The club folded after the 1970 season, but was revived and renamed the Syracuse Suns. The club folded again after the 1971 season, but was revived again before the 1973 season. The team folded 5 games into the 1974 season and forfeited the rest of their games. A new Scorpions team was announced for the 2011-12 MISL season. The team later announced that it would be called the Syracuse Silver Knights.
|Year||Division||League||Reg. Season||Playoffs||U.S. Open Cup|
|1969||2||ASL||1st, Northern||Final||Did not enter|
|1970||2||ASL||4th||No playoff||Did not enter|
|1971||2||ASL||4th||No playoff||Did not enter|
|1973||2||ASL||4th, Northeast||Did not qualify||Did not enter|
|1974||2||ASL||5th, Midwest||Did not qualify||Did not enter|