Cover of McCall's magazine (1911)
Categories Women's magazine
Frequency Monthly
Founder James McCall
First issue  1873 (1873-month)
Final issue 2002
Country United States
ISSN 1060-1201

McCall's was a monthly American women's magazine that enjoyed great popularity through much of the 20th century, peaking at a readership of 8.4 million in the early 1960s. It was established as a small-format magazine called The Queen in 1873. In 1897 it was renamed McCall's Magazine—The Queen of Fashion (later shortened to McCall's) and subsequently grew in size to become a large-format glossy. It was one of the "Seven Sisters" group of women's service magazines.

McCall's published fiction by such well-known authors as Alice Adams, Ray Bradbury, Gelett Burgess, Willa Cather, Jack Finney, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Barbara Garson, John Steinbeck, Tim O'Brien, Anne Tyler and Kurt Vonnegut.


From June 1949 until her death in November 1962, Eleanor Roosevelt wrote a McCall's column, "If You Ask Me". The former First Lady gave brief answers to questions sent in to the magazine.[1]

Starting in May 1951, and lasting until at least 1995,[2] Betsy McCall paper dolls were printed in most issues. Children could cut out the printed dolls and clothing, or for a small fee (10¢ in 1957, 25¢ in 1967) paper dolls printed on cardboard could be ordered. Betsy McCall became so popular that various sized vinyl dolls were produced by Ideal and American Character Dolls.[3]

Another popular feature which ran for many years was the cartoon panel "It's All in the Family" by Stan and Jan Berenstain. A pair of pioneering female illustrators, Jesse Willcox Smith and Neysa McMein, drew dozens of McCall's cover portraits.

Film critic Pauline Kael worked at McCall's from 1965 to 1966, and was reportedly fired after writing a highly unfavorable review of The Sound of Music.[4]

Sewing patterns and The Queen of Fashion

In 1870, Scottish immigrant James McCall began designing and printing his own line of sewing patterns.[5] As a means of advertising his patterns, McCall founded a four-page fashion journal entitled The Queen: Illustrating McCall's Bazaar Glove-Fitting Patterns.[6]

When McCall died in 1884, his widow became president of McCall Company, and hired Mrs. George Bladsworth as magazine editor. Mrs. Bladsworth held the position until 1891. Though still mainly a vehicle to sell McCall's sewing patterns, The Queen began to publish homemaking and handiwork information, and by 1890 had expanded to 12 pages.[7] In 1891, the magazine's name became The Queen of Fashion, and the cost for a year's subscription was 30 cents.

In 1893, James Henry Ottley took over the McCall Company. He increased the subscription price to 50 cents a year, increased the number of pages to between 16 and 30 per issue, and began to publish articles on children's issues, health, beauty, and foreign travel.[7] In order to reflect the magazine's expanded range of topics, the name was changed to McCall's Magazine—The Queen of Fashion in 1897. In time, the name would be shortened to McCall's.

Despite the name changes, for many years information on McCall's patterns filled an average of 20 percent of the magazine's pages.[8]

McCall's Magazine

Fashion 1916 in McCall's

In 1913, the magazine was purchased by the banking firm of White Weld & Co., which organized the McCall Corporation under the direction of president Edward Alfred Simmons. In 1917, the price was raised to 10 cents per issue.[7] In 1922, Harry Payne Burton became editor, and for the first time such well-known fiction writers as Kathleen Norris, Harold Bell Wright, Zane Grey and Booth Tarkington had stories published in McCall's.[7]

In 1928, the 23-year-old associate editor, Otis Wiese, was promoted to editor. He believed "women were ready for more significant fiction than Gene Stratton-Porter" and suggested that McCall's sell Burton's acquisitions of popular fiction to Ladies Home Journal and Woman's Home Companion. Such radical ideas caused Wiese to be fired at least six times within his first year as editor, but he was always rehired because, as he put it, "there was no one else around the place with ideas."[9]

McCall's Homemaking cover (1938): Jinx Falkenberg

In 1932, Wiese changed the format to what he called Three Magazines in One. Three sections—News and Fiction, Homemaking, Style and Beauty—had their own cover, and each contained ads tailored to its contents.[10] A survey was conducted that showed fiction was a major attraction for female magazine readers, and in 1937 McCall's became the first women's magazine to print a complete novel in one issue.[11]

Pearl Harbor was attacked on December 7, 1941, and Otis Wiese immediately revamped the February 1942 issue then in preparation. A frilly valentine cover was replaced with a woman wearing an "I've Enlisted" consumer pledge button. Readers were asked to sign a pledge that stated "As a consumer, in the total defense of democracy, I will do my part to make my country ready, efficient and strong. I will buy carefully. I will take good care of the things I have. I will waste nothing." Within three weeks, 150,000 readers signed the pledge and sent in a coupon printed in the magazine. During World War II, all women's magazines took on a patriotic slant, but McCall's received much positive press coverage for being the first magazine to do so[12] McCall's began a "Washington Newsletter" section, which provided information on rationing and conservation.[13]

During the post-war era, fiction was no longer such an important draw for readers; they wanted more articles and picture spreads. To provide lively nonfiction Wiese hired two former Look magazine editors. Daniel Danforth Mich became editorial director, and Henry Ehrlich was named managing editor.[14]

McCall's Three Magazines in One format was discontinued in 1950.[13] In 1954 Wiese began to reformat McCall's with a "Togetherness" slogan; it was announced that the magazine would no longer be just for women, but aimed at the entire family. During this time period paid circulation was 4.5 million per issue.[15]

In 1953, financier Norton Simon began purchasing shares of McCall Corporation, and in 1956, Simon's group of investors was in control of the corporation.[13]

In 1958, Simon named Arthur B. Langlie as president of the company. Otis Wiese, who had been vice president, as well as editor and publisher of McCall's, had expected to be named president. When Langlie was named to the position, Wiese and a number of staffers resigned in protest.[7] A Business Week article stated "The house of togetherness had come apart at the seams."[16] Simon replaced Wiese with Herbert Mayes, who had been editor of Good Housekeeping.[13]

Mayes did away with the "Togetherness" slant, and came up with a new slogan, "First Magazine For Women."[7] He introduced additional color pages, and used more fiction. In 1962 Mayes became president and CEO of McCall Corporation.[17]

From 1962 to 1965, John Mack Carter was editor of McCall's. Under his leadership, circulation rose to 8.4 million.[13] In 1965, Carter left to become editor of Ladies' Home Journal. A rapid succession of editors followed Carter, including Robert Stein and James Fixx.[7]

In 1969, Life magazine columnist Shana Alexander was named editor. Alexander had no editing experience, and at the time of her appointment stated "I have to educate myself about women's magazines, but I think I know something about women."[18] Alexander left in 1971.

Robert Stein was editor from 1972 to 1986. During Stein's tenure, McCalls gained the slogan / subtitle "The Magazine for Suburban Women."[13] After Stein left, the quick turnover of editors returned.

Change in ownership

Ownership of McCall's began to change nearly as fast as editors came and went. Norton Simon sold McCall's to private owners in 1973. In 1986, McCall's Publishing Company was bought by Time Inc. and Lang Communications. In 1989, McCall's was sold to The New York Times Company, and in 1994, German-based Gruner + Jahr announced plans to purchase their magazine business.[19]

Change to Rosie

In 2000, entertainer Rosie O'Donnell became editorial director of McCall's.[20] In 2001 McCall's was renamed Rosie.[21] O'Donnell stated, "I wanted a magazine that celebrates real women, that understands that they care about more than waistlines or the latest makeup styles or fashions, that they want to be relevant and help each other and care about the world."[20] Rosie ceased publication at the end of 2002. O'Donnell said in a statement "I decided I could not participate in a magazine that bears my name when I could not be assured it would reflect my vision, values and editorial direction."[22] A highly publicized legal battle between O'Donnell and her publisher, Gruner + Jahr, began in 2003. Ultimately, the judge ruled against both sides and dismissed the case. Gruner + Jahr exited the U.S. magazine business in 2005, selling its women's magazine portfolio to the Meredith Corporation and its business magazine portfolio to Mansueto Ventures. Donald Trump has criticized the transition.


  1. McCall's 100th Anniversary Issue. April 1976.
  2. The Bleu Door Betsy McCall Paper Doll Website, see External Links
  3. Twentieth Century Dolls From Bisque to Vinyl, Johana Gast Anderton, 1974.
  4. "Pauline Kael, Provocative and Widely Imitated New Yorker Film Critic, Dies at 82", in the September 4, 2001 The New York Times
  5. La Dolce Vintage website
  6. Women's Periodicals in the United States—Consumer Magazines, by Kathleen L. Endres and Theresa L. Luech, Greenwood Publishing Group, 1995
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Women's Periodicals in the United States—Consumer Magazines
  8. McCall's Magazine—The Queen of Fashion, Oct. 1909, McCall's Magazine, Aug. 1914, Jan. 1915, May, 1916
  9. The Press: Man In a Woman's World, in the January 6, 1947, Time Magazine
  10. The Press: Man in a Woman's World, in the January 6, 1947 Time magazine
  11. A History of Popular Women's Magazines in the United States, 1792–1995 by Mary Ellen Zuckerman, Greenwood Press, 1998
  12. Women's War, in the March 7, 1942 Business Week magazine
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 A History of Popular Women's Magazines in the United States, 1792–1995
  14. The Press: To the Ladies, in the September 11, 1950 Time magazine
  15. Magazines in the United States, Second Edition, by James Playsted Wood, The Ronald Press Company, 1956
  16. Rival Women's Magazines Near Hair-Pulling Stage, in the October 1, 1960 Business Week magazine
  17. Herbert Mayes, 87, a Former Top Editor of Magazines, Dies, in the November 1, 1987 The New York Times
  18. Lady At the Top, in the April 28, 1969 Newsweek magazine
  19. A History of Popular Women's' Magazines in the United States, 1792–1995
  20. David E. Sumner (2010). The Magazine Century: American Magazines Since 1900. Peter Lang. p. 214. ISBN 978-1-4331-0493-0. Retrieved August 19, 2015.
  21. Rosie Pulls Plug on Her Own Magazine, see External Links
Wikimedia Commons has media related to McCall's Magazine.
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 10/30/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.