...By January 1st, she had retained a lawyer and changed our separation to complete divorce. Even though I taught from the house and had a teaching studio in the house, I honored her request that I be the one to leave as we agreed to go our separate ways…we split up the household bills 55/45…planned on her staying in the house with children to provide consistency…I would continue to teach there and see the children there…but then something happened and things went sideways. I fear that she is in a financially hard time right now, but that would be a direct result of her decision to no longer remain married. I have not been able to speak with her directly since January 11th because of the Restraining Order. This transitional time in our family’s life has been complicated by “no communication.” Again, it is important to me that I contact you folks...simply to express my love for Veeby...and my love for you as well. Veeby was processing a lot with my parents during the last year and I finally asked her to stop, which she did in November. I will honor the unspoken request and not contact you directly; however, my heart’s desire is to drive over to your home and cry with you. Veeby is your daughter and she needs you now, but you have been important in my life as well...I miss you guys, also. Veeby’s decision to no longer partner with me...was entirely her decision. She “withdrew her will” to stay together. I was saddened by her decision, but honored her decision by no longer fighting to keep her. She wrote me many notes of encouragement and love, wishing me well in the future, knowing we’d do divorce “well” like we did life “well.” The events and decisions that Veeby has made since December of last year, have been devastating to me...and the children…and our family. I am simply shocked at the complete untruths she has put forth to the Judge, her lawyer, at mediation, to her CPA consultant, to our household service providers, etc. At this point, I can only imagine what she has told our children. While many around me want me to get mad at Veeby, I only feel sorrow for her. I am her partner [still] and I know she is hurting...and I can not comfort her anymore. • • • • • If you ever have an opportunity to talk to Veeby, please pass along the following on my behalf: Veeby, I am saddened with how you have chosen to end our union. We have loved each other and grown up together. We have many wonderful memories and three beautiful children. I only focus on and honor our good times. I am not focused on our past hurts towards each other. I hope you can get to this place at some point in the future. I have not rejected you…I only honored your request to no longer partner with me. I honor our 33+ years together. I do not feel it’s been a waste of either of our lives. You are part of me—forever. I have always been tender, loving and attentive to you. I have never chosen to purposefully hurt you in any of my actions or decisions. I understand how my actions and decisions have been hurtful to you, but the hurt was never intentional. This is completely different than your most recent purposeful hurts towards me…your punitive and vindictive hurts. I do not hold onto the hurts I’ve endured from you…I am choosing to let those go…so we can be amicable going forward…I wish you the ability to do the same. Despite your beliefs to the contrary, my perspectives are not “all [messed] up”…they are merely different from your point of view…that does not make them wrong. I was hurt beyond words when you claimed I’d physically hurt you…and you sought a Restraining Order against me. You and I both know that I never did the things you’ve stated in the complaint…that was just a game you played to get me out of the house. I will remain connected to you for the rest of my life. I will love you dearly for the rest of my life.

49 She Turned Me In

I had moved from the condo into a new house at the beginning of March. Seven (7) days later, Veeby and I went through our mediation session. We immediately hit a bump in the divorce road. I dealt with lawyers and a bunch of legal stuff for most of that month—gathering documents, generating emails and printing detailed income reports. Additionally, I was still disassembling and moving the new landlord’s belongings out of the house into the garage for storage—and moving my furniture from the garage into the house—basically, trying to get the house all set up. All the while trying to leave a walking path past the boxes and around the furniture for my private students to at least see and get into the house for their piano lessons. Not to mention, Mark and I purchased and assembled furniture for his bedroom at my new place. It was time consuming but very rewarding—all bundled together. Needless to say, I was a little busy. I received a call from the local Occupational Business License office. They’d received a report from a “concerned citizen” [I wonder WHO that might have been?] that my Occupational License—the annual “tribute” I had to cough up to the city in order to teach private lessons from my house—was using false information. They needed me to come downtown and update my information. Oh, yeah…I needed to pay them more money to “transfer” my license to my new address. How petty…REALLY? Veeby turned me in to the city! I’d taught my students at the marital house through February, so it had only been a few weeks since I moved to the new rental house. The next day, I drove over to the Occupational Business License office and spoke to the nice lady behind the front counter. She knew all about me and how I had recently moved into a new location. She confirmed my new address by showing me the yellow post-it note with all my new contact information written down…in Veeby’s handwriting. The nice lady gave me a Transfer of Location form—I paid them $17—and all was well. The world seemingly tilted back upright. Was someone in Veeby’s ear with suggestions or did she come up with that one all by herself? Such a silly act of vindictiveness. I wasn’t deceiving the city. I hadn’t even thought about needing a “transfer” form. My business license renewed every year. I would have simply changed my address a couple of months later when I received the renewal form in the mail. Perhaps this was yet another way of ridding my essence from “her” house? • • • • • A hard but valuable lesson to absorb: Absolutely anyone can turn on you at any time—even your beloved partner—no matter how long the two of you have been together. Too cynical? Nope. It was just a silly Occupational License. A seriously “no harm, no foul” type thing. I wasn’t hurting anybody. It simply wasn’t even on my radar—just Veeby being vindictive. I remembered girls acting like that—back in 6th grade.

50 Taken…Out of School

It was a birthday weekend—Mark was about to turn 12 on Monday! He spent that weekend at my place. We celebrated on Saturday by going to a local food and arcade type place and then saw a movie. The previous week I emailed an invitation to Veeby and Noelle to celebrate Mark’s birthday at a dinner on Sunday evening…my treat: Veeby and Noelle: Next Monday is Mark’s 12th birthday. I would like to invite you two to dinner—at a restaurant—to celebrate Mark’s birthday. Next Sunday evening...my treat. Please RSVP. They never replied. Mark and I talked that Sunday afternoon and decided to not push the subject, so we just let it go and ate at home. I apologized for his sister and mom—that they wouldn’t celebrate his birthday with him. Instead, we made plans to celebrate at Mark’s favorite restaurant Monday evening…on his actual birthday. • • • • • Monday morning…HAPPY BIRTHDAY…and Mark went off to school. I made him his favorite birthday cake for later that evening. As part of a long term photographic project I was working on, I had the kids pictures taken every year around their birthdays. Therefore, I’d made a photo studio appointment for Mark that evening at 6 pm…we would eat afterwards. I moved several of my students around to different days that week so I would have extra time to spend with Mark after school. I only taught one student at 4:00 pm, which would allow me to pick up Mark from school and still make it back for the lesson—then I would be free for the rest of the day. Best laid plans…. While driving over to pick up Mark after school, I received a text from him which said, “I’m with mom for my birthday. She’ll bring me in a bit, okay?” Wait…WHAT? I replied, “Nope...I need to pick you up at the school...stay there, son.” [I began teaching at 4:00 pm]. Mark replied, “I’m at lunch with mom, can she bring me after?”—Whiskey Tango Foxtrot? I immediately texted Veeby, “I need to pick up Mark at the school” to which she replied, “We’re at lunch.” A text from Mark came in, “Okay, we’ll be there in half an hour.” I texted Veeby, “I have made plans already. I have no problem coordinating with you so you can see our son on his birthday, but you just can’t swing by and pick him up without talking to me. You know better, Veeby! Take him back to the school immediately so I can pick him up.” I immediately tried to call Veeby’s cell phone, but she let it ring until the voice mail picked up. I left her a message, again saying I had no problem with her seeing Mark on his birthday, but she just couldn’t swoop down and take him without letting me know. That action clearly placed Mark in the middle between his parents. Another text from Mark came through, “Lunch ran late, sorry. Mom will drop me off at your house though, we can’t get back to the school in time, unfortunately.” I tried to call Veeby again, but this time it went directly to voice mail. I then called Mark directly. He answered and I told him he was being put in the middle…sorry, son, but “Where are you?” He didn’t know—they were on the road somewhere. I asked him to let me speak with his mom—since I couldn’t reach her directly. He said she did not want to speak with me. I told Mark to have her take him to her house and I would pick him up after I taught my 4 pm lesson. Very flustered, I returned home and tried to concentrate while teaching my student. Afterwards, I got back in my car and headed over to pick up Mark. I called Veeby on the way…surprisingly it went straight to voice mail. I texted her, “Is Mark at your house? I am coming to pick him up.” She never replied. I called Mark—he said he was playing basketball in the driveway of her house. I told him I would arrive in a moment and to simply come get into the car. When I arrived, mom kissed him goodbye at the front door of the house, then she quickly locked herself back inside [safety first]. He got into my car without saying a word…smart boy. We went to his portrait appointment—it was good to have some time built in to decompress a little. Afterwards, he said he was too tired from the day to go out to dinner—and wasn’t really hungry—so we came back to my place for a little birthday cake. He then decided to go to bed early that night. • • • • • I later learned Veeby had signed Mark out of school for a “doctor’s appointment” at 9:30 am…[the front office showed me their Sign Out sheet]. She then took him to one of those big arcade places, they had a nice lunch at the mall and then walked around until 3:30 pm. She could have easily “walked” less and had him back to school on time if she’d wanted to. Since Veeby was not communicating, I later asked Mark if he had known beforehand that mom was picking him up? He said, “Yes” and acknowledged that she’d set it up with him before he came to my place for the weekend. I completely understand wanting to see Mark on his birthday…and would have had no problem with Veeby seeing or spending time with Mark. However, the new paradigm required our coordinating and communicating—and probably not missing an entire day of school. I had absolutely no idea that Mark was not in school the Monday of his birthday! Also, Veeby and I had just finished going through mediation and had a clearly outlined time-sharing plan—however minimally worded. How could she justify and rationalize her actions? Veeby’s decision to take Mark out of school for the entire day—without coordinating or communicating with me? It seemed wrong on so many levels. Plus, she didn’t get Mark back to school in time for me to [invisibly] pick him up before I began teaching. She just made her plans with Mark…to my exclusion. She just did what she wanted to do. Thinking as a Southerner, “Isn’t that kinda like one of them there Unilateral Decisions she was crowing about earlier?” I was responsible for Mark on Mondays and Tuesdays. She should have at least had the common courtesy to let me know her plans. In contrast, when I wanted to arrange a therapy appointment for Mark a couple of months before, Veeby created all kinds of hellish rain on that parade. I began to remember our marital mantra: Do things her way or there would be hell to pay. Double Standard! With such an outrageous “I don’t care what’s written in the MSA or what I’ve previously agreed to” behavior, I asked Carol to contact Veeby’s counsel. Not only was Veeby refusing to communicate or Co-Parent, she had begun to use Mark like a pawn in her Game of Divorce. • • • • • After Veeby’s little birthday excursion with Mark, I wrote to the School Resource Officer [police] at Mark’s school to document what I believed to be Custodial Interference: TO: Resource Officer, at Mark’s school FROM: John, parent of Mark RE: Custodial Interference The school has already been made aware of a divorce situation that is on going between the parents of Mark. I am including a copy of the existing Parenting Plan currently in effect, signed by the Judge for the school’s files. I want to simply document my concerns regarding Veeby’s behavior, which indicates her contempt for the above mentioned Order and her overall Custodial Interference. I am not wanting the school to get involved, but rather to just be aware of the sensitive dynamics that are going on for Mark these days. • Veeby withdrew Mark from school last Monday to celebrate his birthday. While this would normally not be an issue, she did not inform me at all. I was not aware that Mark was not in school. I had made arrangements to pick him up from school, since I am responsible for him on Mondays and Tuesdays. She had taken him out of town and was not back until well after school was over. In fact, I was only able to pick up Mark after 5:30 pm at her house. I came to pick up Mark at school, he was not there. Due to her decision, he was not available for my court appointed pick-up. Again, I do not want the school to do anything about this—it is simply in stark contrast to her previous position and conversations with the 6th grade school guidance counselor. • Several weeks ago, at the suggestion of the Judge, I arranged for a psychotherapist appointment for Mark on a Monday during school hours. At that time, Veeby was in contact with the 6th grade school guidance counselor asserting I was not making decisions “in Mark’s best interest.” While I understand these are just code words used for potential legal actions, she’s previously stated that because I was trying to take Mark out of school [during FCAT preparations and potentially during his math class] that I was “making unilateral decisions that are not in the best interest of Mark.” However, it becomes a double standard when she elects to intentionally go against a standing Court Order, withdraw Mark from school—without letting me know—and then not have him available for me to pick up at school per normal. This is just the latest example of her Custodial Interference. • Since Veeby is from France, she threatened to take Mark [and his sister, Noelle] and flee to France. On [date], she went to the French Embassy to update documentation. This absolutely struck terror in my heart. I have secured and placed both boy’s France passports with my lawyer for safe keeping, but this is just an example of her using the kids to hurt me. While I know this will probably sound like just another domestic disturbance and divorce situation to the school system, it is new to me and a very hurtful time. I think it’s being played like a “game” by Veeby…a game with rules I am unfamiliar with and am having to learn as I go. I ask for your patience and understanding as I have always been very involved in Mark’s life and am trying to provide consistency for him during this transitional time in his and my life. Please keep this confidential information within his file. Thank you!

51 Braces

I had braces when I was growing up. Our daughter, Eliana, had gone through the experience. Veeby elected to get braces several years before. Noelle was still in braces, which meant it was Mark’s turn next. Seemingly, a right of passage in our world. Veeby knew it was coming and specifically mentioned the subject during her List of Demands meeting many months prior. Several days after Mark’s birthday, I communicated with Veeby: Veeby, FYI, I have scheduled an initial consultation for Mark with the orthodontist to discuss future options for his teeth. Six (6) days later, he and I went to the appointment. Yep, he needed braces. I told the orthodontist that Veeby and I were both financially responsible…[per our MSA]. They billed me 50% and billed her 50%. I bit the bullet and took care of my portion. I didn’t have the money, but hey, my kid needed braces and that’s why credit cards were invented, right? Several days afterwards, I received a phone call from the ortho-dontist’s office. They’d gotten a call from Veeby, who had received their bill and claimed she never knew about Mark’s appointment—didn’t know until Mark told her—and she didn’t have any money to pay for his braces. Wait…WHAT? How could she make that claim? How could she not know about the appointment when I’d let her know? Golly Gee Willikers—the afternoon after his initial consultation, Veeby called Mark to ask what the orthodontist had said. She wouldn’t have known to call and ask him unless she’d received my previous email. Because Veeby had alerted them to potential money problems, the orthodontist stated they would not begin Mark’s braces unless they knew they would receive her portion. Since we had a long history with this orthodontist—everyone in our family had filed through for braces—they began the initial steps for Mark’s braces as a courtesy. A courtesy, yes, but I had already paid half of the total amount, so at least we could get started. If mom couldn’t pay her portion, Mark may never be able to get the braces taken off, but we’d cross that bridge later in his life. Maybe I could gift him the needed funds as a wedding gift…before the big day. We’d see how it went. Of course, the orthodontist then asked ME to sign a promissory letter to indicate that I would take care of the entire amount due—in case Veeby didn’t pay…and they would then let me wrangle the money from Veeby. I knew that future dental and medical expenses for the children had already been discussed in the Mediated Settlement Agreement we had both signed. Although Veeby was telling the orthodontist she was hurting financially, I also was struggling in the same way. Welcome to Divorce Land. However, this was for Mark! Like me, Veeby was responsible for Mark’s braces, she knew they were coming and she’d simply have to figure out how to make it happen. As the orthodontist took care of our son’s dental needs, I kept Veeby in the loop through emails with attached receipts: Veeby, Please be aware that Mark had his beginning braces put on this morning with the orthodontist. I am attaching a picture of his teeth for your files. The orthodontist needs four of Mark's baby teeth removed in the coming weeks...letter attached. You and I will need to split this expense. Mark was able to pull one of his baby teeth [on the bottom] last night…the tooth fairy has already visited him. Also, I was informed that you still need to make arrangements with the orthodontist’s office regarding your half of Mark’s braces. Please take care of this as soon as possible…since this is in Mark’s best interest. And… Veeby, Mark’s orthodontist has sent an extraction letter to our dentist to remove four of Mark’s baby teeth as part of his orthodontic treatment plan. I have secured an appointment to have this procedure done this coming Friday at 12:30 pm. Since Mark will be at your place overnight on Thursday, please make sure he is ready to be picked up at 11:30 am Friday morning to go to this appointment…[a summer appointment]. I will pick him up at 11:30 am Friday morning. I will pay for both your and my portion of the procedure and I will email you the total amount once I know. You may give me a check for your half of this expense at the next Mediation scheduled for the following week. Finances are tight for me, so I would really appreciate your reimbursing me…for our son. And… Veeby, Mark’s four baby teeth were successfully pulled this afternoon...he’s still numbed up and a little sore, but he survived. The cost for the consultation exam, panoramic x-rays and teeth extracted was $100. Please have a reimbursement check for half this amount at Thursday’s Mediation. [dental receipts attached] And… Veeby, Mark has a teeth cleaning appointment tomorrow morning. His last dental cleaning was [date]. And… Veeby, The orthodontist needs two additional teeth extracted from Mark. Please see the attached pdf file. Since I paid for the last two teeth Mark had extracted, it would be great if you paid for these next two teeth extractions. Then, I would not need reimbursement from you for the previous extractions I’ve already paid for. The Oral Surgeon at our family dentist’s office is only available on Fridays. Please schedule an appointment for Mark for next Friday. Mark is scheduled to be with you on that Friday. The orthodontist wants Mark’s teeth out as soon as possible so the new teeth can drop down and be in place before Mark’s next visit. Please confirm in writing back to me when you have made the appointment. What’s wrong with this email picture so far? It’s one-sided. Where are all the email communications from Veeby? They do not exist. Veeby was completely silent—seemingly gone—as I tried to keep her in the loop regarding Mark’s braces. Perhaps Waldo knew where she was during that time…if someone could simply find him. • • • • • In all fairness, I finally received an email from Veeby, albeit the very first one regarding Mark’s braces—and only eight (8) months after the process had begun. Veeby replied: John, I am not in a financial position to pay for Mark’s teeth extraction. While I was sorry to hear of her financial woes, at least her reply confirmed she was receiving my emails. Hopefully, the ice had been broken and Veeby would then start communicating. I continued to send her email updates as Mark progressed through braces. Unfortunately, no matter how inclusive I tried to be, Veeby never replied or communicated again about Mark’s braces. That made it very hard to Co-Parent anything to do with Mark. There was just a bunch of SILENCE from Veeby’s side of the world. While she may have wanted to erase me from her life, that wasn’t in the best interest of our children, nor a real possibility. There was that whole legal 50/50 time-sharing thing—I was still around. To my amazement, Veeby took Noelle in for a follow-up appointment with the orthodontist. Of course, she never let me know. I only learned they’d gone when the office manager later asked me to pay the fee. Noelle was my daughter and although she was keeping her distance from me, my taking care of that expense was only a small expression of my love for her. You bet, I paid it. • • • • • Eventually, the grace period with the orthodontist office expired. I had been getting their subtle hints to pay them the final amount due. They were well aware that I had already paid my half of Mark’s braces. However, they had waited months for Veeby to make any kind of payment and they wanted the balance due. Subtlety turned into directness—unless they received payment, they would discontinue Mark’s orthodontic work. I went ahead and paid Veeby’s balance due with a different credit card. I knew I would have a hard time getting those funds reimbursed from Veeby, but it was definitely in Mark’s best interest. I was just trying to take care of our son’s dental needs.

52 Who Moved Into "Her" House?

During that time period, I wondered everyday “what was going to happen next?” And I usually didn’t have to wait long for the answer to reveal itself. Right on cue, I received a nice email from a former neighbor. It seemed a moving truck showed up one day and unloaded a bunch of “stuff” into Veeby’s house. It appeared “some people” moved in. I wondered if I was supposed to be informed that other adults were living in the same house with my minor children? I wondered if I should be afforded any civility as Co-Parent? I didn’t know—I just had a bunch of questions about the new development. Unfortunately, based on her lack of communication, Veeby had not been nominated for “Co-Parent of the Year” that particular year! Since Veeby had previously indicated she was hurting financially, I assumed she was renting out a room to help with her expenses—and I was not far off the mark. I eventually learned that her sister and brother-in-law moved in. Suddenly, many potted plants were outlining the house—and a menagerie of birds, ducks, fish, dogs and cats were being housed inside and out. The “marital house” had seemingly been turned into a “farm house.” I hoped the extra rental income would help Veeby with the household expenses. I also hoped there would be a little extra left over each month—to pay some towards Mark’s braces.

53 Veeby's Lawyer #3

Next in line…Number One? Number Two? Number Three? Now serving Number Three? What can I help you with, Honey? Veeby’s previous counsel, #2 Lawyer was GONE. Poof! No reason given or known, she’d just been replaced. No love lost, either. Three days before receiving any notice, we were surprised to “hear about” there being a Lawyer #3…from the mediator’s office. Evidently, as soon as Lawyer #3 began Veeby’s representation, she immediately canceled our long-awaited mediation session. Wait…WHAT? We had been court ordered to attend mediation regarding my motion to clarify the Parenting Plan—and we’d been waiting for two months already. The mediator’s office called Carol to inform her that some new attorney called them‚ claimed to represent Veeby, and tried to cancel the mediation session. Lawyer #3 instructed the mediator to then call Carol and inform us the mediation was canceled. That was not the way things should have happened. Carol had not received any “Notice of Appearance” paperwork and Lawyer #3 did not contact Carol directly. What in the world was going on? I wrote Veeby: Veeby, The mediator’s office called my attorney and said you’ve retained a new lawyer and whomever that new lawyer is has tried to cancel Thursday’s scheduled mediation? There was no discussion of rescheduling…it was just ‘canceled.’ Unfortunately, that’s not the way it works. If you’ve hired a new lawyer [why?], then that lawyer needs to call my lawyer immediately to discuss any issues. It’s improper to not give official notice to my lawyer. Whatever type lawyer you’ve hired needs to file notice with the court, etc. They can’t just call and cancel a court ordered mediation…that we’ve been waiting months for…it doesn’t work that way. So, please have your newest lawyer call my lawyer immediately. This silliness on your part is getting old, Veeby. Let’s just finish up. Within the hour, Lawyer #3 called Carol. All of a sudden, Veeby’s camp was refusing to use that particular mediator—even though she had been the original mediator and the new session had been scheduled for months. Evidently, Veeby felt “uncomfortable” with that mediator. Lawyer #3 said she would get back in touch with some new mediator options. We seriously had some pressing issues that needed to be figured out—and I had been looking forward to addressing them within mediation. I needed clarification on the time-sharing as it related to not only school holidays, but also upcoming summer vacation plans. There was an issue regarding a school bus for Mark that needed to be discussed. Veeby’s lack of communication had placed us squarely in the “High Conflict” divorce category—so we had suggested hiring a “Parental Coordinator” to bridge the communication gap. No Wellness visits and only one therapy session had occurred for Noelle. Both kids had excessive school absences on the days they were with Veeby. There was Custodial Interference and Parental Alienation threads that needed to be dealt with. There were orthodontic reimbursements—and ‘service providers’ that weren’t being paid—and HELOC payments that needed to be addressed. If only we could get to the mediation table. After three days of dealing with some supposed new legal counsel, we finally received the official ORDER APPROVING SUBSTI-TUTION OF COUNSEL, which replaced Lawyer #2 with Lawyer #3. However, the phrase “the third time’s the charm”…was not applicable to #3. Indeed, from my personal interactions with Lawyer #3 throughout the next segment of the divorce journey, I would come to view her as an incompetent idiot—pretending to be a lawyer. In my personal opinion, every letter Lawyer #3 would eventually try to write—was an affront to all intelligent human beings! [He said when asked, “How did she make you feel?”] I loved that movie Dumb and Dumber. The title so aptly described the corner that had just been turned.

54 HELOC